3 ms·
Back when the Constitution was written, the militia was "all able bodies males" who could be called to service. It wasn't a formal organization like the milita
by refurb 4y ago
Back when the Constitution was written, the militia was "all able bodies males" who could be called to service. It wasn't a formal organization like the military today. It was basically all male citizens.
So that actually aligns with it being an individual right.
- acdha 4y agoThis is leaving out a lot: the militia usually had equipment requirements, was often restricted to men of property, and had training requirements. It especially was not all male citizens - for example, even in the north where the militia didn’t do slave patrols there were often racial restrictions excluding free black men, and the Whigs were big on restricting it to property owners out of fear of groups of armed unattached men being swayed against the local community. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/a-well-regulated-militia-9780195341034 https://global.oup.com/academic/product/a-well-regulated-mil... https://uncpress.org/book/9780807896419/citizens-in-arms/ https://uncpress.org/book/9780807896419/citizens-in-arms/
- bluGill 4y agoTrue, but that eliminates people who belong to groups that we no longer recognize at all. We don't recognize slaves at all, so that slaves can't own guns doesn't matter. Nobody would complain about a law that makes it illegal for slaves to own guns: there are no slaves. Laws that blacks or women are somehow different and thus cannot own guns might be historically supported, but today we elevate those groups to the same level as white land owners, and so they get the rights of white land owners.
- refurb 4y agoSure but we also interpret all other Constitutional rights as belonging to everyone regardless if they were unjustly restricted in the past. Your argument sounds like “we denied black people rights in the past so there for the 2nd amendment right doesn’t apply to everyone.” Weird argument.
- acdha 4y agoIt only sounds weird because you reworded it to remove the main points: even if you ignore the portion about the groups of people who were excluded, you still have the militias being groups with rules and requirements rather than a free-for-all.
- refurb 4y agoRules required to make sure the militia was “well regulated” (functioning properly). But the rules (other than race, money) only excluded those without equipment, everyone was still a part of the militia otherwise.
- acdha 4y agoYou’re leaving out the other parts, most importantly the training and the concept that you were working in a group rather than acting as a lone wolf. Any remotely historical reading does not preclude safety standards and, indeed, American history is full of those and they were not considered controversial prior to 2008.
- refurb 4y agoI'm not sure you understand what the militias looked like during the time the Constitution was created. It was basically "calling all men to service". There was no standing army, membership was fluid and as long as you were able to fulfill the requirements of physical health, bring a weapon, be willing to follow orders.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Back when the Constitution was written, the militia was "all able bodies males" who could be called to service You are focussing on what the militia is (and erroneously pretend that it has changed over time; it still essentially the same thing, see, e.g., the codification in Title 10 of the US Code.) But my point is about what the second amendment says the militia is necessary for, not what the militia is. Because that's the part that is relevant to the claim that the 2nd Amendment provides a right of the type that should be applied by the 14th Amendment to be protected against the states or rather than that explicitly has a role for the benefit of the states and to which the incorporation logic of the 14th Amendment does not apply. Incorporation of rights protected against federal encroachment by the Bill of Rights against the states isn't universal (the requirement of indictment from the 5th Amendment is not incorporated, for instance), even for rights that are expressly individual rights. Incorporation is a separate question.