4 ms·
Alas, I would love to implement this, but the world of eink is filled with patents and lawsuits, and I think that if I implemented this and it worked well I cou
by londons_explore 4y ago
Alas, I would love to implement this, but the world of eink is filled with patents and lawsuits, and I think that if I implemented this and it worked well I could never sell it. Even if I gave it away for free, I'd probably have lawyers banging on my door wanting to take away my home.
- pooper 4y agoPlease excuse my ignorance but are there new patents coming in every year or is it more like mp3 where we had a patent but eventually it expired? My question is like will we have e ink in about twenty years?
- londons_explore 4y agoWhile any company is trying to do R&D and sell product, there tends to be new patents each year. That means there never a nice 20 year boundary when it becomes safe to build on top of the tech, because you'll always have the threat of a lawsuit that you are violating one of the newer patents in your implementation. And the costs of such litigation deters investors, even if you would have a good chance of winning.
- bayindirh 4y agoThe methods or refreshing e-ink displays are called "Wave Functions" in e-ink parlance, and they're actually implemented in software. However, somehow they're so closely guarded, and even if you have top of the line e-ink reader, it might not come with a license for a nice Wave Function which refreshes your display very nicely. For example, one of the most attractive features of Kindles is they use the best Wave Functions available for their displays (they may even licensed it exclusively) which refreshes the screens instantly and smoothly. My Kobo, while using the same screen, has more clunky refreshing modes built in. Moreover, it seems, not all methods are provided on every CPU architecture, and you can't see the code of these things. Lastly, these methods are probably improved upon and re-patented to keep the barrier for entry pretty high. New screens are definitely developed with more features, and they need new Wave Functions to work as expected.
- robinsoh 4y ago> The methods or refreshing e-ink displays are called "Wave Functions" in e-ink parlance, and they're actually implemented in software. I've never heard of "wave functions" in the context of electrophoretic displays nor have I ever seen a widely used commercial e-ink controller implement a software update method. Do you mean waveform table? All of them that I've seen in commercial use rely on hardware updates to perform the waveform table processing. Eg: here's the software used to setup the hardware used on most ebook readers: https://github.com/UDOOboard/Kernel_Unico/blob/master/drivers/video/mxc/mxc_epdc_fb.c https://github.com/UDOOboard/Kernel_Unico/blob/master/driver... Could you share some citations or links to what specific thing you're referring to?
- bayindirh 4y agoI've briefly looked for the things I've read in the past but failed to find them currently. Will do when I return home, and will send another reply. I don't like when I can't find the references I remember so vividly.
- russh 4y agohttps://github.com/vroland/epdiy/tree/master/src/epd_driver/waveforms https://github.com/vroland/epdiy/tree/master/src/epd_driver/...
- robinsoh 4y agoPlease clarify what you are attempting to communicate with the link to the header file, otherwise it looks like you just googled and gave a link to something that you yourself don't really understand.
- FullyFunctional 4y agoIt would be hard to miss as it’s required to display anything. However, most dev kits come with a controller which embeds a [proprietary] set of waveforms. That however leaves you with conservative implementations and far from state-of-the-art.
- robinsoh 4y ago> but the world of eink is filled with patents and lawsuits, and I think that if I implemented this and it worked well I could never sell it. Even if I gave it away for free, I'd probably have lawyers banging on my door wanting to take away my home. I work in the display industry. I've never heard anything like what you describe, except on HN comments and blogs that use HN comments as citations. Look at my comment history. I think your claim is false because everytime I've challenged a claim like yours the poster has never been able to substantiate it, but I keep an open mind, if you can provide some real citations backing your claim then I'm happy to be corrected.
- londons_explore 4y ago[patent links. You may or may not want to click] There are lots of patents on electrophoretic displays.[1] And unlike some other industries, these patents are actually used in lawsuits by some players [2]. And anonymous insiders suggest that litigation and threats of litigation, together with enforced secrecy agreements really shape the industry [3]. [1]: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=electrophoretic+display&hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&as_ylo=2010&as_yhi= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=electrophoretic+display... [2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/press-releases/2017-12-20/e-ink-successfully-defends-patent-infringement-case https://www.bloomberg.com/press-releases/2017-12-20/e-ink-su... [3]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26143779 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26143779
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoA link to a single patent lawsuit and a link to an old HN post from a brand new throwaway account which itself provides no citations or links? That's not very persuasive. Both Dasung and Onyx have been able to bring e-ink monitors using their technologies to market so if there's a significant barrier, it's not apparent.
- robinsoh 4y ago> There are lots of patents on electrophoretic displays. There are lots of patents on software. Could you explain your point in greater detail? > And unlike some other industries, these patents are actually used in lawsuits by some players I'm not able to follow. I work in the display industry. What lawsuits are you referencing? What players? How is it any different than the software industry? Anonymous insiders? You mean one HN post that appears nonsensical to a display industry insider who commented on that post and said it sounds like sour grapes from a guy who bought a few displays from Samsung LCD and expects Samsung to give him commercial pricing terms and special support and handholding for his startup?