4 ms·
NYC kicked the bums out of Manhattan in the 80s and kept them out through the early 00s. It worked really well. Wealthy people used public transit to get to the
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
NYC kicked the bums out of Manhattan in the 80s and kept them out through the early 00s. It worked really well. Wealthy people used public transit to get to their wall street jobs, and many people walked home alone at night. Fast forward to today, and it's not progressive to go after the bums any more. Now the subway is extremely dangerous and smelly, and nobody but the desperate takes it. The streets are a lot less safe than they used to be.
You can take the bums off the street (and put them in shelters) and your city will get a lot better. It's just very unpopular with progressives, who happen to be the voting base in big cities.
Eventually, things will get bad enough that the progressives leave, and then the streets can get cleaned up again.
- xyzzyz 4y agoI agree with you, but I only have one lifetime, and by the time it plays out in its entirety, I’ll be long retired. Point is, government needs to first clean things up, and then the civil society will move back in, not the other way around.
- codyb 4y agoExtremely dangerous might be a bit much. I ride the subway a fair amount. And there's been an uptick in crime (all over the US), but I wouldn't really call the subway dangerous. NYC houses something like 95% of its homeless as well, which is why we have a lot less people on the streets than in places like LA or SF. But shelter conditions are pretty miserable as I understand it so you can sort of understand the hold outs. And we may just not have enough space. But yea, NYC's a big city, there's definitely some homeless, but I'm not sure my lived experience here is as dire as you make it sound. That being said, some areas are certainly worse than others, and there's definitely some aggressive mentally ill people you'll see here and there.
- WillPostForFood 4y agoNYC houses something like 95% of its homeless as well, which is why we have a lot less people on the streets than in places like LA or SF. This is true, and is the most clear example of how immoral the "housing first" policies in California are. It is a pipe dream that creates a horror show of homeless misery on the streets in LA and SF. The vast majority of the city’s approximately 50,000 homeless people live in shelters — about 30,000 in family shelters, and about 18,000 in shelters for single adults. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/30/nyregion/nyc-homeless-eric-adams.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/30/nyregion/nyc-homeless-eri...
- xhevahir 4y ago> You can take the bums off the street (and put them in shelters) There's your problem, I think. In the US, at least, the elements of our polity that favor "taking the bums off the street" are mostly unwilling to pay for things like shelters and mental hospitals.
- throwaway894345 4y agoI'm a moderate liberal and I would love for my tax dollars to go to pay for shelters and mental hospitals.
- germinalphrase 4y agoThe dearth of mental health institutions is not (directly) because “elements of our polity” don’t want to pay for them. It’s a legacy of actively closing them in the 70’s-80’s due to inhumane conditions and civil libertarian concerns around institutionalizing people against their will. Now - we certainly aren’t having a very productive public conversations about the obvious negative outcomes of that policy shift.
- xhevahir 4y ago"With President Reagan and the Republicans taking over, the Mental Health Systems Act was discarded before the ink had dried and the CMHC funds were simply block granted to the states." https://www.salon.com/2013/09/29/ronald_reagans_shameful_legacy_violence_the_homeless_mental_illness/ https://www.salon.com/2013/09/29/ronald_reagans_shameful_leg... I don't see how anyone can claim that austerity and a deep cynicism toward the very idea of mental treatment didn't play major roles.
- germinalphrase 4y agoNo, of course that is a large part of the story, but things like the Willowbrook expose also caused left-wing politicians (in that case Robert Kennedy) to also attack institutions.
- throwaway894345 4y ago
- deanCommie 4y agoYou're so obsessed with turning "progressive" into a derisive term that you're not being consistent with it. > You can take the bums off the street (and put them in shelters) and your city will get a lot better. It's just very unpopular with progressives, Progressives are absolutely for building more low income housing, and making it available to street bums. It's conservatives who fight 1/ building low income/subsidized housing, 2/ putting that housing in any neighbourhood where they might be in. I don't know what happened in the 80s, or where the bums went. Maybe they all were shipped off to California, where it's warm, and now HN posters complain about IT'S progressive policies. Maybe they all died and nobody in the 80s cared but now they do. Either way, the economic forces that led to them being created in the first place never were fixed, so there is a steady supply of new bums throughout America. Why? What is Europe able to do to keep those people at bay that America isn't?
- xyzzyz 4y ago> It's conservatives who fight 1/ building low income/subsidized housing, 2/ putting that housing in any neighbourhood where they might be in. That’s why, I presume, cities that are thoroughly controlled by Democrats, like San Francisco or Seattle, have no trouble building low income housing and putting it all around the city, right? I mean, conservatives have no government representation in those cities whatsoever, so the Democrat politicians are simply listening to the wishes of their constituents, and as a result, low income housing projects sail through, and housing prices are low, correct?
- plorkyeran 4y agoSan Francisco is extremely progressive in some ways, and extremely conservative in others. There seems to be a general assumption that because SF is very visibly progressive on some high-profile social topics that it must be progressive on all topics, but it's not. More generally, the idea that Democrats cannot be conservative is incorrect, and not just in the leftist "Democrats are right wing" sort of sense. In an effective one-party state you see a lot of people who are ideologically much more aligned with the Republican party running as Democrats, and vice-versa in Republican-dominated states.
- lovich 4y agoUse the subway every time I’m in Manhattan and I barely even see any crazies. It’s about on par with Boston. It’s got some notable events that make it in the news but I think that’s more a function of the population size rather than a noticeable increase in the crazy percentage
- twobitshifter 4y agoHave you been since the pandemic?
- kelnos 4y agoNot the parent, but I've visited Manhattan and Brooklyn a couple times in the past year, and I didn't find the subway scary at all, even when taking trains fairly late at night. Maybe I was just in the safer areas, though.
- lovich 4y agoYes, I was there 2 weeks ago. Mind you I didnt go to every single line and section of the city, only in Manhattan, but literally no issues. Also spent about 3 hours outside smoking until 4 am and only had a single person approach me to bum some change and left with no issue when I told him I didn't carry cash. I have no doubt there are rough parts of the city, but its not all lawlessness and mentally unwell in the streets everywhere.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI used to use it until the pandemic. It's a horror show in comparison now. Some lines used to be horror shows before, too, but it was mostly only bad outside of Manhattan.