11 ms·
The saddest thing about Mathematica is that despite the incredible level of effort invested into it by some of the smartest people on the planet, it will inevit
by jiggawatts 4y ago
The saddest thing about Mathematica is that despite the incredible level of effort invested into it by some of the smartest people on the planet, it will inevitably be relegated to the dustbin of history.
As a proprietary language and kernel, it can never compete long-term with open source alternatives.
It's one thing to have a proprietary product, but for decades now proprietary languages have been a no-go for practically everyone. Even formerly closed languages have been opened sourced, such as Java and C#.
There is no other use for Wolfram Language scripts outside of Mathematica, which comes with a "license server". That's... a dead end.
Can I publish Wolfram code in Docker Hub and expect it to work (legally)? No.
Can I throw some Wolfram code into an Azure Function and have it compute something for me on demand? Nope.
Can I embed Wolfram code into a C# app, publish it on GitHub, and have other people be able to use it without forking out $thousands for a Mathematica license? Nope!
And on and on...
Python, Julia, and Jupyter notebooks will simply wipe out all usage of Mathematica outside of a few esoteric fields. As you said, they're all markedly inferior in almost every way, except for one critical one: they're open and extensible.
You mentioned AI/ML having stopped dead in Mathematica. I noticed that too. I wanted to test some GPU-hosted ML stuff recently that's not the standard Pytorch/Tensorflow type of thing, checked Mathematica, gave up, and I'm now using Julia.
If Mathematica was more open, there would be no "dead end" there, I could simply extend it. Or more importantly, other people would have already.
- bowsamic 4y agoI'll believe it when I see it, because right now there is no alternative. I wrote a piece of physics software recently and sympy (and indeed python in general) was so lacking in features that I had to write half of the software as mathematica packages, half of it as python. I would have implemented those functions myself but they are actually extremely non-trivial and I wouldn't be surprised if just one of the basic functions I needed had many years of R&D and thousands of lines and edge cases. Until there is an open source software that can match the raw symbolic power combined with the huge libraries nothing can touch it for a lot of people.
- sterlind 4y agoran into this myself just today, but with Symbolics.jl instead of SymPy. I just needed an algebra scratchpad, and Symbolics was.. barren. and uninviting. I thought of reaching for Mathematica but resorted to pencil and paper, like a barbarian. same deal with solvers more generally. the coin-or stuff (e.g. Cbc) is slow and buggy, Cplex and Gurobi are far better but very expensive. where are the PhDs in this field? what are they building?
- logicchains 4y ago>I just needed an algebra scratchpad, and Symbolics was.. barren. and uninviting. I thought of reaching for Mathematica but resorted to pencil and paper, like a barbarian. Have you tried Maxima? It seems more ergonomic.
- anthk 4y agoI use Maxima on a Atom N270 netbook. It works greatly, fast and usable. Gnuplot for plotting, and I'm done.
- sfriedr 4y ago> I thought of reaching for Mathematica but resorted to pencil and paper, like a barbarian. A very computer-science perspective with the obligatory dose of hubris. Pencil and paper is continuing to serve a much older, much more consolidated discipline (mathematics) well for... ever since paper was invented.
- sterlind 4y agothe barbarian bit was tongue-in-cheek. it's just that symbolic algebra is one of those old-school, classic use cases for computers, like playing chess or guiding missiles or scheduling routes. I enjoy those kinds of moments.
- bowsamic 4y agoSympy is good as a scratchpad I think. For my case I needed minimal state space realisations of MIMO transfer matrices. In mathematica this is just two functions. Implementing this in Python could take months
- plaguepilled 4y agoI agree wholeheartedly with this. In fact, if Mathematica were open source, I feel it may even encroach upon machine learning applications. Since finishing up in university, I have sorely missed my free access to a fast and ergonomic symbolic equation solver. Sympy is an unsatisfactory substitute.
- logicchains 4y agoHave you tried Maxima as a symbolic equation solver?
- bloaf 4y agoSage/maxima/etc are significantly worse than mathematica at symbolic operations. Check out these benchmarks: https://www.12000.org/my_notes/CAS_integration_tests/reports/summer_2021/inch1.htm https://www.12000.org/my_notes/CAS_integration_tests/reports...
- throwaway81523 4y agoOr Sage (sagemath.org)?
- lokedhs 4y agoSage uses Maxima though. And a bunch of other things as well.
- ilirium 4y agoFor my cases, when during R&D (data science for weather/geo/agro) I rarely need to work with formulas in symbolic representation, Sympy works enough. Cases like combining 2 equations into 1, simplifying, defining numeric coefficients, and printing formulas in TeX representation.
- dhdc 4y agoCounter example: MATLAB. Proprietory software, proprietory language, yet it remains unrivalled in control engineering, DSP, communication systems and so on. I genuinely hope that Octave can take off and trade blows with MATLAB face to face, but not sure if that will ever happen simply because of the amount of money MathWorks is pumping into developing toolboxes.
- catchclose8919 4y ago> yet it remains unrivalled in control engineering No, its usage is just declining slower in those areas because ppl don't want unnecessary change introducing unnecessary defects, esp since safety and reliability matters a lot for some equipments, and also engineers spend time on smth else than learning new languages and frameworks. In 20 years Matlab will be as legacy as Fortran is now, still some left but mostly forgone.
- bowsamic 4y agoNo way, Simulink is way too popular for that
- dhdc 4y ago> In 20 years Matlab will be as legacy as Fortran is now Not if MathWorks keep offering discounts to universities for putting MATLAB in the courses, gotta get those undergrads "hooked" early before graduating.
- notagoodidea 4y agoNot really the reality imho. I was in a cursus where mostly Matlab were taught 10y ago, while I was already programming on the side in Python/R. Most of the students realized after their master that neither academia nor private company were using Matlab and because programming was not the focus, they had a really hard time to transfer their knowledge to any other programming language. Not SW/SE/Dev here, just scientific/engineer cross-over students. After raising their voices, Faculty finally switched from Matlab to Python for those courses because what matters was your number of hire after their master not to get a deal for a software nobody uses besides two old professors. And in general, the more academia moves away from private solutions (be it STATA, ArcGIS, Matlab, SAS, etc), education will move from it also. (Belgian University)
- sveme 4y agoThat's the perspective of a software developer. Neither Mathematica nor Matlab actually try to address this market. Both are languages for mathematicians, scientists and engineers and are still mostly unrivalled when it comes to domain knowledge. Python has the domain knowledge in the datascience domain, Julia has pretty good domain knowledge in OR. No one really comes close to capturing the symbolic computation domain as Mathematica does.
- dguest 4y agoTargeting the non-engineering crowd also means they are optimizing for a group that cares less about stability. That allows them to deprecate features, change interfaces, etc. An open source language is inevitably going to attract some maintainers who care about (or are paid to care about) keeping legacy code working. I haven't worked with Mathematica in years, though, so this is mostly speculation: how strictly do they maintain backward compatibility?
- danachow 4y ago> Targeting the non-engineering crowd also means they are optimizing for a group that cares less about stability. Looking at how many buzzword bingo boards I could make with JavaScript frameworks de jour and even enterprise platforms like .NET I find this statement exactly backwards in practice. > An open source language is inevitably going to attract some maintainers who care about (or are paid to care about) keeping legacy code working. Over 20 years I’ve found this to be quite a mixed bag.
- Smaug123 4y agoExtremely strictly. They're fond of saying that most programs from v1 will Just Work in version 13. See https://reference.wolfram.com/language/tutorial/IncompatibleChanges.html https://reference.wolfram.com/language/tutorial/Incompatible... for a list of breaking changes. They even document certain bugfixes this way: > AbsoluteOptions has been reimplemented to be more accurate, and the form returned for a particular option may be different now. They deprecate stuff, but almost never remove it: > ValueQ has been redesigned to test for the presence of a definition regardless of whether the definition is used. Old behavior can be restored by specifying "Legacy" as the method. They play more fast-and-loose with functions documented as "experimental".
- pjmlp 4y agoJava and C# are partially open source, some of the best tools that make them shine are commercial. Real time bare metal implementations, GUI tooling, 3rd party GUI components ecosystem, data analysis of runtimes in productions without code changes, architecture modeling tools on the IDEs,...
- discordance 4y agoMathematica set the standard for Notebooks (as seen in iPython, Jupyter, Sage etc). If their influence on that is their only contribution to the world, which it is not, then they have made their mark.
- bborud 4y agoThe first time I encountered Mathematica was 30 years ago, and I genuinely thought that within a decade this would be a tool that everyone would learn in college. A few years later, when working at the university I was a bit puzzled to find that while you could find things like Matlab on the various computer labs around campus (usually running some flavor of Unix), Mathematica was nowhere to be seen. Not even on the Windows labs. The guy who was in charge of negotiating software licenses for the university said that it was a chicken and egg problem. Mathematica wasn't very available because it was expensive, Wolfram wasn't easy to negotiate with. With people not learning Mathematica there never developed a demand for it - and because you couldn't expect to get your hands on a license it wasn't worth the investment both in time and money to learn mathematica, or worse yet, to make yourself dependent on it for getting work done. Mathematica has always been a lovely product. But it has also always been impractical due to its pricing and restrictions. Whether you are in academia, a working professional or just a hobbyist. Which has made it a very niche piece of software. For 30+ years. There is no reason to believe this will change. And that's fine. It is their software and they can do whatever they want with it. But it also means it is largely irrelevant software for most people, including the scientific community. That isn't a disparaging remark, it is an accurate representation of reality.
- 7thaccount 4y agoMathematica is like $3k for a commercial license with the kitchen sink. Matlab can cost that much for like the database toolbox addon or the ML toolbox add-on. Mathematica is cheap in comparison.
- kgwgk 4y ago> Mathematica has always been a lovely product. But it has also always been impractical due to its pricing and restrictions. Whether you are in academia, a working professional or just a hobbyist. [...] There is no reason to believe this will change. The hobbyist license is less than $200 per year. What kind of pricing would make it practical for you? [Edit: The student license (non-expiring) was $139 twenty years ago, $176 today. That may be "expensive" but many textbooks cost more than that.]
- tableofzero 4y ago> There is no other use for Wolfram Language scripts outside of Mathematica, which comes with a "license server". That's... a dead end. Yes. They call it Wolfram Engine >Can I publish Wolfram code in Docker Hub and expect it to work (legally)? No. Yes, they call it Wolfram Application Server (does require a license) >Can I throw some Wolfram code into an Azure Function and have it compute something for me on demand? Nope. Yes: https://reference.wolfram.com/language/ref/RemoteBatchSubmit.html https://reference.wolfram.com/language/ref/RemoteBatchSubmit...
- Archit3ch 4y agoMy Raspberry Pi 3 came with Mathematica. If I write Mathematica code on it, put the device in a box and sell it, I just violated the license agreement. Contrast with gcc.
- coldtea 4y ago>As a proprietary language and kernel, it can never compete long-term with open source alternatives. What "open source alternatives"? There aren't any at this level of polish and maturity... Meanwhile, whatever the "dustbin of history" does, we can continue keep using Mathematica just fine, for 20+ years, and 20+ more...
- ur-whale 4y ago> Python, Julia, and Jupyter notebooks will simply wipe out all usage of Mathematica outside of a few esoteric fields. Yup, and all that's needed for the floodgates to open is for someone to write some sort of converter.
- jansan 4y agoAs a proprietary language and kernel, it can never compete long-term with open source alternatives. People have been saying this about Windows for the last 35 years.
- palisade 4y agoI don't know if it could really be considered to be in the dustbin of history. Wolfram Alpha is actually what powers Siri and other services like it. It is what gives her the intelligence. That is a massive accomplishment.
- the_optimist 4y agoDocumentation please. Perhaps SRI originally prototyped on Mathematica, but I do not believe our iPhones are running m scripts in a Mathematica interpreter.
- palisade 4y ago"Rather than return a list of Google search results, Siri uses Wolfram Alpha to generate what it believes is the correct answer." https://www.siriuserguide.com/what-is-wolfram-alpha/ https://www.siriuserguide.com/what-is-wolfram-alpha/ https://www.siriuserguide.com/how-to-use-siri-knowledge/ https://www.siriuserguide.com/how-to-use-siri-knowledge/ "Siri Knowledge uses a combination of web searches, inbuilt apps, and Wolfram Alpha to find the answers to a fantastic variety of questions." If you ask Wolfram Alpha for more information about Siri: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=Siri https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=Siri It returns: "Siri is a personal assistant application for iOS. The application was first available from the App Store, then came standard on Apple's mobile devices starting with iPhone 4S. Siri uses natural language processing to answer questions and perform actions by delegating requests to an expanding set of web services, including Wolfram|Alpha."
- iancmceachern 4y agoAs I understand, Matlab and it'd kernal ate also closed, it's used everywhere.
- BeetleB 4y ago> Python, Julia, and Jupyter notebooks will simply wipe out all usage of Mathematica outside of a few esoteric fields. I'd wager that most of Mathematica's usage today, and in the past has been for those esoteric fields. MATLAB always had higher market share for numerical work. Mathematica's strength is in pure math. And nothing out there comes even close - not even SageMath. I wouldn't be surprised if all the pure math open source developers who are also math experts out there are fewer in number than those who contribute to Mathematica. You need detailed expertise in a math discipline. William Stein - founder of SageMath, wrote once on how impossibly difficult it is to get grants to support SageMath - most of them go to Mathematica or MATLAB. So if a math faculty member wants the extra income from grants, he/she is going to write a proposal targeting Mathematica, not SageMath. Of course, once Stephen Wolfram dies, I don't know if Mathematica will continue to survive. But as long as he's alive, no open source pure math SW will overtake it.
- david38 4y agoWhy would Mathematica die? You think Stephen writes code today?
- 7thaccount 4y agoHe runs every aspect of the company. You can see his "live CEO'ing" videos which are very interesting. It's hard for companies like that to survive after the founder dies.