3 ms·
> all of the pages and URLs you visit will be sent to Google in order to retrieve +1 information This is a deal breaker. There's no reason that Google couldn't
by tantalor 15y ago
> all of the pages and URLs you visit will be sent to Google in order to retrieve +1 information
This is a deal breaker. There's no reason that Google couldn't have used a hash of the URL.
- grecy 15y ago>There's no reason that Google couldn't have used a hash of the URL. While I agree with you, I have to constantly remind myself of Google's core business and that everything they do, directly or indirectly, needs to feed that. Advertising is king.
- ajross 15y agoTo be fair, that quote lives in the following (verbatim) context: ***THIS ISN’T THE USUAL YADA YADA!*** In addition to the practices described in the Google +1 Button Privacy Policy, by installing this extension, all of the pages and URLs you visit will be sent to Google in order to retrieve +1 information. Examples of this information include whether you’ve previously +1’d the page and how many people have already +1’d the page. Google’s use of this information is described further in the following help center article (http://www.google.com/support/profiles/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=1319578). At least they're not trying to hide anything, recognize that some people will have privacy concerns, and are drawing attention to this fact. The linked FAQ claims that they don't store the information persistently. Though I suppose it could be argued that this policy is subject to change in the future.
- gojomo 15y agoJust wondering, do you also block AdSense and Google Analytics? If not, a large portion of URLs you visit are already reaching Google through those inserts.
- abraham 15y agoGoogle does some normalization on urls before +1'ing them. For example urls shared through Feedburner have a bunch of GET parameters added on. If Google just hashed the URL they wouldn't be able to strip those and single pages would end up having multiple groups of +1's.
- gwern 15y agoYeah. This is even worse than the Alexa plugin because at least with the Alexa plugin, the pinging might result in all the pages I visit entering the Internet Archive's queue.