3 ms·
> My question is why hasn't anyone come along and fixed it? Git has the plumbing vs. porcelain separation. Dozens have, but by the time their replacement porce
by masklinn 4y ago
> My question is why hasn't anyone come along and fixed it? Git has the plumbing vs. porcelain separation.
Dozens have, but by the time their replacement porcelain gets anywhere near useful they’ve attained a grasp of the plumbing more than good enough they don’t need it anymore.
> My second question is, if the underlying model is so f*cking elegant, how did it lead to such a confusing interface?
Mastery of structural elegance doesn’t mean you have also mastered interface and experience. In fact it’s often not the case.
> I can't offhand think of another piece of software where "the model is elegant but the interface is confusing" is such a common critique.
Every database. The relational model is a beautiful thing, sql is a horrendous shit-show.
- kjeetgill 4y ago> Every database. The relational model is a beautiful thing, sql is a horrendous shit-show. Amen. We probably disagree on if we need less abstraction or better abstraction though. For all the griping that git gets I really think it could be much worse. It's a somewhat inelegant shrink-wrap over its data structures but at least I can get at all the pieces I need. I get that SQL works well for ad-hoc analysis and business cases, and a query planner is super useful there, but for service to service calls I'd love a language that let's me refer to the tables, the b-trees, row-ids, and lets me tell it what to do.
- zasdffaa 4y ago> but for service to service calls I'd love a language that let's me refer to the tables, the b-trees, row-ids Quite Insane :) Ok, more helpfully, what possible value would you get if the DB gave you access to those?
- tmaly 4y agoIt seems then what is needed is a better way to onboard people to get them to that state of knowing.
- goto11 4y agoJavaScript is another example. The core model is simple: Closures + dictionaries. But the syntax is clunky and confusing.