3 ms·
Isn't this a bit backwards? The royalty system for writing and music evolved in a different age, an age where a physical artifact carried the writing/music and
by bediger4000 4y ago
Isn't this a bit backwards? The royalty system for writing and music evolved in a different age, an age where a physical artifact carried the writing/music and thus it was relatively easy to charge for it, count the reproductions, and distribute any income. You also have to include the huge special interests that have... motivated... the current royalty system. Google for the story of "Mitch Glazier" and "work for hire" to see what shenanigans have been discovered.
Programmers and the job of programming evolved when a physical artifact wasn't necessary, and has become impossible to attach to a work. It's more or less impossible to count reproductions or uses. Any income collected would be less than the number of reproductions or uses, but by how much is utterly impossible to determine. Distribution of the income would be similarly arbitrary.
The screenwriters, songwriters and authors should be paid like programmers, not programmers paid like screenwriters, songwriters and authors.
- b20000 4y agohahaha... do you really think these people will accept to be paid like programmers? they have unions.
- bediger4000 4y agoNo, just saying that there's a lot of history, and path dependence wrapped up in that issue. Ideals don't enter into it.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoEbook authors, Netflix screenwriters and Spotify artists are still able to obtain royalties for every download or view, so I wouldn't say it's a system of a bygone era just yet. Indie video games, for example, show a path (albeit one with a middleman) to how one might obtain royalties for a work that is "impossible" to count reproductions or uses for.