6 ms·
If I were a woman, there is no way I would entertain the idea of having kids without my name on the title or lease of the house.
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
If I were a woman, there is no way I would entertain the idea of having kids without my name on the title or lease of the house.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- antisthenes 4y agoAnd if I were a man, there's no way I would just let a house become marital property if I owned it outright before the marriage, especially considering how family courts screw men over. That's a surefire way to homelessness, unless you are very (SV engineer or doctor) rich.
- antiverse 4y agoWhy is this comment downvoted? It's literally what goes through the minds of parents of newly weds and weds-to-be. Let's not beat around the bush and be upfront about it.
- helen___keller 4y agoOff topic. GP and the response from female POV are regarding living in the elders’ house, not the husbands house.
- antiverse 4y agoThat distinction is not worth burying the comment. It was an earnest response, and a valid one at that.
- antisthenes 4y agoI don't see it being buried (author), it seems to stand at neutral karma. But usually such opinions are fairly controversial, which suggests a clash of deeper underlying values.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat is an issue for each couple to work through themselves, but I was more alluding to inhabiting a home belonging to your partner’s parents, not to your partner.
- watwut 4y agoThe property acquired before marriage is yours after divorce. The split part are properties acquired during marriage, unless you have prenup that says otherwise for some reason. That has zero to do with whether it is safe to move into in-laws house when you are entering vulnerable period of pregnancy and being primary caregiver for small kids. Because both severely limit your economic options even in best conditions.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>The property acquired before marriage is yours after divorce That is generally only true until kids are in the picture, then the famous "what is best for the child" over rules all
- hef19898 4y agoExamples please where property was split because of that. Child support obviously takes real estate property into account, but the actual ownership? Not sure where this happens, but than I'm no family law expert and there are so many different countries that it actually just might happen.
- phpisthebest 4y agoJust about everyday in the USA. Family courts take stability of the child over all else, so if the child is used to living in the family home who ever the custodial parent is will get possession of the home even if that custodial parent was not the owner of the home before the marriage
- watwut 4y agoThis is literally not true and specifically not true when that house was acquired by one partner before marriage.
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y agoThis is not the case everywhere; in some jurisdictions, the marital home, even when previously owned free and clear by one of the couple, becomes subject to being split 50:50 at divorce simply because it was the marital home.
- jtsiskin 4y ago… why does gender affect it? As a man, you would be fine with it?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI would not be fine with it as a man, also. All the cultures I am aware where younger couples live with one of the in laws, it is always the woman living with the man and his parents in their home, so my default thought process went to that scenario.
- bombcar 4y agoI suspect either parent would be a bit hesitant in a house that is "officially" owned by someone else "in the family" as it's a power imbalance. And we see that rent-vs-own is a thing as it is, so it fits (I've heard people say they will have kids once they buy their own place, etc).
- gspr 4y ago> If I were a woman, there is no way I would entertain the idea of having kids without my name on the title or lease of the house. There's lots of prosperous countries where renting is very common, is well-regulated, and not some great risk (Germany and Switzerland spring to mind). I, too, live in a country where owning is the norm. That turns the rental market into (mostly) shabby flats for the very lowest income brackets, for students, for migrant workers, or for short-term renting. It doesn't have to be that way.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoSorry, but no. The well regulated rental market in Germany has had the consequence of a housing unit shortage. Try renting anything in well regulated Berlin. It's like trying to find an PS5/ RTX 3080 during the scalpocalipse. Similar in well regulated Stockholm. Renting is very popular in Germany because buying is out of reach for most due to how expensive it is, therefore those who aren't well off have no other choice but to rent, leading to old age poverty for those who don't own their own property by the time they retire. That's why Italian pensioners are statistically better off than their German counterparts despite their country being poorer, because they own their own property at retirement, instead of paying market rent and having to search the city trash bins for empty bottles to make ends meet. Most Germans with financial means or inheritance do own property since it's financially better than renting, especially when your old and living on a measly pension. Not that I don't support rental regulations, I do, but the real estate market in Germany is broken and therefore is not what I consider a model to be followed by everyone.
- iSnow 4y agoBerlin as a yardstick is very problematic. The western part used to be an economic backwater and for a long time after reunification, the city hardly attracted people to live there. It's only in the last 15y that Berlin has been growing like crazy. In general, capital cities in Europe are extremely expensive, no matter whether we are talking about well-regulated Berlin or less-regulated Rome.
- 4y ago