3 ms·
A brief history of green opposition to nuclear power will show the following points, which should not be handwaved away: - nuclear weapons. This is where Green
by pjc50 4y ago
A brief history of green opposition to nuclear power will show the following points, which should not be handwaved away:
- nuclear weapons. This is where Greenpeace actually got their start and where the "peace" comes from in their name. Most uranium designs require enrichment to some level and can also be used to produce plutonium. This is not a dead consideration; see Iraq's controversial civilian nuclear programme, and the ongoing war between a very large nuclear-armed rogue state and the proxy forces of the nuclear-armed West. Are you comfortable with a nuclear power plant in every country?
- terrorist and other attacks. The Ukraine war has seen fighting around Chernobyl, and actual shelling of Zaporizhzhia. https://theconversation.com/russian-shelling-caused-a-fire-at-a-ukrainian-nuclear-power-plant-how-close-did-we-actually-come-to-disaster-178549 https://theconversation.com/russian-shelling-caused-a-fire-a...
- nuclear waste. Again a big issue for Greenpeace in the 80s; admittedly this has massively improved. Note that there is both "high level" waste which can be reused as fuel, "high level" waste which cannot be used as fuel, and a much larger amount of contaminated normal materials. Some of which are less radioactive than naturally occurring rocks.
- choose your poison: CO2 is a slowly rising problem. Nuclear power plants are a "black swan" distribution; mostly perfectly safe, but the disasters that have happened have affected huge areas.
An additional practical consideration:
- cost and time overruns. Hinkley Point C is projected to have a 50% cost overrun and to be completed 17 years from its initial announcement. Even if we were to decide to roll out nuclear power, we must keep up the rate of renewables buildout (now considerably cheaper) because it will take decades for the plants to actually be built.
I do think the SMR concept is worth giving another go. nuclear powered submarines and aircraft carriers are already small modular reactors with great safety records. We must not bet on it alone.
Thorium seems to be a nerd trap; nobody seems to be trying this commercially, and since it can't be used for weapons there's no government subsidy as there was for the original buildout of uranium based plants.
Molten salt has unsolvable materials science / plumbing issues: it's too corrosive.
- stefantalpalaru 4y ago> nuclear waste. Again a big issue for Greenpeace in the 80s; admittedly this has massively improved. Did it? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asse_II_mine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asse_II_mine
- pstuart 4y agoChina is giving thorium a go: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02459-w https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02459-w
- exabrial 4y ago> nuclear waste I think this is the most over-hyped point. I used to think this was a big issue, but we're talking a swimming pool of spicy rocks for an entire nation.
- defterGoose 4y agoWonderful. Using this in the future.
- blibble 4y agothe UK's high level waste for the past 70 years would fit inside half of one olympic sized swimming pool this is a problem we are capable of dealing with
- pjc50 4y agoThe problem is what happens if that pool leaks into the water table or sea, because things like caesium are bioaccumulative. The absolute volume is kind of irrelevant because many of these substances are very dense.
- exabrial 4y agoThis is the problem with humans: They have a hard time recognizing conceptual scale without examples. A _swimming pool_. Literally more readioactive crap from outerspace hits the ocean every year than this. And no, The absolute volume does matter. That is non-sensical and nonsense. There's more uranium in sea water that humans would put every "pollute" it with
- viraptor 4y ago> choose your poison: CO2 is a slowly rising problem. Co2 + all air pollution around the coal/gas power plants. On average they're still more harmful than an occasional nuclear plant failure.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoOrder of magnitude for the gas plants. Two orders of magnitude for the coal plants (and note that this is worldwide, the local effects are even worse.)
- LorenPechtel 4y agoThe waste is purely a political issue. In the left corner we have a coal plant. In the right corner we have a nuclear plant with the same output, as well as a reprocessing setup. They run for a year, both have produced waste. We dig identical landfills for both of them and bury the waste. Next year we need to dig a new landfill for the coal plant, but the nuke one has plenty of space left. 10,000 years from now the nuke landfill finally fills up--but the first waste we have put in it has decayed to ambient and no longer needs any special storage. Accidents: The worst nuke has ever done is no worse than normal operation + unfortunate weather has done with coal many times. With even halfway decent safety measures we should be looking at Fukushima as the worst likely event--and note that the death toll ascribed to Fukushima is purely political, had they not evacuated the city the expected death toll was zero. I wouldn't advise farming around there for a while but otherwise it should have been life as normal. Weapons: At the nation-state level you can't prevent this. At the terrorist level there's a pretty simple defense--your reprocessing plants put some of the waste back into the fuel. Most of the waste that builds up is irrelevant to the reactor, it's a few neutron absorbers that cause the problems. Take those out, put the gamma emitters back in. Even new fuel rods are therefore wickedly hot. Since both the reactors and the reprocessors already have the robotic equipment to handle the wickedly hot spent rods this causes only very minimal issues, but it makes stealing material very dangerous and very easy to spot--you can't hide a gamma emitter with any shield you can smuggle out. I will object about the small reactors, though--we do *not* want shipboard reactors for civilian use! To keep them small enough those shipboard reactors are fueled with weapons grade uranium.
- pjc50 4y agoI don't remember coal ever rendering food unsafe to eat for 20 years. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cumbria-18299228 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cumbria-18299228 Your assertion is that all the precautions around Fukushima are entirely spurious, and that everyone involved is wrong about the risks, and that you're right and the risk is much lower? I can't help but feel I've heard this a lot during covid. Is there any evidence?
- LorenPechtel 4y ago