3 ms·
> Only in the 18th century did grammarians declare that the singular they was invalid, their reasoning being that a plural pronoun can’t take a singular anteced
by mdp2021 4y ago
> Only in the 18th century did grammarians declare that the singular they was invalid, their reasoning being that a plural pronoun can’t take a singular antecedent. [...] According to these sticklers, it made more sense to use he as a “gender-neutral” pronoun when describing one person
> The conventions of a language are shaped by the general population that uses it daily
That author calls academicians «sticklers», which may be read as a diminishing qualifier, and seems to assume that the «conventions of a language» are equivalent to the language - a conventionalist depreciating competence.
Not really the approach to convince the skeptics.
Well, it will be interesting and comforting for those acquainted with languages which use academically confirmed, established "gender neutral masculine form", to meet the notion that the same was academically defended for the English language.