4 ms·
The first thing I looked for was a comparison with the official Slack client in terms of performance, since that's the only reason why I'd consider using this.
by paxys 4y ago
The first thing I looked for was a comparison with the official Slack client in terms of performance, since that's the only reason why I'd consider using this. Numbers for CPU load, memory use, time to perform certain actions, crashes. Doesn't seem to be anything available on the site regarding this, which is a shame.
- greenthrow 4y agoAn even better reason would potentially be security. Exploits in electron are pretty common, which may be a result of its ubiquity making it a big target. But also it's just a complicated platform to secure.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xmprt 4y agoIf I was worried about security then I think I'd probably move to using the web client (or a web wrapper) instead of switching to a third party native application.
- bobblywobbles 4y agoThat's a common refrain I hear that Electron apps aren't secure. It was more true in the past and less-so now. I've been maintaining a secure Electron template for 2 years that's got traction in the community, if you are interested - https://github.com/reZach/secure-electron-template https://github.com/reZach/secure-electron-template.
- Griffinsauce 4y agoHow is installing rando native apps any more secure?
- anaisbetts 4y ago.
- noptd 4y ago>Slack is one of the most secure Electron apps currently in existence at the moment, they have been... And from your other comment >we in the Slack Desktop team Seems misleading to declare something like this without a disclaimer that you work for the company in question, especially when phrasing it as if you are definitively not a part of said company.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- g_delgado14 4y agoWant to double-down on this. I read "native" and immediately assumed the main selling point was perf - which enticed me to open the link.
- babypuncher 4y agoWell the other selling point would be a native UI experience. I like apps that use the native UI style of the host operating system.
- Bendy 4y agoPaying for native macOS apps is like buying vinyl records. It’s an aesthetic choice, nothing more.
- incanus77 4y agoSadly, this take misses so much about Mac native software, things that many people just do not know are possible. - accessibility built in which benefits everyone - native application scripting - consistent keyboard shortcuts, including focus ring movement - ability to App Nap / fast system shutdown - consistent retina/DPI behavior across display drags I've been developing Mac native software for 20 years now and I'm still wowed by some of the things that come with the toolkit for free.
- Uupis 4y agoIt is a user experience choice. Most decent native macOS apps adhere to system conventions. Text editing works as one would expect in a system text field. Keyboard shortcuts behave as expected. Custom keyboard shortcut definitions from the Keyboard section in Preferences actually work. And on and on. Slack in particular is extremely, extremely slow, even by Electron standards. I can't expand it to the full-height of a 4K (running at 1080p) portrait monitor without typing becoming unbearably laggy, so I either have to keep it at 1/3 monitor height, or have to use another application for writing the text.
- masukomi 4y ago
- sofixa 4y ago> crashes I've literally never had or heard of Slack crashing, across Windows, Ubuntu and macOS, regardless of memory available (8-32GB) and use. Do people really have Slack regularly crash on them or is that just something that gets attached to Electron (for some reason).
- dijit 4y agoA slack crash would be the window going white and reloading. I get them occasionally. An electron crash would kill the window. I get these sometimes too when I try to run natively in wayland, which I’m aware is unsupported so I’m not blaming anyone for that.
- bitexploder 4y agoHappens to folks on my team on occasion. Slack crashing. And the whole Electron app crashing too. Linux users.
- noptd 4y agoSlack crashes (unresponsive white window -> hard reload) for me at least once a day on the latest MacOS and Intel MBP, and it seems a common occurrence for many of the coworkers I talk to.
- skizo 4y agoSlack crashes on my Ubuntu setup on the regular. Grey screens. Unresponsive during video calls. Eats all of my memory at least once a day. The app is a mess.
- danieldrehmer 4y agoMost of the point of skipping electron is memory usage, which is a major issue with having a full separate installation of Chrome just to handle a webpage, which is what Slack is.