4 ms·
Too many people confuse faith with the idea of absolute belief. It's one thing to be faithful to a set of teachings and it's another to believe a particular set
by netcan 18y ago
Too many people confuse faith with the idea of absolute belief. It's one thing to be faithful to a set of teachings and it's another to believe a particular set of statements to be literally true.
I understand the wish to be diplomatic & uninflammatory. After all, a lot of wars have started over these kinds of things but.. I think that statement doesn't make much sense. I think that making that statement is confusing religion with scripture. If you take Christians as an example, many do not believe various elements (eg Adam & Eve) to be literally true. OK. I understand.
But all that means they are essentially reading a different text. One is reading a history & rule book. The other is reading a book which contains high level principles in the form of stories, some of which may be based on real events. There are lots of variations.
What they have in common is that both are receiving information from a divine, supernatural (unless you do semantic cartwheels) source. Both believe this information to be definitively true. To me (an atheist) the distinctions seem less significant then the commonalities. The religious have a source of information that I do not have.
The words faith, belief, god, religion etc. are very hard to generalise. But the idea behind them is often simply information
- bayareaguy 18y agoAlthough it may not have made much sense to you, you seem to have captured the gist of what I tried to say. Even athiests can appreciate the Beatitudes.
- netcan 18y agoI suppose I did if the Gist of "Too many people confuse faith with the idea of absolute belief" is "Too many people assume that faith = literal belief in Genesis, Leviticus or Luke" Certainly absolute beliefs matter in a practical sense. If I were in The States, Obama's beliefs wouldn't worry me. Palin's might. In the very theoretical sense, they both worry me a little. But even Palin's beliefs are probably less likely to affect anything to the degree that her social conservatism (related but not equivalent) is likely to have.
- MHollender 18y ago"But even Palin's beliefs are probably less likely to affect anything to the degree that her social conservatism" Well, I'm not an American and not religious (well, Buddhist but that doesn't really count as a religion), but I fail to see what's wrong with a moderate amount of social conservativism. One of my favourite hobbies is history. And what I learned from history is that liberal periods, when everybody was running around having fun and not caring about much else, were, well, the last period before a collapse. Societies, civilizations when they still had a future before them were very conservative, regarded duty more important than fun, there was a strong focus on families, and so on . It's not something to like or dislike. It's more like a factual thing. A man might be most alive when he is having the most fun, but a society isn't. Think of the Romans, when they still had a lot of will to live, the early period when they really expanded, what virtues they had, gravitas, pietas, dignitas... wasn't very fun and not liberal at all. But they had a very strong will to live. And had a future.
- bmj 18y agoA common apologetic for Christianity is that you either believe Christ was God, or that he was a lunatic. The middle ground (that is, Christ wasn't God but merely a brilliant moral philosopher) is hard to defend given what the Bible says Christ did and said.
- tptacek 18y agoIt's not a "middle ground" to suggest that the core beliefs of a religion are false. I'm not saying you have to accept Christianity or Buddhism or Zoroastrianism, but you might be a bit more self-aware.
- netcan 18y ago"Middle ground" is just not a great way of looking at things. It's nice to be able to put things on a scale of Jesus was a nice guy--->The bible contains divine guidance--->The Bible is infallible That's fine for practical reasons (eg politics). But those are essentially different beliefs. They're not on a scale in the same way that Christianity, Buddhism or Zoroastrianism are not on a scale.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoAs a non-religious person, let me offer: I give Jesus the credence I would somebody I met at a bar --->I admire his teachings and do the best I can to emulate him-->I treat all the information I can gather about him to be divinely inspired What something is, that's dogma and inflexible. How I treat it is human nature, and infinitely scalable. As a personal note, I think I'm somewhere between 1 and 2.
- alex_c 18y agoI think that statement doesn't make much sense. I think it does. It makes the distinction between making an attempt to reconcile a set of moral and spiritual concepts with our scientific knowledge of the world, and rejecting scientific thought in favor of literal interpretation of a scripture. If you think of it as a Venn diagram, religious belief and scientific knowledge are, for the most part, disjoint, but overlap (which usually means "conflict") in certain areas. The distinction is between people who, in that area of conflict, tend to give precedence to either belief or science.
- netcan 18y ago"The distinction is between people who, in that area of conflict, tend to give precedence to either belief or science." I think you're wrong here. I think few give precedence to science. They find a way to work around the conflict. Giving precedence is along the lines of 'I see a green sheep so I know they exist' taking precedence over 'I read on wikipedia that all sheep are white.'Generally, the latter set of believers interpret 'wikipedia' in a way that does not cause conflict or minimises conflict. Obviously there is a practical distinction between various points on the scale between Obama & Bin laden (with Palin somewhere in between). But the scale is not about how they deal with 'conflict.' It's about how often the conflicts occur & where. That's the practical scale that affects what people do & how they vote. On the more fundamental scale of how they deal with such conflict, the variations tend to be much smaller. Edit: Clarification