4 ms·
The global economy does not really have a carbon problem. It has an energy problem. That is, if you take the energy required to turn CO2 into methanol, why not
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
The global economy does not really have a carbon problem. It has an energy problem.
That is, if you take the energy required to turn CO2 into methanol, why not just use that energy directly in the things that need it? I'm not saying this is entirely useless, because obviously with renewables the biggest problem is energy storage, but too often I feel announcements like this lead with the "we can turn atmospheric CO2 in gasoline" while glossing over the crux of the problem, which is where does that energy come from in the first place.
- inglor_cz 4y agoMethanol may be more transportable than electricity. Imagine a farm of floating wind farms far in the ocean, located in places where the wind conditions are reliable. If they produce methanol, you do not have to run a long power cable to the nearest shore, you just need to visit them every now and then with a cistern ship.
- tunesmith 4y agoIsn't part of the answer that we actually need to reduce the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere? It's not sufficient to just get to net-zero.
- outworlder 4y ago> why not just use that energy directly in the things that need it That's a very important point. However, sometimes you can't use the energy - like we can't eat CO2 + sunlight, but plants can turn that into something usable. Methanol is useful for chemical processes. The US Navy was looking into fuel production in aircraft carriers, which involved CO2 sequestration. That's useful since they have the spare power. And so on. It may also indirectly avoid more emissions - the CO2 being used has to be transported from somewhere, be it coal, oil, or other sources.
- elil17 4y agoTwo thoughts on this: Good progress is being made on the clean electricity generation front. But distribution and storage are huge challenges. CO2 utilization processes solve distribution and storage challenges. Many CO2 capture processes need heat, not necessarily electricity. That really changed the landscape of effective energy sources (e.g. nuclear looks ~3x cheaper per thermal kWh vs. per electric kWh according to a researcher I spoke to). Solar thermal also starts to look practical (and for many processes the energy intensive sorbent regeneration step, unlike the air contractors, is not capex constrained so you don’t really care that it only runs when the sun is shining.
- ncmncm 4y agoNuclear only ever looks cheap if you hide costs -- decommissioning cost, disaster insurance cost, fuel disposal cost. And, its acknowledged operating cost is high. Concentrated solar thermal is cheaper; the failed projects had misdirected their efforts to electric generation.
- vgel 4y agoI think your question is "why burn fossil fuels for energy, then use more energy to clean their exhaust streams, instead of using that energy in the first place instead of fossil fuels?" If so, I think the purpose of this research is to process the exhaust streams of industrial processes that create lots of CO2 for reasons other than energy. For example, steel production produces a lot of CO2 due to chemical reactions used to remove impurities from iron, even if the blast furnace runs entirely on renewable energy. This process would, hypothetically, allow us to input more renewable energy to capture the exhaust CO2 and make steelmaking more carbon neutral.
- goodpoint 4y agoThe global economy does not have a carbon, energy, plastic, particulate problem. It has an inequality problem.
- Johnny555 4y agoThere are still some processes that are hard to make carbon free -- like cement production, for example. Even ignoring the energy needed for heat, the chemical process itself creates CO2, which a process like this could sequester.