6 ms·
Looks like more fossil-fuel promotion FUD. CO2 to methanol is energetically uphill. This is going to take energy to do. A lot of energy. It's likely to be ins
by Animats 4y ago
Looks like more fossil-fuel promotion FUD.
CO2 to methanol is energetically uphill. This is going to take energy to do. A lot of energy.
It's likely to be insanely wasteful of energy, like using solar power to make electricity to crack water into hydrogen so the hydrogen can be burned to make electricity. That's about 40% efficient, nobody does it, but it's used as a talking point.
Producing energy without generating CO2 is now both easier and cheaper than trying to do something with the CO2 from burning fuels.
- oifjsidjf 4y ago"Imagine the amount of brainwashing it took from the oil industry to convince people that cows are the problem instead of the oil industry".
- samstave 4y ago[0] - the old interview that supposedly states the origin of "fossil Fuels" by Oil Exec... [1] - One of the many articles refuting [0] --- [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2RC9DgbJtM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2RC9DgbJtM [1] - https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-fossil-fuel-rockefeller/fact-check-the-term-fossil-fuel-was-not-coined-by-john-d-rockefeller-to-trick-people-into-thinking-oil-is-a-scarce-commodity-idUSL1N2QQ1UK https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-fossil-fuel-rockef...
- missedthecue 4y agoBut this pull CO2 out of the air and puts it to good use, whereas building solar panels only prevents future CO2 emissions. They are different goals.
- lozenge 4y agoThis doesn't pull CO2 out of the air. CO2 in the air is at 420ppm meaning you would need to process a huge amount of air to get a significant amount of methanol. This pulls CO2 out of "where carbon dioxide occurs in maximum concentration - for example directly in the exhaust gas stream of large industrial plants". One example would be fossil fuel power plants... It's an interesting technology but is bound to be co-opted by those who will pretend it is a reason to allow fossil fuel extraction to continue without limit. Eg [1] Also, many uses for methanol, such as as a fuel additive, release the carbon back into the atmosphere. Once the fossil fuel is extracted and burned, the carbon has moved from the slow cycle to the fast cycle - and it'll stay there.[2] [1] https://www.climatecouncil.org.au/resources/ccs-will-not-solve-this-problem-energy-expert-responds-to-expected-morrison-government-announcement/ https://www.climatecouncil.org.au/resources/ccs-will-not-sol... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_cycle#:~:text=Fast%20and%20slow%20cycles,-The%20slow%20carbon&text=The%20fast%20or%20biological%20cycle,%2C%20soil%2C%20ocean%20and%20atmosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_cycle#:~:text=Fast%20an....
- nomel 4y ago> whereas building solar panels only prevents future CO2 emissions That's a little simplistic. The biological systems on the earth are a carbon sink. Not adding CO2 causes a reduction in CO2, many orders of magnitude more than humans could hope to accomplish by pulling it out of the air with non-biological contraptions.
- Semiapies 4y agoIt's just a university press release. They exist to wildly overhype every mildly interesting project in hopes of getting attention and support for the institution in question. Now that HN get far fewer "random university student's silly CAD design project treated as a real, upcoming invention" submissions this last decade or so, they're one of my least-favorite types of submissions to HN.
- hotpotamus 4y agoThe theory is that you make "electro fuels" compatible with existing ICE vehicles. The idea is that if the costs of solar keep decreasing and the costs to extract and refine oil keep increasing, you hit an inflection point where this is economically feasible and as a byproduct possibly save the planet. Here's an example startup https://terraformindustries.com/ https://terraformindustries.com/
- SoftTalker 4y agoYes, the idea is that if solar energy is "free" (it's not, but set that aside for sake of argument) then it doesn't matter how inefficient the process is. The downside of this process seems to be that it doesn't extract atmospheric CO2 to make methanol, it converts CO2 from concentrated industrial waste streams. It's perhaps "better than nothing" but the methanol will probably end up as CO2 again later (if it's used as fuel, for example) so it really isn't as great as it might sound.
- VectorLock 4y agoCapturing CO2 to be burned elsewhere sounds like releasing half the CO2. Not great, but better?
- ncmncm 4y agoNo, it re-releases all of it.
- moralestapia 4y agoAnd a bit more because producing it wasn't free.
- VectorLock 4y agoBut then you're only releasing it once, rather than twice as much. Hence: half.
- 4y ago
- aaronblohowiak 4y agoWith methanol, density is higher and storage costs are lower than batteries though, right? Those things may matter depending on application. Like, building battery banks to store energy for a season? no way. building tanks to store methanol? maybe?! I dont know.
- funcDropShadow 4y agoGoing that route has some promising aspects if you look at a larger picture. If you can get clean methan via hydrogen powered by solar, wind, or water you don't have to replace huge amounts of machinery right now. Replacing millions and millions of natural gas heaters all over Europe will also emit huge amounts CO₂ in the atmosphere. If we could continue to use them until their normal end of life with CO₂ neutral fuel, that could be a real benefit. And the life span of heating units is often measured in decades. Your rant also neglected that storing electricity directly is hardly a solved problem at scale. Whereas transporting and storing methan has a huge existing infrastructure.
- Enginerrrd 4y agoI don't know the specifics of this idea, but there's actually some merit to the more general idea you are denouncing. There are processes in which you can take some fuel, and add in some low-quality (i.e. low temperature) heat that would otherwise be wasted, and some CO2, and get more energy in the form of fuel out. Some of these things actually look like they have potential if you can get the catalyst.
- random314 4y ago> CO2 to methanol is energetically uphill. This is going to take energy to do. A lot of energy. What if we use "free" solar energy for this. This could also be a carbon sequestration technique. It might not make sense now, but 20 years down the line - when most power generation is green except jet fuels, ships and reserve gasoline to electric generators. Bottomline, it could accelerate the shuttering down of oil wells 20 years from now.
- dv_dt 4y agoAlso isn't escaped methanol a worse greenhouse gas than CO2 (86x worse by a quick search).
- KAMSPioneer 4y agoI'm fairly sure that you're thinking of methane, CH4, which is a gas at normal temperature/pressure. Methanol is a simple alcohol, is liquid at home temperature/pressure, and I don't believe it has the same extreme GG effect as methane.
- bartimus 4y agoBut what's cool is that the energy is easily stored and transported. 40% efficiency is fine as long as production is cheap.
- vkou 4y agoIt's not 40% efficient at turning CO2 in the atmosphere into fuel (If we had a technology that could do that, I would not worry at all about climate change), it's 40% efficient at turning highly concentrated CO2, from say, the chimney stack of a coal power plant into fuel. Which is what makes it nearly-useless. The solution to energy generation that emits CO2 is not trying to recover it from the chimney. The solution is eliminating it. This can solve the problem of concentrated CO2 emitted as an industrial byproduct of non-energy-generating chemical processes, but that is not a major contributor [1] to our carbon emissions. [1] Cement manufacturing is often pointed to as a major CO2 emitter... Yet it is responsible for ~1.5% of emissions in the US (~8% in China). So, you could make a bit of a dent in a small fraction of our emissions, but it doesn't come remotely close to solving the overall emissions problem.
- bartimus 4y agoI disagree with the idea that we shouldn't build capturing innovations on top of chimney CO2 emissions just because we need to eliminate those chimney emissions. Yes, we should reduce chimney emissions. But it appears that isn't going to be as easy as we'd like. It's why we're seeing various European countries turning on their coal plants again because Russia turned off the gas. We really need to have these capturing innovations that happen at the chimney too. I wrote this other comment a couple of days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31850610 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31850610 I don't see us succeeding in reducing our dependency on fossil fuels in the near future. We can achieve some reductions at national level. But these fossil fuels are simply going to find a customer somewhere else. It would be better if the West can provide cheap sustainable fuels or export/sponsor CO2 capturing solutions for foreign countries.
- aaron695 4y ago
- kmonsen 4y agoYeah, the key issue is energy. If we have unlimited energy we can deal with climate change in so many ways. Unless there is a full energy accounting it is just useless at this point.