6 ms·
Nuclear power can help the democratic world achieve energy independence
- mikewarot 4y agoNuclear fission power is a good base power supplier for electrical grids, if properly managed and operated. It emits far fewer toxic and radioactive substances than coal fired power plants (leaving aside the CO2). It does NOT, however, solve the problem of liquid fuels necessary for most of our global transportation infrastructure. It does take the strain off of those uses where they are consumed for electricity generation, so that's a plus. We've got an energy crisis rapidly approaching as the energy required to get a barrel of oil out of the ground begins to reach break-even. If we fail to make the adjustments in time, we're in for a great simplification of society, with all the collapse and death that implies. Nuclear is a bridge we should use to reach that post-oil future.
- hakfoo 4y agoI feel like the liquid fuel problem is much more manageable with a proper heirarchical transport model. Railways are easily electrifiable (century-plus proven technology). Rip out the Interstates and run networks of higher speed and local rail systems. Electrify existing freight corridors. Then you're just using liquid fuels for the relatively short last-mile journeys to or from a rail station. That's far less of a range anxiety problem, so even an old Leaf with 75km range will suffice for many. The problem isn't the technology, it's the political will to be able to say "No, you shouldn't/can't drive anymore" to hundreds of millions of people.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mikewarot 4y agoHow are airlines or ships supposed to work? How are tug boats going to navigate the Mississippi?
- tluyben2 4y agoIs there any progress on those Small Nuclear Reactors (SMR)? The promise was 3-5 year builds for one unit and allowing builds in parallel to deploy multiple units and hooking them up to form practical larger plants. But it seems it cooled a bit now? It would appear to be perfect for the EU situation and there would be a lot of money and interest I guess. It is just hard to find concrete and up to data information.
- 2trill2spill 4y agoChina has built a couple HTR SMR[1] and is also currently building a PWR SMR[2]. And in the United States, Nuscale is looking to have the UAMPS project starting to supply energy in 2029[3]. [1]: https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Demonstration-HTR-PM-connected-to-grid https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Demonstration-HT... [2]: https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Chinese-SMR-containment-takes-shape https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Chinese-SMR-cont... [3]: https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Fieldwork-completed-in-milestone-for-UAMPS-SMR https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Fieldwork-comple...
- ncmncm 4y agoIt is all fluff. SMR means many more moving parts for the same aggregate output. No nuke can begin to approach the opex, never mind capex, of renewables + storage. So, each dollar put toward nukes produces proportionally less energy, and brings climate disaster nearer. During the ten years from breaking ground to turning on, the money spent on coal in the meantime would pay for as much solar as needed to match the nuke's output, but the solar would begin producing and displacing carbon immediately. Soon, even new nukes will be mothballed except where government coercion and taxes force people to pay extra for their output.
- credit_guy 4y ago> It is all fluff. SMR means many more moving parts for the same aggregate output. You say that, but NuScale spent half a billion dollars of only private money to get the NRC approval for their SMR [1]. If they thought the SMR was uneconomical, would they have done that? [1] https://www.nuscalepower.com/newsletter/nucleus-fall-2020/program-development-update https://www.nuscalepower.com/newsletter/nucleus-fall-2020/pr...
- ImHereToVote 4y ago"democratic world"
- helloworld11 4y agoYes indeed, because there are genuinely more democratic countries than others. China for example is very different from the United States or Canada in terms of governance, and so too is this the case if you compare say, Cuba and the Netherlands or any other number of western European states.
- moronicwebsite 4y ago
- freemint 4y agoAnd what about the non-democratic world? Do we want every country to run nuclear power plants? Would you want foreign governments and countries running nuclear plants in your country? One way to help with that would be to have nuclear plants in trusted countries, but will they stay trusted and will other countries accept being dependent on a one sided dependence on power? Those questions are (in addition to cost concerns) why nuclear is not a tech i see helping the world moving forward. Solar/renewable could foster entirely energy independent countries with a ton of storage or my preferred option, a global grid having sun 24/7 and robust to seasons due to production on both hemispheres. That way we are all interconnected and keep trading even if long distance trade becomes verboten.
- kleene_op 4y ago>Solar/renewable could foster entirely energy independent countries with a ton of storage or my preferred option, a global grid having sun 24/7 and robust to seasons due to production on both hemispheres. That's pretty cool but I'd rather we achieved energy independence this millennia.
- freemint 4y agoBuilding under sea cables between asia and europe already exist, an undersea cable between NA and Europe would be profitable, so would be a cross Mediterranean power connection.
- ncmncm 4y agoAnything but renewables brings global catastrophe and civilization collapse nearer. Collapse of civilization would deliver a kind of energy independence, but maybe not the kind you want. Power from renewables is so radically cheaper than anything else ever known that not building it out as fast as possible costs strictly more. That building out renewables fast enough might fend off global catastrophe is an extra benefit. Building nukes would steal capital from building out renewables.
- forum_ghost 4y ago
- jgelsey 4y agoThere's no cheaper electricity source then renewables, by a long shot. Why bother with nuclear? https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-levelized-cost-of-storage-and-levelized-cost-of-hydrogen/ https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-... https://rameznaam.com/2020/05/14/solars-future-is-insanely-cheap-2020/ https://rameznaam.com/2020/05/14/solars-future-is-insanely-c...
- ncmncm 4y agoRenewables offer less scope for fully-legal corruption. Nukes still lead, there. SMRs might leave less scope for it, and if so can be counted on to gain little traction.
- TrumpRapedWomen 4y ago
- forum_ghost 4y agoWhy bother with nuclear: 1. fields belong to trees, grass, animals, not to some ugly panels that were produced with millions of tons of toxic waste that was then dumped into the ocean. 2. windmills are ugly, kill birds, ruin microclimate. 3. Additional expertise in fission will lead to more capital, talent, and mindshare available to develop fusion further. How would a spacefaring civilization get off from this rock and survive without nukes? Colonization of planets cannot happen without them. Renewables is just the Sun, rebadged, nothing "renewable" about it.
- plaguepilled 4y agoThe impact of windmills is not as bad as you imply, and the pollutant threat is still far lower than alternatives. We should not destroy this planet JUST so that we can colonise other planets. That is risky at best, self-sabotaging at worst. (The climate disaster is not an excuse to say 'we have to colonise other planets or we're toast!' BTW)
- plaguepilled 4y agoI'll confess I am not nearly informed enough on international relations nor nuclear security to make a judgement call here, so let me know if I'm looking at this wrong, but: Wasn't there a big worry about the Russian siege of that one Ukrainian nuclear plant? So, if the world at large is worried about Russia being hostile to them, doesn't nuclear energy represent a weakened security posture?