3 ms·
" ... think that Barack Obama is a looney because he's a practicing Christian ..." Many people deride Sarah Palin for assorted religious beliefs (such as the
by jamesbritt 18y ago
" ... think that Barack Obama is a looney because he's a practicing Christian ..."
Many people deride Sarah Palin for assorted religious beliefs (such as the co-existence of people and dinosaurs) yet there is next to no deriding of Obama for believing that there lived a man who could bring the dead back to life, and who was himself killed and then rose from the dead.
How and where do people draw the line for acceptable bizarre beliefs?
- tptacek 18y agoSo, two things. First, the other comment in this thread, where the commenter talks about all the conversations they have with Christians that are useful and don't wind up offending people? I'm guessing they don't start by calling people's beliefs "bizarre". Bizarre means "strikingly out of the ordinary"; Christianity is one of the most common belief systems on the planet. Just a thought. Second, Palin's beliefs are far outside of the mainstream. Mainstream Christians don't reject the most basic findings of science; plenty of mainstream Christians believe in evolution, the big bang, and quantum mechanics. Palin's beliefs are, by modern standards, eccentric. They also directly impact her job: I have zero problem with a President who believes in the Ten Commandments, but a lot of problems with a President who believes who should ban books on evolution from the libraries. Does that answer your question?
- Herring 18y ago"..common belief systems... far outside of the mainstream.." Good thing you're not saying normal people actually evaluate beliefs according to how popular they are. Because that would be bizarre.
- tptacek 18y agoPalin's beliefs are both noteworthy for how far outside the mainstream they are, and alarming (for a President) on their own merits.
- jamesbritt 18y ago" I'm guessing they don't start by calling people's beliefs "bizarre". Bizarre means "strikingly out of the ordinary"; Christianity is one of the most common belief systems on the planet. Just a thought." If you say, "I am a Christian", few think that bizarre. If you say, "I believe it that someone could bring the dead back to life just by willing it so", many more will think it bizarre. The mundane ubiquity of various religions seems to have shielded people from any real scrutiny of what those religions ask one to believe. And many of those beliefs, common or not, are just plain bizarre. I don't disagree that that Palin's beliefs would have a sooner, greater impact on national life, but do you not think that a president's belief in an afterlife or almighty creator will also effect executive decisions?
- netcan 18y agoHow far out of the American norm would Palin's beliefs be? I understand there is a constant debate about teaching evolution in the States. Presumably this is backed up with a substantial minority. Certainly it is not Bizarre enough to exclude her from gaining traction in a mainstream party (Governor, VP). If a Salafist became a VP in Iraq (a formerly relatively secular country), we would take that of evidence of a move towards more conservative religion. Maybe that's a bad example because at the moment, a Salafist politician in the middle east probably has more immediate political consequences. But all the same, I couldn't imagine a Scientologist VP of the US. I am genuinely asking here. Is the fact that Palin is an acceptable politician a hint that the beliefs are 'mainstream' or does it just mean that religion is really a non0issue in US politics.
- menloparkbum 18y agoI grew up in a community not unlike Palin's home town. In my youth I spent a lot of time traveling to other similar towns. Her beliefs and attitudes are very similar to the mainstream in the rural communities I am familiar with. I will go out on a limb and say that there are quite a few people in rural Montana, the Dakotas, Wyoming, Minnesota, and Idaho who would be Palin supporters. I'm not sure if this can be extended to 'mainstream' in the rest of America, because more people live in big cities and suburbs, which are much different than the rural areas. Even rural areas in other parts of the country seem wildly different. Rural New Mexico, "the South" and Oregon all seemed very different from each other and from anything that I experienced growing up. I'm not sure how Palin would fare in those places.
- bayareaguy 18y agoMainstream Christians don't reject the most basic findings of science; plenty of mainstream Christians believe in evolution, the big bang, and quantum mechanics. Is that really so? I think the majority of Christians aren't familiar enough with any of those things to really know if they believe them. As far as Palin is concerned, after hearing the kinds of bullshit answers she's been giving I've come to think she is a typical ignorant american hypocrite at her core and it would not surprise me if she knew less about specific Christian teachings then she knows about scientific ones.
- bayareaguy 18y agoHow about when they cause problems? Too many people confuse faith with the idea of absolute belief. It's one thing to be faithful to a set of teachings and it's another to believe a particular set of statements to be literally true. I'm no great fan of religion because most require the suspension of inquiry into their core principles when really that's exactly what they should encourage.
- jrockway 18y agoI'm no great fan of religion because most require the suspension of inquiry into their core principles when really that's exactly what they should encourage. I agree here. Religion encourages you to stop looking for answers and to just believe what you're told. Where did the Universe come from? "God made it." Where did God come from? "He has always been." Those answers aren't good enough for me.
- Chocobean 18y agoI agree that those answers aren't good enough when stopped there. But it's not merely limited to religion. How many people understand the evidence of evolution being true, and are able to apologize for it when challenged? There are easy answered for everyone: Evolution made animals; the big bang made the universe. Most people stop at the first reasonable idea passed onto them from authority because it is widely accepted. Don't credit religion for creating in man what was there to start out with, please. Don't be satisfied with easy answers: alway dig deeper for reason. The easy answers to "Why the central basis to every single religion is wrong" is temptingly easy as well. (hint: "it's impossible") What is the basis for ethical behaviour? (hint: "herd instinct/evolutionary advantage") What keeps humanity "going" in the face of understanding that each of us and the universe will die one day? (hint: that "something" will continue on.) Look deeper, keep asking. Jesus' first and greatest commandment, contrary to popular belief, isn't love your neighbour. It was 'Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ Christians are required to use our intellects as part of worship. The first step to understanding anything is to find out what it's all about; making insulting blanket statements and feeling condescendingly superior without actual knowledge is something "the other camp" does, no?
- Chocobean 18y agoJesus once told a parable about sheep going to heaven and goats going to hell. The meaning, I think, is that in the end the church* will be judged by its works: the disciples who fed the poor and did nice things to the least of society were promoted, while the "goat" disciples who refused to be kind to others, were sent away. Most people don't really care whether Obama believes in Zombie Jesus, but they care about whether his interpretation of believing in Jesus leads to actions which they deem unacceptable or unkind to themselves or others. Obama, McCain and Palin are all judged by their actions, not their faith. [PS: Jesus never said anything anyone who wasn't already "part of his flock" to begin with. He judges his own Church the harshest out of anybody. Don't let anyone tell you the fire and brimstone is meant for the unbelievers -- it's always been meant for the flock]