3 ms·
The medium is the message^W affordance. During the aughts, I got used to saying "Linux is not Windows" --- if you're looking for a Microsoft experience on a Fr
by dredmorbius 4y ago
The medium is the message^W affordance.
During the aughts, I got used to saying "Linux is not Windows" --- if you're looking for a Microsoft experience on a Free Software operating system ... you're liable to be disappointed.
If you accept the strengths, and weaknesses, of a platform, you're going to be far happier.
The first computers I used didn't have e-ink displays. They had ink displays. Teletype access to an early Unix system, mostly offering BSD games. No, I didn't do Real Work on those systems....
But I was doing real work on glass-tty VT-200 Wyse terminals about a decade later, also on campus-wide Unix servers. (Benefit: walk into any terminal room, log on, and all my work was Just There.)
As I've noted for a while, E-Ink has features which differ from emissive (OLED / LCD) displays:
- Persistence is free. Once the display is set, it does not change, even with power shut off.
- Pixels are cheap. Current displays tend around 220--300 DPI. That's the effective resolution of most laserprinters (given toner drift and paper coarseness).
- Refreshes are ... slowish. Not seconds, but 4-10 Hz is a typically upper end, rather than 60--120 FPS of an emissive display. Higher-quality refreshes may be slower.
- Colors are nonexistent to few. My monochrome display offers 16 greyscale shades, though with dithering and/or halftoning, that increases. Photographs appear slightly posterised without those. Colour displays exist, though they're limited in size/format, muted in saturation, slower than B&W e-ink, and carry a price premium.
- Paginated navigation is strongly preferred to scrolling. A single whole-screen flush is much better than scrolling a pixel at a time. This is where EInkBro really shines over conventional tablet browsers, in that it supports paginated navigation through a web page.
- Displays are reflective rather than emissive. The brighter the ambient light, the easier the display is to read, with direct sunlight being the optimum. I suspect colour displays will also reflect a mix of ink-vs-light colour design / mixing.
Ultimately, e-ink applications and platforms should play to the medium's strengths. E-Ink does fixed text and graphics exceptionally well. Operating systems, graphical shells, and controls which reflect this should do well. Those that fight these characteristics will deliver disappointing experiences.
- ladyattis 4y agoYep, I think there's no need to make e-ink into a competitor for oled or lcd monitors. Something like a tablet or small purpose built computer like a POS machine with built in scanner and card reader is something I think would fit best for this kind of display rather than forcing LCD/OLED to handle small form factors but somehow compete on power usage.
- dredmorbius 4y agoMy suggestion is somewhat different. It's that e-ink is a viable display, but that it provides a different set of capabilities which must be recognised in the tools (applications, interfaces) which are used on it. Some of those already exist, others might have to be developed or tweaked. And platforms in which the display endpoint is not predefined (e.g., Web content), consideration of e-ink and other alternative display formats and factors will have to be increasingly considered either be designers or by application developers. Again, EinkBro is an examplar of the latter: an e-ink optimised Web browser with a specific design philosophy informed by the characteristics of e-ink displays. (I've had numerous exchanges with the developer, Daniel Kao, and he gets it.) https://github.com/plateaukao/browser https://github.com/plateaukao/browser Text- and static-graphic-centric presentation works well. High-colour and dynamic displays don't. A large set of traditional text-mode tools (e.g., traditional Unix/Linux userland, and tools inspired by these) work quite well, as do many graphical presentations so long as they respect the properties of the display. I've reflected a fair bit on the MOAD (mother of all demonstrations), now 54 years in our past. MOAD was based on the principles of high-framerate emissive displays, and virtually all elements shown in the demonstration remain the core elements of present-generation graphical displays, despite the migration from CRT to LED to OLED/Plasma displays. All effectively are emissive and low-latency. Another alternative would be to adopt different display options. LCD (or transflective LCD) is one option; these work fundamentally by light polarisation, which means that they halve whatever ambient or backlight intensity is provided, greatly reducing apparent contrast. What might be interesting would be a materials advance in which substances or fluid cells transition between primary colour states, giving the ability to directly create static pixels of a given colour, under some influence --- electric or magnetic influence, perhaps some induced pH state change. If that's a durable shift (e.g., there's a stable state that isn't changed until a new stimulus is applied), then we'd have a new display technology. That might even give a true ink-mixing behaviour, if, say, a given fluid cell or particle fibre might include multiple colour elements which would mix as paint or ink pigments do. Any material scientists know of materials which transition between white and CMYK spectra? Advantages of E-Ink include not only power but readability in high-ambient light situations, or under normal room lighting rather than requiring an independently illuminated display as with LCD screens. Depending on how displays are specifically addressed, the possibility of arbitrarily large displays at lower costs might also exist. That ... would be interesting. I have the usual present fear: that these would be appropriated principally for advertising and propaganda on wall- or building-sized form factors.