3 ms·
Only in the sense that people are bad with numbers and timescales, and that the fears themselves directly led to funding for research that happened to be succes
by ben_w 4y ago
Only in the sense that people are bad with numbers and timescales, and that the fears themselves directly led to funding for research that happened to be successful at creating affordable solutions.
The fictional population of NYC in Soylent Green (released 1973, set in 2022) was 40 million, whereas the actual population today is 8.8 million, but even 40 million would give it about the population density of Manila today and wouldn’t look like it was portrayed in the film.
With sufficient industrial farming effort[0] and only existing technology, we could support something like 10 trillion on Earth, but if we did that then everything that wasn’t a farm would look like the top of the Wikipedia list of highest density city districts.
As for the correspondence between the rat experimental world and the human world, as the article itself says:
> Given these wildly varying (even contradictory) readings, it’s hard to escape the suspicion that personal and political views, rather than objective inquiry, are driving these critics’ outlooks. And indeed, a closer look at the interpretations severely undermines them.
Also, we aren’t mice, so while we are doing various — and in some cases, unhealthy — things in response to our world of high abundance and low child mortality, we are doing different things, more slowly, and with the ability to discover and respond to the big picture.
[0] the material requirements are on par with paraterraforming the Moon, because the first step is “make enough greenhouses for most of the land on the planet”, but it could be done.
- NeoTar 4y ago> The fictional population of NYC in Soylent Green (released 1973, set in 2022) was 40 million, whereas the actual population today is 8.8 million, but even 40 million would give it about the population density of Manila today and wouldn’t look like it was portrayed in the film. Another example is Isaac Asimov's Trantor, a world-wide city enclosed with globes which requires the resources of multiple agricultural worlds to sustain it. It has a population of 45 billion, and a surface area of approx. 40% that of Earth. Do the calculations, and the population density is, as Wikipedia says: "similar to the current population density of Germany or Connecticut. " I can't speak for Connecticut, but Germany certainly doesn't feel crowded. Even in central Berlin we have a huge amount of green space. Even Coruscant in Star Wars, with a population of 1 trillion people (1 000 000 000 000) has a population density less than New York City.
- rsynnott 4y ago> It has a population of 45 billion, and a surface area of approx. 40% that of Earth. I think he retconned this up a bit in later stories, after people had pointed out the problem. But yeah, it's a weirdly common problem in science fiction; for whatever reason few authors bothered to check the density of existing cities before declaring a weirdly sparse world-city.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoYou could explain away the discrepancy by saying that the 45 billion number is the number of permanent residents. As the seat of a galactic empire it would likely host representatives and their staff and families from tens of thousands of worlds, would probably be a hub of interstellar trade with many merchants and the crew of their ships staying for weeks at a time, a major tourist and religious hub with billions of visitors and pilgrims, countless numbers of galactic citizens would also make the journey to petition the emperor for various things. The list could go on for a mile and could result in a much larger effective population at any one time.
- chaostheory 4y agoIt’s hard to take making sense of population numbers with the use of fictional material.