3 ms·
> Everyone agrees that the right to privacy is in the constitution. That is demonstrably not true. Robert Bork may be dead, but many folks still believe what h
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> Everyone agrees that the right to privacy is in the constitution.
That is demonstrably not true. Robert Bork may be dead, but many folks still believe what he said, which was that the Constitution does NOT guarantee a general right to privacy. Thomas specifically argued that the court should also look at overturning the right to contraception, private consensual sex, and gay marriage specifically because the same privacy right underlies those rulings.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoOne more thing to add the above comment. The ruling in Loving v Virginia, which is what allows interracial marriages like Thomas' to exist in Virginia in the first place, is also based on substantive due process (which is what underlies the privacy right in all these cases). Quite conveniently, Loving v Virginia was not one of the rulings that Thomas argued needed revisiting.
- delecti 4y agoLoving v Virginia is based both on due process and equal protection. He's not necessarily a hypocrite to be against Loving but not Roe. But he did call out Obergefell, which is also based on equal protection, so he is very much a hypocrite for calling out that but not Loving.