3 ms·
We have a ton of dead humans in the ocean, it isn't considered a national embarrassment, I don't think. Accidents are sad, but their inevitability is something
by bee_rider 4y ago
We have a ton of dead humans in the ocean, it isn't considered a national embarrassment, I don't think. Accidents are sad, but their inevitability is something that everyone understands.
I don't think we should colonize Mars, at least given what we've seen there. Currently, it appears to be a big, empty, inhospitable, far away rock. Getting there and then terraforming it would, I guess, require figuring out how to live in space long term, at which point why bother going down the gravity well? Once we've figured out how to live in space... there's plenty of space in space, just stay in orbit (maybe we'll have expensive tourism on planets).
- graycat 4y ago> We have a ton of dead humans in the ocean, it isn't considered a national embarrassment, I don't think. Accidents are sad, but their inevitability is something that everyone understands. In practice, on the moon or Mars, the dead bodies would just pile up. And otherwise there would be a lot of them in long lasting orbits. Here on earth, we don't have that problem. E.g., using side scan sonar, we just found a US destroyer 3+ miles down, in two pieces, sunk by a shot from the battleship Yamato in one of the WWII battles in the Philippine Sea. We are not bothered by the pile up of the bodies of the dead US sailors. The bodies decompose and don't pile up, and in the case of the ocean are miles deep where it is pitch black, just above freezing, with not much in life. In my original post, I didn't object to the deaths. Instead I objected to the accumulation of dead bodies that will last for thousands of years. There is no reasonably feasible way for humans to colonize either the moon or Mars. Big problems include the medical effects of high energy cosmic rays and the low gravity. Other dangers stand to be the highly foreign, restrictive, threatening, and hostile environments, even nearly the best environments we could hope to create. Even if we could get some plants to be healthy on the moon or Mars, we can't get humans healthy there. No practical way. So, we will get piles of dead bodies, and all for nothing -- the moon and Mars are so hostile to humans that there is no way humans could be at all productive on either. Robots? Fine. Humans? No reasonably feasible way, and with a result of piles of dead bodies. Sorry 'bout that. It's not at all complicated.
- yellowapple 4y ago> and in the case of the ocean are miles deep where it is pitch black, just above freezing, with not much in life. That's even more true about space. If you're fine with bodies in the ocean, then you should be even more fine with bodies in the literal infinity that is outer space. (And no, bodies on the ocean floor don't decompose, at least not fully; the cold suppresses a lot of the decomposition processes, and the deeper you go, the fewer the scavengers to pick meat off your bones - bones which themselves have a tendency to stick around for a very long time.)
- graycat 4y ago> If you're fine with bodies in the ocean, then you should be even more fine with bodies in the literal infinity that is outer space. Yes, space is for us nearly infinity, but getting very far takes a lot of energy. So, the dead bodies will nearly always be in some orbit around the moon, earth, Mars, the sun, etc., frozen, and so expensive to retrieve that they will be there for 1000+ years and, thus, an embarrassment. Last I heard, a dead whale, several miles down, gets eaten back to just the bones by some specialized worms fairly quickly. But it's several miles down. On the moon or Mars, there will be a pile of frozen dead bodies right there, fully visible. Such a pile of frozen dead bodies, I don't think that will be acceptable ethically, politically, emotionally, etc. In a word, it will be embarrassing. The media will have a lot of headlines -- add up all the money, the huge pile of money, and claim that about all we got was a pile of frozen dead bodies, as proof of our folly, that will be there for 1000+ years.
- yellowapple 4y ago> Yes, space is for us nearly infinity, but getting very far takes a lot of energy. It takes a lot less once you're in orbit, and... > But it's several miles down. There are many thousands or even millions of miles to cover in order to encounter a body in even Earth's orbit, let alone every other body we might explore. > On the moon or Mars, there will be a pile of frozen dead bodies right there, fully visible. Have you seriously never heard of cremation? Or burial?