3 ms·
> 13 pins in two unequal rows were plugged into a socket on the circuit board. I suspect this was done to ensure the device could only be plugged in one way.
by WalterBright 4y ago
> 13 pins in two unequal rows were plugged into a socket on the circuit board.
I suspect this was done to ensure the device could only be plugged in one way.
This technique was forgotten by the time I worked on designing embedded systems. All kinds of devices (chips, caps, diodes, etc.) had symmetrical pinouts, so they could be plugged in the right way, or the wrong way (and would burn out as a result). At least the #1 pin on a chip had a slight depression over it. We always designed chip circuit boards so the #1 pin was always in one direction, so a visual scan of the completed board would verify the chips were all in the right way.
The board was also set up so the diodes were all pointed the same way, caps too.
Of course, the chips could still be plugged in off-by-one.
Sometimes mathematical symmetry is just a bad idea. I had an old Benz that had a mechanical fuel injection system that sat on a splined shaft. There was no key spline. If you got the spline off by one, you couldn't tell until they engine ran poorly. What a wretched design.
Boeing always used keyed splines if orientation made any difference. 4 hole bolt patterns were never symmetrical so the device could only be bolted on one, the correct, way.
It was so catastrophic to hook up hydraulics to the wrong ports that the supply and return ports used different size fittings, color codes, and even one port was left-hand and the other right-hand to prevent swapping them. The ports were placed so the tubes could not reach the wrong port.
Even then, now and then some mechanic would fashion an "adapter" in order to hook them up wrong, which is why they are also tested after assembly for correct polarity.
- andyjohnson0 4y ago> We always designed chip circuit boards so the #1 pin was always in one direction, so a visual scan of the completed board would verify the chips were all in the right way. The board was also set up so the diodes were all pointed the same way, caps too. I'm not an EE, but wouldn't this have the potential to significantly complicate the layout of traces on the board? I assume you're talking about hand-assembled boards, and hand-drawn too?
- WalterBright 4y agoSurprisingly, it worked out rather well. Of course, the boards those days weren't so tight, either.