3 ms·
See also: Ripcord[1], which has both Slack and Discord support. [1]: https://cancel.fm/ripcord/ https://cancel.fm/ripcord/
by woodruffw 4y ago
See also: Ripcord[1], which has both Slack and Discord support.
[1]: https://cancel.fm/ripcord/ https://cancel.fm/ripcord/
- vdfs 4y agoWon't using a 3rd party app for Discord get your account banned?
- woodruffw 4y agoIt's probably against their terms of service, so maybe. It probably depends on a combination of (over)zealous automation and whether they feel it's in their expedient interest to crack down on.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoTheir client exists almost entirely to collect data about you (chiefly what games you're playing and with whom.) That's one reason they are so quick to ban non-official-client users.
- toastercat 4y agoIt's actually not https://discord.com/terms https://discord.com/terms Although like with all things, proceed with caution.
- j1elo 4y agoFrom today's conversation about Thunderbird 102: yes, it seems running a 3rd-party client has a high chance of receiving a ban. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31914288#31915716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31914288#31915716
- toastercat 4y agoNot necessarily, although this gets routinely brought up in the Ripcord Discord server. Ripcord essentially just uses the browser APIs, so it's not really different from opening Discord in Firefox. That being said, Discord can ban people at random for whatever reason they choose, and this has happened before. For the record, I've been using Ripcord with the same Discord account for 3 years, daily.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kody 4y ago+1 for ripcord. So much better than using a bloated web browser
- toastercat 4y agoRipcord is great and I use it for Discord and Slack, but it is far from feature complete. Important to note that Ripcord is developed by one person. Some major things that are lacking: * No search (Slack/Discord) * No huddles in Slack * Thread support in Discord For these reasons, I typically navigate to Discord/Slack in the browser when I need access to those features. Not ideal, but the snappiness of Ripcord over the slow bloat of Slack/Discord make it worth it to me.
- kevingadd 4y agoRipcord has had search support in Slack for a while, it's under the Workspace menu. Otherwise, yeah. It's unfortunate to have to open the browser to do some of this stuff but the day-to-day experience of using it is great.
- toastercat 4y agoThanks -- I really had no idea.
- gtirloni 4y agoI feel like it being based on Electron is the least bad thing about it. Native or not, you have to reach the API for everything and that's slow.
- toastercat 4y agoAgree to disagree. Selecting a channel in Slack takes like 300ms for me almost every time. There seems to be an inherent UI lag with Slack and Discord. Ripcord, on the other hand, is instantaneous.
- klabb3 4y agoWholeheartedly agree that that's not acceptable performance, but blaming electron, which runs on chromium which is famously fast (despite its other issues) seems misguided. To me it sounds like an artifact of architectural choices, eg by polling before rendering to avoid flicker, lack of client side caching, or possibly just bloat. Companies won't stop their poor software practices even if they switched to native.
- buzzert 4y agoI still use Ripcord at work every day, and it's fantastic.
- alexb_ 4y agoI actually downloaded Ripcord, immediately saw that they will "never" support video calls or embed videos, and then immediately uninstalled it. Why do a lot of these alternate clients purposefully leave out vital features?
- wolfpaws 4y ago> they will "never" support video calls Video calls are somewhat involved, and no third-party implementation exists to my knowledge. Discord uses WebRTC over the browser, but the desktop app uses a native module written in C++ that I assume handles decoding, audio screensharing, and other related functionalities. It's not impossible of course, but the cognitive barrier is much higher than simply observing the WebSocket and HTTP requests to get text chat working.
- thewebcount 4y agoI use Ripcord to access Slack daily and it’s… very mediocre. It uses Qt, so it looks terrible (but at least it’s not a web browser). It’s more native than an electron app, but not by a lot. It doesn’t even use native scroll bars which can be really irritating at times. All images are thumbnail size and if you click to enlarge, it dumps you to the web, which slack.com just ignores. It logs you in and then doesn’t take you to the image or file you clicked on. I don’t hate it (as much as I hate using Slack in a web browser or electron app), but I certainly don’t love it. I’ll be giving Shrugs a try, but it sounds like it’s missing a lot, too, so I’m not hopeful.