3 ms·
Passkeys are such a great idea that is for sure going to be ruined by implementers clinging stupidly hard to their “secure enclaves” making them a huge PITA to
by Spivak 4y ago
Passkeys are such a great idea that is for sure going to be ruined by implementers clinging stupidly hard to their “secure enclaves” making them a huge PITA to actually use.
It should be as simple as storing your private keys in your password manager, browser keychain, in a folder, or USB stick, Yubikey, or anywhere the user damn well pleases.
You should be able to easily export presigned tickets for recovery, support CA style auth for advanced users, and support passcode challenges (ie site gives you a short code you type in and your vault spits out a code) for cases where getting the two devices to talk directly is hard.
- RL_Quine 4y agoThat's not really how they're meant to be used. Want multiple keys? Register multiple devices. Copying the same key around willy nilly just means you can't revoke access selectively. Not being able to export keys and mishandle them is kind of a design goal rather than a limitation.
- exmadscientist 4y agoThat's because WebAuthn in general is a poor match to most lower-stakes uses of passwords. Not everything is a bank account. Many things are appropriately authenticated using "just" a password manager. WebAuthn refuses to acknowledge that, because it's a standard born of corporate security officers serving their own ends. It's still appropriate for some things an average human or techie human does, but not everything, and its promoters need to stop acting like it is the only game in town.
- iggldiggl 4y agoSo every time I sign up somewhere I need to dig out all devices (including possible off-site backups if I was really thorough?) and sign them all up, too? If yes, then that doesn't sound particularly enticing…
- sally1620 4y agoAs the tidbits article says, only the client is proprietary. I am sure that eventually a fully open-source Linux version of this is going to be developed and integrated into Seahorse.