11 ms·
How far out of the American norm would Palin's beliefs be? I understand there is a constant debate about teaching evolution in the States. Presumably this is b
by netcan 18y ago
How far out of the American norm would Palin's beliefs be?
I understand there is a constant debate about teaching evolution in the States. Presumably this is backed up with a substantial minority. Certainly it is not Bizarre enough to exclude her from gaining traction in a mainstream party (Governor, VP). If a Salafist became a VP in Iraq (a formerly relatively secular country), we would take that of evidence of a move towards more conservative religion.
Maybe that's a bad example because at the moment, a Salafist politician in the middle east probably has more immediate political consequences. But all the same, I couldn't imagine a Scientologist VP of the US.
I am genuinely asking here. Is the fact that Palin is an acceptable politician a hint that the beliefs are 'mainstream' or does it just mean that religion is really a non0issue in US politics.
- menloparkbum 18y agoI grew up in a community not unlike Palin's home town. In my youth I spent a lot of time traveling to other similar towns. Her beliefs and attitudes are very similar to the mainstream in the rural communities I am familiar with. I will go out on a limb and say that there are quite a few people in rural Montana, the Dakotas, Wyoming, Minnesota, and Idaho who would be Palin supporters. I'm not sure if this can be extended to 'mainstream' in the rest of America, because more people live in big cities and suburbs, which are much different than the rural areas. Even rural areas in other parts of the country seem wildly different. Rural New Mexico, "the South" and Oregon all seemed very different from each other and from anything that I experienced growing up. I'm not sure how Palin would fare in those places.
- tptacek 18y agoTake any large group of people, and a large fraction of those people will not care enough to understand natural selection, the role of chance in nature, or the implications of genetics. They may maintain piecemeal understanding of facets of these issues --- for instance, noticing that their children share their eye color, and that there's a non-supernatural reason for that --- but they're going to lack the big picture. The big picture isn't their problem. They have better things to deal with. This is just specialization of labor. To that significant portion of the population, the word "evolution" is just a buzzword, and a political football. Most of the people who have a problem with the teaching of evolution don't really have a problem with evolution per se; they have a stake in a culture war that our media and our politicians are stoking up to serve their own interests. I don't think this has anything whatsoever to do with religion. If I had to guess --- just totally off the top of my head --- the people who really commit themselves to believing in the literal truth of the Bible are probably far more "reasonable" in arguments than the Colorado Springs megachurch set is. Either way: rejecting evolution is far outside the mainstream.
- MHollender 18y agoYou know, the funny thing about evolution-acceptance is that it forms a full circle. There are the weird creationists on the far right. And there are the liberals in the center and left who accept evolution but reject the psychological consequences of it, consider human nature a "blank slate" or "noble savage" and thus heavily engage in social engineering. And then there are those people who fully understand evolutionary psychology. And they tend to be on the right too, for reasons that would be too long to enumerate here. Sometimes I hope creationism is a giant scam. You play a dumb ID-iot and that makes everybody on the center and left equate any kind of disbelief or ignorance against anything that's evolutionary with stupidity. And then when it's done you hit them in the head with evolutionary psychology and then they just cannot afford to ignore it, because it would make them look stupid.