9 ms·
What’s interesting about this ruling (if you listened to the oral arguments and read the ruling) is that it appears to undercut the ability for any executive ag
by gumby 4y ago
What’s interesting about this ruling (if you listened to the oral arguments and read the ruling) is that it appears to undercut the ability for any executive agency to make a rule, under them claim that congress cannot delegate its powers.
So the FAA can’t determine and then require that aircraft have transponders. Congress has to do this.
If they continue down this path it will be chaos.
- Miner49er 4y agoI don't think this is correct. Congress can definitely delegate its power, they are just saying that Congress didn't delegate the power the EPA is trying to use in this case. From the final paragraph of the opinion: "But it is not plausible that Congress gave EPA the authority to adopt on its own such a regulatory scheme in Section 111(d). A decision of such magnitude and consequence rests with Congress itself, or an agency acting pursuant to a clear delegation from that representative body." So it seems that Congress can still give the EPA a more clear delegation that they have this power.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoHow do you write an entire opinion about delegation without mentioning Chevron? As the dissent points out, that delegation is inherently required to do the EPA's job and the court has previously accepted their technical and policy expertise in this area.
- cryptonector 4y agoYou would think they would have reversed Chevron, or distinguished it. But note, I've not read this decision yet, and I'm taking your word for their not mentioning Chevron.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoI wonder if the conservative majority will use these recent decisions as precedent to overturn Chevron in what would be another shocking and shameless display of legislating from the bench.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoMaybe I missed something between reading and ctrl-f, but it's only mentioned in the dissent as far as I can tell.
- gnicholas 4y agoThe Court has been dodging Chevron of late. This is their second opinion this month where they conspicuously avoided mentioning Chevron: https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/court-side-steps-overturning-chevron-4540148/ https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/court-side-steps-overturni...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elmerfud 4y agoI don't agree it will be chaos. Congress has for far too long abdicated what it is supposed to be directly responsible for to unelected bureaucrats that exist in agencies that are overseen by the executive branch of government. Congress is now free to focused on creating chaos between the people that elect them. When is the last time you've seen anyone from Congress campaign on any substantive issue? I've not seen it in my lifetime they leave that campaign up to the president. Congress is invested with the sole power to regulate our money when is the last time you've seen them do anything except throw up bloated budgets? They have completely advocated that power to the Federal reserve of which they exercise zero oversight of and apparently leave it to the president who also lets it run autonomously. So what you call chaos is reconnecting the actual responsibilities of our elected representatives with their duties. I for one would very much enjoy seeing my elected representative actually doing their constitutional duties instead of pitting citizen that one another's throat in order to get reelected again.
- wkearney99 4y agohave you met any congress personnel? fence posts would be insulted to be compared to some of them. there's definitely a gap between regulatory officials making regulations and legislature codifying the details. This is where appointing heads of those departments is supposed to come to bear. It's a mess, but the answer isn't to let lobbyists and special interests burn the house down.
- cryptonector 4y agoIt's not like the regulators are incorruptible. The regulators get captured all the time. I don't know what the right answer is here.
- burkaman 4y agoThe right answer here is that Congress explicitly delegated a decision to the EPA administrator, so they should be allowed to make that decision. The court's decision is well-argued, but it seems to come down to "I know Congress said you could do this, but it's a really big deal and they might not have thought it through enough, so you have to go ask for permission again before you do it". It's kind of patronizing to both the EPA and Congress, and I don't think it's a good decision or precedent.
- jibe 4y agoThat is silly hyperbolic overreaction. The court literally upheld the EPA regulating greenhouse gasses at the point of creation. It upheld the specific regulations how coal was burned. All it said was the EPA wasn't empowered to move into grid management schemes. If congress wants to grant them that power, it can.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrekandre 4y ago> it appears to undercut the ability for any executive agency to make a rule, under them claim that congress cannot delegate its powers. this had been a goal for a long time, since even before goldwater... its called "deconstruction of the administrative state" (steve bannons phrase)
- gnicholas 4y agoI read this differently (and am a former lawyer who worked on administrative law). This is about the "major questions doctrine", which involves a subset of administrative actions. It's not about whether administrative agencies can do anything whatsoever. > Under this body of law, known as the major questions doctrine, given both separation of powers principles and a practical understanding of legislative intent, the agency must point to “clear congressional authorization” for the authority it claims. The reasoning for this is that: > We presume that “Congress intends to make major policy decisions itself, not leave those decisions to agencies
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gumby 4y ago> That is silly hyperbolic overreaction. Darn, my interpretation is shown to be naïve by someone who actually has the specific relevant experience! Joking aside, thanks for your comment.
- giantg2 4y agoI didn't see the claim that they can't delegate. The issue I saw discussed is whether or not a specific power was delegated. I don't see rhem invalidating all agency regulations. I do see them requiring better definitions to support that regulation. (Eg C02 was not considered a pollutant under the original grant of power, so the court doesn't want to interpret it to be inclusive).