9 ms·
Pre-Modern Battlefields (2015)
- SHAKEDECADE 4y agoWhen pre-modern battlefields are brought up, I often think of the Battle of the Bastards scene from Game of Thrones. One of the few battle scenes that gives me the cold sweats. Watching the absolutely suffocating clash of flesh and metal is horrific.
- tmpz22 4y agoThat battle was a terrible representation of medieval warfare. And it was still one of the better representations of the entire show.
- OJFord 4y agoIs there a similar show without the fantasy/supernatural elements that you might recommend, if you see what I mean? I don't need it to be historically accurate (if anything I'd prefer it didn't even pretend to be about 'Romans' or whatever, like GoT doesn't, since then there's an historical truth for it to (likely) miss) but the more GoT went on the more dragony, visiony, giants-y, etc. it seemed to get, and while I enjoyed it I do find it harder to engage (or perhaps rather easier to disengage, take a while to get into, etc.) with that sort of stuff.
- danenania 4y ago'Vikings' is great. It has many battles and focuses a lot on strategy and tactics. It has a touch of the supernatural since it's based on the Icelandic sagas, but it's a fairly minor element.
- tmp_anon_22 4y agoHBO's Rome is pretty good, but only two seasons. Its from the mid 00s.
- the_biot 4y agoIt really was terrible, but the aspect of the fighters getting pushed ever closer together, to the point where it's hard to watch it's so terrifying, really did happen. The battle of Cannae was apparently like that, where soldiers were so terrified they started digging holes to crawl into. The article mentions this as possibly one of the things that make a flanking attack so terrifying -- it would squish the ranks together in a way that a frontal attack didn't.
- westpfelia 4y agoSome real terror was the early days of WW1. We had long standing generals who just did not know how to adjust to the (at the time) modern battlefield. So they would just lead mass charges into fortified positions with artillery and machine guns. It was the definition of a meat grinder. I would suggest checking out Dan Carlins Hardcore History podcast for more about it! The series he did on WW1 was called "Blueprint for Armageddon" Its really good and Dan does a great job of pulling you into the narrative.
- pdpi 4y ago> So they would just lead mass charges into fortified positions with artillery and machine guns. It was the definition of a meat grinder. I read something a while back that, while I'm not sure how accurate it is, got sort of seared into my brain. In medieval times, permanent fortified positions (castles and such) were of the utmost importance, and sieges were a major part of war. With the arrival of gunpowder, cannons could wreck walls and other fortifications, and warfare in the open field largely replaced siege warfare. The single biggest military failure of WW1 (by both sides) was that the then-modern military doctrine told them to treat trench warfare as slow-moving open warfare, where it should've instead been fought as a slightly mobile form of siege warfare.
- ivanonhn 4y agoI think this is still true for the case of a conventional war. This can be checked in Ukraine right now. As far as I know, most of the losses of Russian troops at the beginning of the conflict are associated with hidden groups of Ukrainian soldiers who did not show up while the Russian tanks were making the initial march. And then, when supply caravans were heading to the front line, these hidden groups instantly attacked them from the side, and then hid again in the woods by the roads. Then the Russians changed tactics - no rush, but intense shelling of the front line with all kinds of artillery for several days, then a small advance, then a sweep, and then the cycle repeats.
- icegreentea2 4y ago"Fighting siege warfare" means that both sides can expect to "win" by doing nothing and sitting in their defenses. It's unclear if this really applies to WW1 Western Front. Perhaps Germany was in a position were it was happy to sit in their trenches and just endure, but France was not. France had to be able to compel Germany to come to terms and restore French territory (which we should also remember contained a good chunk of French industry). While the blockade of Germany was clearly effective, it's not clear to this day (and certainly would not have been clear to the western allies at the time) if the blockade alone could have compelled Germany to terms. And certainly the western allies DID attempt to strategically outflank Germany. It just... didn't really work. WW1 generals understood sieges. They generally understood what fortifications could and could not do. There's a reason the Belgiums kept building forts. There's a reason why Germany built ever bigger artillery. WW1 generals got to see the Russo-Japanese war 10 years ago. They got to see a 6 month siege of Port Arthur. They got to see the ridiculous causalities that modern weapons could inflict. But they also saw something - the attack WORKED. The costs were awful, but the Japanese achieved their goals.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoThe pile of bodies in that battle is completely unrealistic. About the only thing that was realistic was the shield wall. But then the writers left a huge plot hole because the good guys had a giant that could have just broken the lines.
- jbandela1 4y ago> The losers could suffer appalling casualties in the battle itself or in the ensuing pursuit, but the victors rarely suffered more than 5 per cent fatalities even in drawn-out engagements. One of Rome’s biggest advantages was that their training and discipline were such that even when they lost, they would often still extract a high price from the opponent (see Pyrrhus). This could be a real problem during civil wars and the opposing Roman legions would devastate each other.
- cercatrova 4y agoWell, except for Cannae and other Hannibalic battles.
- WJW 4y agoOr the ambush in the Teutoburg Forest where the Romans lost 16k+ troops vs only minor losses for the Germanic tribes.
- jbandela1 4y agoYeah and there was also Carrhae. But those cases either involved a brilliant general (Hannibal was probably top 10 of all time generals) or else ambushes in unfamiliar territory far from their home base. I think the original point still stands.
- cercatrova 4y agoFrom Livy's History of Rome, when Scipio Africanus and Hannibal met at a party once: > Africanus asked who, in Hannibal's opinion, was the greatest general of all time. Hannibal replied: 'Alexander, King of the Macedonians, because with a small force he routed armies of countless numbers, and because he traversed the remotest lands. Merely to visit such lands transcended human expectation.' > Asked whom he would place second, Hannibal said: 'Pyrrhus. He was the first to teach the art of laying out a camp. Besides that, no one has ever shown nicer judgement in choosing his ground, or in disposing his forces. He also had the art of winning men to his side; so that the Italian peoples preferred the overlordship of a foreign king to that of the Roman people, who for so long had been the chief power in that country.' > When Africanus followed up by asking whom he ranked third, Hannibal unhesitatingly chose himself. Scipio burst out laughing at this, and said: 'What would you have said if you had defeated me?' 'In that case', replied Hannibal, 'I should certainly put myself before Alexander and before Pyrrhus - in fact, before all other generals!' > This reply, with its elaborate Punic subtlety, and this unexpected kind of flattery...affected Scipio deeply, because Hannibal had set him (Scipio) apart from the general run of commanders, as one whose worth was beyond calculation.
- waynesonfire 4y agoI really like this introduction of the terror aspect. It really is key. Another place I recognize this concept being utilized is by Jordan Peterson. One of the foundational pillars to his analysis of human psychology is that we are surrounded by malevolence and he uses that in his analysis to better understand human behavior. It certainly makes for compelling arguments because that foundation is so true. And, it seems to be missing from his critics.
- EarthLaunch 4y agoInteresting read! Funnily, this reminds me of World of Warcraft 40 vs 40 horde vs alliance battles in Alterac Valley (in vanilla). Can a game battle be taken as a realistic simulation of real battle? Anyway, it matches this description of grouping. Depending on the current meta, both sides would generally urge each other to 'charge' immediately to the enemy base and win. This was called rushing the base. However, sometimes the opposing side would mount a defense. In that case, a battle line would naturally form. Both sides would face off at 40 yards, which was roughly the maximum spellcasting range. They would pick at each other with long range spells, cautiously, no one wanting to do a suicide charge. Then smaller teams on each side (cohorts?) would urge each other to charge in simultaneously. A grouped warrior or mage +healer, if they charged in together, could decimate (yes) the enemy. When that happened, the enemy would attempt to back up. Sometimes they couldn't back up fast enough; they had overcommitted. Then they got 'wiped'. Other times, they retreated and the battle line was re-established closer to their base.
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoWell, modern and post-modern are pretty terrifying too.
- lofatdairy 4y agoThere's a pretty telling anecdote in Suetonius's life of Augustus where "[Augustus] sold a Roman knight and his property at public auction, because he had cut off the thumbs of two young sons, to make them unfit for military service" (24). In fact, this was apparently not uncommon, with several more references to similar self-inflicted injuries to avoid service popping up in various texts. I think there were also direct reforms put in place that specified that men without fingers could still be deemed fit for service (I think this might have been the late imperial period but unfortunately the precise source was found in a library book that I don't have access to at the moment). While war is obviously still horrific, I think it's a bit easier to forget that when discussing history when we don't have particularly realistic images to base our imaginations. That even the Romans, at the height of its power, feared sending their sons to war, kinda counters the notion that conquest was this glorious, honorable thing that built an empire and made men like Caesar into the immortal gods we remember.
- lkrubner 4y agoIn her book SPQR, the historian Mary Beard emphasizes that the Roman Empire was unable to conquer anything. The Roman Republic conquered the Mediterranean world, and then the Roman Empire failed at everything: https://www.amazon.com/Spqr-History-Ancient-Mary-Beard/dp/1846683815/ref=sr_1_5?crid=2DONE6LB5O6FX&keywords=Mary+beard&qid=1656520705&sprefix=mary+beard%2Caps%2C91&sr=8-5 https://www.amazon.com/Spqr-History-Ancient-Mary-Beard/dp/18... The only major, lasting conquest made by the Roman Empire was the conquest of Britain, under the Emperor Claudius. But for the most part, from the moment it was created, the Roman Empire was in a defensive crouch, trying to defend what the Roman Republic had built. The Republic had a culture that very much treated war as a glorious thing, and mobilized the public for total war, over and over again. The Roman Empire was very different, fighting became professionalized, and it became defensive.
- starwind 4y agoThe Romans were also up against some adversaries who fought desperately to not be Roman. Somewhat off topic, but I’ll bring it up anyway, it must have been better to have lived in a Gallic or Germanic or Iberian tribe than to have lived as a Roman ~citizen~ person if they were willing to die than submit. I’m sure honor had something to do with it, but the general trend seen in the archaeological record in the Middle East and North America is that people got shorter and had more teeth problems as they settle down into civilization than when they were hunter/gatherers or lived in settled communities for no more than a few years before hitting the proverbial road again. I’m sure the same thing applies in Europe during the Roman age.
- _the_inflator 4y agoNot only pre-modern. I got to know quite a couple of WWII veterans. PTSD was invented for them and coping mechanism #1 was alcohol. During the 80th you could witness a lot of vets, who were blind, men who had lost limbs - quite common here. Not to mention rape for the women. These folks shaped the daily live.
- chrisseaton 4y ago> PTSD was invented for them You think nobody suffered PTSD before WW2? Look up the battle shock that people suffered in WW1.
- conorcleary 4y agoThey're referring to the semantic term. Also 'shell shock' is a more common term for WW1's version.
- kloch 4y agoGeorge Carlin had a classic bit on the topic of evolving names for PTSD: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSp8IyaKCs0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSp8IyaKCs0
- shitpostbot 4y agoI propose Betteridge's law of internet comments: Any question at the start of a reply can be answered with, "No, that's obviously not what they said, let's try to keep the drama to a minimum please."
- sandworm101 4y agoPTSD is also less common in soldiers than in other jobs. Many types of doctors (oncology, some branches of pediatrics) are pretty much expected to experience symptoms after a given number of years. It is also very very common amongst train engineers. And prison guards.
- Group_B 4y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hSp8IyaKCs0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hSp8IyaKCs0
- DicIfTEx 4y agoAnother interesting exploration of maniples is available at https://yewtu.be/watch?v=croWDsDhgPo https://yewtu.be/watch?v=croWDsDhgPo, at the end of which he references a excellent battle scene from the HBO's Rome (https://yewtu.be/watch?v=J7MYlRzLqD0 https://yewtu.be/watch?v=J7MYlRzLqD0). The pike scene from Alatriste (https://yewtu.be/watch?v=4y6agtVxWi8&t=125 https://yewtu.be/watch?v=4y6agtVxWi8&t=125) also gives a good idea of how terrifying close-quarters battle must've been (disclaimer: I'm not a historian so I can't vouch for the historical accuracy). Imagine being the little guy with the dagger who has to duck under all that.
- atwood22 4y agoWhile pre-modern battlefields were certainly horrific, I wonder which is more terrifying: 1) Hand-to-hand combat where your fate is decided within a few seconds but you have some control over the situation. 2) Sitting in cover while artillery shells rain down randomly around you.
- burnished 4y agoHow do you reckon melee combat is finished so quickly?
- jessaustin 4y agoHumans with penetrating wounds to the torso don't fight much longer. Such wounds can be created with sharpened sticks (as well as a variety of slightly more advanced weapons), while preventing such wounds requires armor of complicated manufacture. Humans with concussive damage to the head tend to stop defending themselves, which also means they don't fight much longer. Such wounds can be created by anything dense, such as rocks or big sticks (as well as a variety of slightly more advanced weapons), while preventing such wounds requires very modern high-quality helmets. Once steel and higher-quality swords and polearms came along, a variety of new types of wounds became more likely, many of which also quickly led to cessation of fighting on their victims' part. Even unarmed fights are usually shorter than portrayed in popular fiction. If ancient battles lasted days, that's because they were organized to move combatants around and avoid actual combat until advantage could be taken. Melee between two groups of armed humans could be over in less than a minute. Note that the most common way for melee to cease would be for the losing side to retreat (perhaps without those of their number who had already succumbed), which is viable when ranged weapons aren't used.
- piyh 4y agoWatch any UFC match, then extrapolate that to the death.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoUFC would be much slower than conflict between groups of men with weapons. In a 1-on-1 situation, grappling and extended engagement become viable techniques. Anyone who tried to wrestle in the middle of a melee would have a very short lifespan.
- morninglight 4y agoIf you were in a battlefield that was not terrifying, you were not in a battlefield.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- larsrc 4y agoMethinks a key difference in "terror level" is that in close combat, you see the enemy and their deadly possibly bloodied weapons up close. Much more psychologically present. Ranged weapons give a different overall stress of "I could suddenly die without warning", but you're not facing your death as clearly.
- t_mann 4y agoThe efficiency of well-trained armies such as the imperial legions at their peak just defies belief. At the battle of Watling Street in Britain, two Roman legions (~10,000 soldiers, including auxiliaries) faced off against an estimated 230,000 tribal warriors. They came out victorious, with minuscule losses (~400) compared to an estimated 80,000 Britons (not all warriors) who left their lives in the battle. The odds were so heavily stacked against the Romans prior to the battle that the commander of the Legio II Augusta had refused an order to join the outnumbered troops (and committed suicide after hearing the outcome). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defeat_of_Boudica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defeat_of_Boudica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legio_II_Augusta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legio_II_Augusta
- jaqalopes 4y agoJust a small contribution to the discussion: my understanding is that alcohol also had a lot to do with loosening soldiers up enough that they'd be willing to actually charge the enemy. They don't call it "liquid courage" for nothing.
- Borrible 4y agoThe Imperial Japanese Army in Manchuria in WWII used to use living prisoners for their bayonet training.
- usrusr 4y agoI suspect that we have a coping mechanism wired in where a certain part of our mind tries to refute bad conscience over something we have done that we consider really bad by repeating the deedwhile internally shouting down the horrified parts "see? it's not that bad, life goes on". Repeating the deed, or exceeding. I'd imagine that conditioning (I refuse to call it training) to have been exceptionally effective.
- Borrible 4y agoIt is estimated that the number of intraspecies killings in humans is about six times higher than the average of all mammals. The 20th century compared to the Middle Ages, was a peaceful affair. It's estimated that in the good olden times about 12 percent of recorded deaths were inflicted by killing, in the century of two Great Wars, the Holocaust and some minor naughties like the Holodomor, Cambodia, Rwanda etc. just about 1.3 percent. It seems humans don't have to be taught to suppress a "natural" kill inhibition, but to suppress a natural tendency to kill. You know, I guess there is a reason, God Allmighty had to forbid it explicitly in almost all of his writings from time immemorial. It's always itching the brains of his loverly creatures so much that somehow they can't let it go. By the way, those Japanese believed wholeheartedly they did it for a greater good and it would strengthen them to inflict severe fear, pain and death on their enemies. They didn't needed to be desensitized.
- carapace 4y agoWith apologies to those for whom this is just dreamstuff... A long time ago I was trying various therapists to get help with some personal problems, and one of them did something that they called "germ-line regression". This was like a hypnotic past life regression, but rather than going back through previous incarnations, it was going back through the genetic line of my ancestors. We went back to a man who lived in Europe at the time when the Romans were making inroads up there. His name was something like "Otygh" and he was a huge "Conan the Barbarian"-looking dude, biggest and toughest guy in his village. He was pretty much the top of the local food chain and social hierarchy, no one above him but the gods themselves. And then the Romans show up... They're short (not too short, there were standards, but shorter than the barbarians), smelly (garlic eaters, eh?), weak and (seemingly) stupid, they're like beast-men, orcs. They should be easy to defeat, every other living thing has been, but damned if they don't keep winning fights! They always win!? WTF!? How is this possible? I can't exaggerate the rage and frustration Otygh felt at losing to these Romans. It was totally incomprehensible. For what it's worth, which may not be much, Otygh loved battle. Far from terrifying, it was exhilarating, right up until he started losing and the Romans torched his village and killed or enslaved everybody he knew and loved. Don't shed any tears for him, he was a murderous dickhead who did the very same thing to other villages.
- the_biot 4y agoIf that helped you, or at least gave you some enjoyment in a fun story to tell, good for you. But you should know that the therapist that did this was an absolute quack. Please, don't seek help from quacks.
- carapace 4y ago> If that helped you, or at least gave you some enjoyment in a fun story to tell, good for you. It did help, not enough to keep going to that therapist but it helped. (I left out the cathartic part of the story/dream.) > But you should know that the therapist that did this was an absolute quack. What would happen if I didn't know that?
- JoeDaDude 4y agoPhilip Sabin, quoted in TFA, is a professor at King's College London with a long list of publications related to warfare [1]. He is also known as a war game designer where he puts his ideas in rule sets designed to simulate the battles he has studied. See his list of game credits in [2]. [1]. https://www.kcl.ac.uk/people/professor-philip-sabin https://www.kcl.ac.uk/people/professor-philip-sabin [2]. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamedesigner/6341/philip-sabin/linkeditems/boardgamedesigner https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamedesigner/6341/philip-sabi...
- bee_rider 4y agoIt would be interesting to try and model this scenario in a videogame (the Total War series has a morale system of course, but it doesn't seem to quite match this description -- units with good "leadership" bonuses can sustain fighting basically from full strength to death), or a pen-and-paper RPG (the idea that the neutral state of armies is a sort of stand-off situation could be beneficial for a couple reasons -- mechanically simpler with less going on, the players can perform heroic feats in the stand-off area, and the psychological differences between the various fantasy races could play with the scenario interestingly).
- ilovecurl 4y ago'Why was cold steel a “unique terror” for troops in combat?' The most terrifying part of Saving Private Ryan is private Mellish's death after hand to hand combat with a knife.
- gigaflop 4y agoI haven't seen that movie in a while, but the gist of that scene is burned into my brain. The grossest death of the movie, IMO, and it isn't even that gory.
- lifeisstillgood 4y ago>>> combat as a dynamic balance of mutual dread enough said ...
- AlbertCory 4y agoA book [1] that's nearly 30 years old now by one of the best military historians of his age, John Keegan: The Face of Battle. It looks at what it was actually like to be there, in the midst of it, at three famous battles. I need to read it again. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Face-Battle-Study-Agincourt-Waterloo/dp/0140048979/ref=sr_1_1 https://www.amazon.com/Face-Battle-Study-Agincourt-Waterloo/...?