3 ms·
I think it would behoove you to read this entire thread again. I'm not particularly interested in defending some kind of absolute prohibition against firearms f
by woodruffw 4y ago
I think it would behoove you to read this entire thread again. I'm not particularly interested in defending some kind of absolute prohibition against firearms from a constitutional perspective, because I know of no such argument.
Here are two points I've made, both of which I think are defensible:
* SCOTUS has repeatedly recognized that the Second Amendment does not reflect an absolute right to either own or employ guns however individuals would like. In particular, SCOTUS has recognized that both the states and the Federal Government have rightfully and reasonably regulated concealed firearms, and that there is no constitutional threat to such regulation as long as it does not constitute prohibition. The Federal precedent for such regulation goes back to 1897 and is not meaningfully adapted by either McDonald 2010 or Bruen 2022 (which both preserve "shall issue," like you've mentioned).
* There is a reasonable public interest in knowing who receives a CCW permit, one that is not impeded by the current "shall issue" standard. That public interest complements the current privacy standards under most states' FOIA/FOIL-style laws. You can see above and adjacent comment threads for why I think this is.