15 ms·
Headlines about Supreme Court cases are almost uniformly misleading, because they suggest the Court is making decisions on policy issues rather than legal issue
by rayiner 4y ago
Headlines about Supreme Court cases are almost uniformly misleading, because they suggest the Court is making decisions on policy issues rather than legal issues.
The very first words of the opinion, on p. 2, make clear that the legal issue before the Court is very different: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-1530_n758.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-1530_n758.pdf
The Clean Air Act does not purport to give the EPA blanket regulatory authority over anything involving emissions into the air. It has detailed provisions focused on reducing the amount of toxic pollutants, in particular through the use of control (scrubbing) technologies. This case concerns whether the EPA can use its power to impose control technologies on power plants, to force the industry to use a particular mix of power generation sources (solar, gas, etc.). The Court decided that the statute did not confer on the EPA the power to do that. The relevant discussion begins on page 16.
This decision gives legs to something that has been called the "major questions doctrine." The gist of that doctrine is that an agency can't stretch some pre-existing grant of Congressional authority to create sweeping regulations addressing a major new problem. As applied here, that means that the EPA can't rely on authority delegated by Congress to, for example, tell coal plants what kind of scrubbers they have to use, to tackle climate change. pp. 17-19.
- Workaccount2 4y agoSo the EPA is kneecapped since they have to go through the most ineffective and hyper partisan congress since the founding of the country.
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoYes the EPA, created by congress and given a mandate by congress, must go to congress if it wasn't new powers or authorities....
- politician 4y agoAnd yet, fixing that problem -- the problem of the ineffectiveness and hyper-partisanship of Congress -- would have so many positive effects for all of our lives regardless of our ideological perspectives that it should be our number one priority as the electorate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kmeisthax 4y agoThe ineffectiveness and hyperpartisanship of Congress is directly attributable to the ideological perspectives of the electorate. Also, Congress is not as ineffective and hyperpartisan as you think. It's only on issues that have public attention that they act this way. When nobody is looking they move quickly and decisively.
- themaninthedark 4y agoSo true, see the Patriot Act, DMCA and all the anti-network Neutrality bills.
- JauntTrooper 4y agoEliminating partisan gerrymandering would go a long way. Less than 10% of congressional districts this year will be competitive (defined as the most recent presidential election margin was within 10 percentage points). Only 41 seats! I haven’t really seen a realistic plan to do it though.
- zajio1am 4y agoOTOH, results of elections to congress (house of representatives) looks balanced - total seats gained by each party matches popular vote with deviation < 1%. Which is much better than i expected considering single-seat system leads to advantages for dominant players even without gerrymandering. Even in my home country, which is european country with proportional system and no gerrymandering, such deviation is higher (< 2%) due to rounding effects. Gerrymandering is main issue in (some) state elections (e.g. Wisconsin 2018 is egregious example), not federal elections.
- JauntTrooper 4y agoThe totals are a little misleading because there is partisan gerrymandering on both sides, so they somewhat balance each other out. Courts have also been highly involved in rejecting the most brazenly disproportionate maps, but that may soon change next year due to the newly constituted Supreme Court. The bigger problem is that it incentivizes partisanship and extremist views in uncompetitive districts because the representative is effectively decided in the party’s primary election, not the general election which has higher turnout and a more representative electorate. Also the fact that 90%+ of congressional seats are safe except for the occasional primary opponent discourages accountability. Our districts are so distorted, they make no geographic sense. And it means a large percentage of our population is permanently disenfranchised, which dampens voter participation. It really is one of the biggest structural problems of our democracy right now.
- dfxm12 4y agoThat's the strategy of the Federalist Society, make rulings via the undemocratic SCOTUS under the guise of giving states/congress power, but then also making sure that state elections are undemocratic via gerrymandering, voting laws, etc. It doesn't help that taking action on matters of national importance is inherently difficult in a Federalist government.
- mistrial9 4y agofrom Wikipedia '... The Federalist Society provides its 70,000 members with "intellectual sparring and professional grooming.' without taking sides on this attorney gang, it seems to be like a bunch of professional boxers and others here are mad because they cannot fight. I do not want to fight lawyers, but calling them a conspiracy, when they specifically engage and practice debate professionally, is sort of pathetic honestly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- robonerd 4y ago> but calling them a conspiracy, when they specifically engage and practice debate professionally, is sort of pathetic honestly. Debating professionally precludes conspiracy? What if a high-school debate club decides to rob a bank?
- sterlind 4y agoI grew up going to FedSoc. officially, it's just a debate society - the panels are streamed on CSPAN, it's all public. unofficially, it's a Mecca of networking for conservative lawyers. the upper echelons are nearly exclusively Catholics, and the founder provided Trump with shortlists of Justices he could pick from. and all that networking made it happen. it's no coincidence all the recent nominees are Catholic.
- mistrial9 4y agoas an aside it is actually sort of humorous to describe the center of bunches of Catholic Attorneys as Mecca
- giantg2 4y agoDo you have a source for that claim? I find it hard to believe that partisan conduct didn't exist on the hot topics of the day throughout history. For example, it took years to create a constitution, then more years for a bill of rights. There was a lot of federalist vs anti-federalist debate. Then things like slavery, segregation, etc. I mean, we fought a civil war. How much more partisan can it get than that?
- thehappypm 4y agoWe used to admit states to the Union in pairs so that there was an equal number of free and slave states. THAT is partisanship.
- blowski 4y agoPerhaps there is a hyper-partisan congress because it’s a reaction to what some have viewed as a hyper-partisan Supreme Court. On a positive reading, the Court is now saying states have the right to choose these issues for themselves. There are means in the constitution for overruling a minority of states, that is by passing a constitutional amendment. By allowing and even encouraging the Court to make these decisions, Congress has built up a democratic deficit which has exploded in its face. On a negative reading, sadly, the Court is just as partisan now but in the other direction. Thus the deficit won’t go away.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoThe previous court was conservative on a linear scale. The current court is radically conservative with fascist imperialist theological trends becoming more apparent by the day.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- themaninthedark 4y agoThe EPA is under the executive branch, they should not "have to go through congress" for anything. That is entirely out of their scope of operation. They are supposed to be enforcing and upholding the laws that congress enacts.
- mlindner 4y agoThe Executive branch is not a king. They cannot make new laws. We live in a democracy.
- SllX 4y agoWell there was once a Congress that passed the Missouri Compromise which institutionalized hyper-partisanship and another that was so ineffective its successor Congress literally fell apart when several States seceded from the Union and those States then went to War with the Union. So, cut the hyperbole. Partisanship has always been a political reality. The EPA is capped to the powers that Congress gave it, and does not have the autonomy to expand that power at will because they’re subordinate to the President and the President cannot unilaterally and legally make laws on his own, nor can any of the agencies which answer to him.
- egg1 4y agoI fear what a lot of what outspoken "progressive" types (and yes, before anyone asks, also the MAGA crowd) want is a CCP-style political system as long as they're the ones in control. Concepts like separation of powers and rule of law are merely obstacles to smash through on their road to utopia.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoFew progressives want sprawling bureaucracy. Rather, that’s typically what we get out of social safety nets due to conservative sabotaging of the process and text.
- SllX 4y agoSprawling bureaucracy is a byproduct of what you get from investing the government with additional functions. Every office you open whether Civil Rights or Agriculture or Patent Office needs staff. If we had a single payer system, there would necessarily be an enormous bureaucracy attached to it, most likely an expansion of the existing Medicare/Medicaid bureaucracy. You just don’t get one without the other, even if you cut the staff down to the bare minimum that can still efficiently manage government programs you still end up with a sprawling bureaucracy.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y ago
- matthewdgreen 4y agoThis case could have been decided either way. The result clearly depends on the makeup of the Court and the justices' personal inclinations. As evidence: a very similar question was decided by the Court in 2009, with a completely different result [1]. [1] https://ballotpedia.org/Massachusetts_v._Environmental_Protection_Agency https://ballotpedia.org/Massachusetts_v._Environmental_Prote...
- lolinder 4y agoThis doesn't make OP's point less true: the headlines surrounding this decision are misleading. This is not judicial overreach, it's an application of a different theory of judicial review than we've become accustomed to, and it's not necessarily a bad one. If we don't like it when the police creatively interpret laws to target minorities, can we allow the EPA the authority to creatively interpret laws to target fossil fuel companies? Is it possible to give the executive authorities the power to be creative, but only in the service of a good cause? This Supreme Court believes it's not, and that seems like a reasonable position to take.
- LargeWu 4y ago"A different theory of legal review" which here means coming to a predetermined policy decision, and then inventing legal justification for it, no matter how flimsy.
- lolinder 4y agoI've had plenty of educated, well-informed individuals make exactly the same legal arguments to me for decades. Whether or not I agree with the reasoning, it's not hard for me to believe that the Supreme Court justices believed the principles they're following long before they arrived at this decision. You can disagree with the legal justification, but that you disagree is not evidence that it was invented to achieve a specific goal.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y ago
- evanpw 4y ago> Headlines about Supreme Court cases are almost uniformly misleading, because they suggest the Court is making decisions on policy issues rather than legal issues. I agree with this completely, but it doesn't help when justices begin their opinion / concurrence / dissent with a long policy discussion before talking about the legal questions. That's been the case in several of the recent decisions.
- waffleiron 4y ago> This case concerns whether the EPA can use its power to impose control technologies on power plants, to force the industry to use a particular mix of power generation sources (solar, gas, etc.). Dissenting opinion quotes the following, which to me (and at least one supreme court judge) does not seem to limit this power: > “the degree of emission limitation achievable through the application of the best system of emission reduction which (taking into account the cost of achieving such reduction and any nonair quality health and environmental impact and energy requirements) the [EPA] Administrator determines has been adequately demonstrated.” §7411(a)(1).
- xyzzyz 4y agoThe headlines aren’t entirely wrong. If you look at the conservative majority opinions, you’ll find that indeed, it’s about the relevant legal issues, ie. what the law actually says. On the other hand, if you read liberal dissents, they’re mostly about what they think appropriate policy should be. In this particular case, the majority opinion starts off by quoting the relevant statute and analyzing its meaning, whereas the dissent starts off by saying (quoting) that “climate change is the most pressing environmental challenge of our time”, and continues with a long litany of how bad it is. Really, I find the entire thing to be rather crazy: if the Congress wants EPA to regulate emissions the way they tried to do, all it needs to do is to pass a law explicitly instructing it to do so. Of course, it won’t, because there is no political will in Congress to pass this. At the same time, the EPA’s argument in this case was that the Congress has already delegated this to EPA. Considering that the Congress won’t pass a law confirming that yes, it did in fact delegate authority to execute these particular regulations (which, again, would render the entire SCOTUS decision irrelevant), I find the EPA’s argument of rather dubious quality.
- belltaco 4y agoTrivially disproven by https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31940815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31940815
- JamesBarney 4y agoThe roe v Wade decision seemed to follow a similar pattern with the conservative opinion being about how there isn't really a basis for a constitutional right to an abortion up to viability (seems true) and the liberal dissenting opinion was about how the decision was going to be bad for women (also true) and how this opens up the floodgates to reversing a lot of other important supreme court decisions ( not sure how true that is)
- TylerE 4y agoI’m waiting for the first lawsuit against the DEA. What in the constitution gives the right for the Fedwral Government to regulate what we voluntarily put in our bodies or grow in our back yards?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoYou don’t get say civil asset forfeiture from simply reading the constitution and ruling based on it. Cases make it to the Supreme Court because the outcome is ambiguous, so the court can’t actually make decisions based on an objective standard. It’s simply not how they operate in this or any other court. Instead the outcome is decided and various legal justifications are provided by both the justices who agree and those who disagree. You can agree or disagree with the outcome of any case, but there’s a reason the appointment of Supreme Court justices is considered so politically important, it’s a political job.
- JeremyNT 4y ago> Headlines about Supreme Court cases are almost uniformly misleading, because they suggest the Court is making decisions on policy issues rather than legal issues. This is the naive version of how SCOTUS works that they teach us in elementary school. History has shown that the Supreme Court is a political body with its own political agenda. The doctrine and precedent cited is used as a justification for whatever policy they actually want to enact. Yes, there are some guidelines and guardrails, but this is a case of the tail wagging the dog. They choose their interpretation of law based on the actual impact they want to have on society.
- philwelch 4y agoThe majority of justices on the current Supreme Court have been doing a good job of sticking to the law rather than attempting to enact policy. What you’re describing is a good criticism of the mid-20th century Supreme Court, but the current Court has done a good job of rolling back those excesses.
- plandis 4y ago> The majority of justices on the current Supreme Court have been doing a good job of sticking to the law rather than attempting to enact policy. _in your opinion_, you mean?
- rat87 4y agoHave you seen the Dobbs decision? It's about what policies the judges personally prefer
- SllX 4y agoThe one that returns the decision to make policy on a controversial subject matter back to the people and their elected representatives, per the opinion of the Court?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI personally like the Roe standard, but it was made out whole cloth constitutionally.
- Spooky23 4y agoSure, whatever. These guys are great at espousing some high minded principle that happens to fit into whatever the desired outcome happens to be. These reactionaries represent the dead hand of a generation of people who control or seek to control to guide society to meet their own generational/dynastic wealth and power goals. I’m sure you’ll feel differently as the assaults on the 14th amendment continue and things like the right to privacy are whittled down to a nub.
- robonerd 4y agoIf recent SCOTUS decisions are a dead generation reaching out of the grave to get their way in the end against the united consensus of the living, then the living should have no trouble sorting Congress out and getting the right laws and amendments passed the proper way. Of course, the truth is that living generations are not nearly so united against this as you seem to be suggesting. There certainly isn't enough consensus to pass any amendments. It's not really the dead hand of a bygone generation doing this, it's people who are still very much alive and relevant who disagree with you.
- Spooky23 4y agoThe more reactionary elements are very concerned and talk openly about things like replacement theory as a call to action. It’s a prime motivation for some of the more extreme positions and differentiates the 2020 right winger from a 1980 conservative.
- iostream24 4y agoThe whole concept of a corporate fourth estate informing a populace how to vote contrary to their own interests is surely a major problem our founders weren’t considering very heavily, given the media of the time. I can’t imagine the World War generations silently watching Tucker give aid and comfort to Putin either…
- robonerd 4y agoI can see how corporate influence might play a role in this EPA decision, but most of the ire being thrown at SCOTUS recently is about abortion and I don't see any clear corporate pro-life consensus. On the contrary, I expect most corporations want to keep abortion legal to protect their workforce. > I can’t imagine the World War generations silently watching Tucker give aid and comfort to Putin either… Yes, the world war generations had trouble with the principle of free speech; for instance, arresting people for protesting the draft during the first world war: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States And do I need to remind you of the mass internment of Japanese Americans, convicted of no crimes, during the second world war? I like to think we've made some progress since then.
- rat87 4y agoThat is because that's what they do. The supreme court is a political organ making very conservative political decisions. Much of the time the sort of headlines you seem to prefer would be navel gazing that's not important to most people and would be misleading distract from the real world result that it's gutting much of the EPAs powers? Why because conservatives don't like the EPA. I applaud the headline for getting at the truth of the matter
- burkaman 4y agoRead the dissent and see if you don't find it equally convincing. Supreme Court justices are very smart and very good at their jobs and it's not surprising that pretty much everything they write sounds reasonable and well-argued. Key quote from the dissent: > Section 111 of the Clean Air Act directs EPA to regulate stationary sources of any substance that “causes, or contributes significantly to, air pollution” and that “may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or welfare.” So, does CO2 qualify, or is it a "major new problem"? Sounds like a policy issue to me. By the way, it definitely isn't a major new problem, the Nixon administration viewed CO2 and climate change as settled science in the 60s before he signed the Clean Air Act: https://www.nixonlibrary.gov/sites/default/files/virtuallibrary/documents/jul10/56.pdf https://www.nixonlibrary.gov/sites/default/files/virtuallibr...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoSo you would be fine with the EPA regulating marijuana?
- burkaman 4y agoIf they had convincing scientific evidence that marijuana both contributes significantly to air pollution and endangers public health, yes I would be. Edit: Actually I think the particular Clean Air Act section in question only covers buildings or other "stationary sources", so I don't think marijuana would qualify unless a building was emitting marijuana smoke.
- robonerd 4y agoThat sounds like technocracy, not democracy.
- burkaman 4y agoWhy? This authority was intentionally granted by a democratic legislature. If it's too broad, the act can be amended. The "technocrats" are only in control of what we have voted to let them control. The text is pretty straightforward: > The Administrator shall, within 90 days after December 31, 1970, publish (and from time to time thereafter shall revise) a list of categories of stationary sources. He shall include a category of sources in such list if in his judgment it causes, or contributes significantly to, air pollution which may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or welfare. That is explicitly delegating these decisions to the judgement of the EPA Administrator. This is extremely normal, every government agency works like this.
- radley 4y ago> The gist of that doctrine is that an agency can't stretch some pre-existing grant of Congressional authority to create sweeping regulations addressing a major new problem. But it's not a major new problem. The Congress that established the EPA granted the "stretching" along with it, otherwise it would take an act of Congress to determine the color of the Post-its. The new rulings are farcical zealotry. Apparently, the only people capable of making decisions died 100 years ago and anything we've learned after the Civil War doesn't matter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrguyorama 4y agoAh yes, this is all perfectly above board. It just so happens that after a huge amount of horse shit by the republican party to appoint certain specific justices, there are immediately perfect test cases to put everything exactly the way they want it. No. This was planned, planned very in advance, planned in the open. The republican party has openly wanted to do this for decades, put a plan in motion and executed very well. It is obvious that these justices are completely beholden to the republican party, and should be seen as such. We can play all the dumb semantics games we want, but none of that changes that the Supreme court is part of the US government, that their decisions have broad consequences, and that those consequences are obvious. If you do "the right thing" and it leads to millions of people oppressed when "the wrong thing, or nothing at all" would have led to zero suffering, did you really do the right thing?
- carabiner 4y agoWhy does HN, or SWEs in general, have a libertarian / small govt bias?
- thehappypm 4y agoBecause everyone here is a phony. Everyone publicly wants socialism, and privately wants to protect their own assets.
- jhgb 4y agoEngineering woo effect, perhaps? https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Engineers_and_woo https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Engineers_and_woo
- sterlind 4y agoeven Scalia thought Thomas was a kook for inventing the "major questions doctrine." where in the Constitution can you find this? separation of powers, apparently, if you're looking through a seer stone in a hat at some golden tablets. the majority invented the doctrine to neuter Federal agencies.