9 ms·
My offer to Google Reader
- dorian-graph 15y agoProblem? Perhaps for this fellow and some others. They might might not be aware there are those who don't care for the social side of Google Reader and use it as a place to keep RSS feeds in sync.
- kfury 15y agoActually, I only made light use of Reader's social features. Aside from their absence (which I do think is a shame) the visual changes to the more newsreader aspects of Reader severely impact the product, and are a big part of what I want to repair.
- joebadmo 15y agoFantastic, constructive, mostly positive response to a somewhat frightening problem. I hope Google takes him up on it.
- ianterrell 15y agoDear God in Heaven please let them take him up on it. Now that I'm a few days into the new redesign my workflow has become 1. Read RSS feeds. 2. Research RSS feed readers.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoMe too, I am definitely in the market for a new RSS reader now.
- ttonelli 15y agoI couldn't take it anymore. After living for a while with the Element Hiding Helper for Adblock Plus, which allowed me to simply hide some of the stupid white space, this last change made Reader essentially unusable. Today I switched to Bloglines, and I can keep using j, k, etc. I have to thank Google, however, for making my switch so easy with their export utility...
- armaanahluwalia 15y agoI don't know if this is considered blatent advertising or not. But I worked pretty hard on getting my chrome extension replacement for google reader done. I would love it if people would check it out. I made it because I couldn't stand the UI for Google Reader in the first place. I'm open to adding features like short cut keys ( fairly easy to implement) Please check it out at http://www.digi-dil.com/MESH http://www.digi-dil.com/MESH
- jfsurban 15y agoNo way to import?
- armaanahluwalia 15y agoI'm currently using JSON to hold feeds but creating a JSON string from OPML should be lemon squeezy... Great idea. Thank you.
- jbigelow76 15y agoWas going to give it a whirl until I saw it was a Chrome extension. I use Chrome but thus far resisted any content formatting extensions. Extensions feel a little too ActiveX control-ish for me.
- armaanahluwalia 15y agoWell I'm not sure how I can convince you other than to say it is quite like running another web page on your browser. Quite literally. Chrome extensions are built using HTML, CSS and Javascript just like anything else on the web. The reason I think this extension makes sense is purely because users should have control over the way in which they read and see content. I'm not a big fan of restrictions being imposed on us just because some designer somewhere thought that's the way it should be. I've built in an editor that let's you create your own viewing interface. Give it a shot!
- rmccue 15y agoWhat are you looking for in a reader? I develop one called Lilina, which aims to be pluggable and themeable, so I'd love to know what sort of things I should be focusing on. (If you'd like to check it out, http://getlilina.org/ http://getlilina.org/ )
- kasbah 15y agoI like it! It is nice and simple. I hope you keep it that way. I think it will be replacing my Google Reader. Two features that would make it perfect for me: - Get rid of the sidebar completely and just allow to navigate through feeds with j and k keys. - Ability to save posts for later.
- dsr_ 15y agoHere's my problem, and I recognize that it is my problem, not yours. As soon as I see that something was written in PHP, my prejudices announce that it is probably badly written and full of security holes.
- Gmo 15y agoDoes it handle smartphone/tablets correctly ? (my current online RSS reader is really not good at that)
- mooism2 15y agoCan I try it out online without downloading and installing it?
- Kototama 15y agoThe RSS reader of www.netvibes.com isn't that bad.
- nemoniac 15y agoThis morning I did what I should have done a long time ago: configure gnus to do all my RSS reading. It took me an hour but it was an hour well spent. Until recently Google Reader was just good enough but with the recent changes, it became just too painful. I'm not talking about the "social" features; I never used them. It was the poor layout and design, wasted real estate and especially the broken key shortcuts that did it. So now Google has lost access to all my RSS habits. It has also been a lesson to me in SaaS solutions (Software as a Service). When the provider can make substantial changes in their service at a whim, they can leave you high and dry. You're no better off than when you put yourself in the hands of a commercial software vendor or, dare I say it, Ubuntu :-) Now happily reading the HN feed and others through gnus...
- morsch 15y agoIf you are 1) using Firefox and 2) a client-side RSS reader isn't a deal breaker, I would heartily recommend Brief%. It's a Firefox extension and, when I was looking around for RSS readers a year or two ago, it was the only one I found comfortable. It finally converted me to an RSS addict. Google Reader was all right, but I preferred a non-cloud solution, partly because I could manually refresh feeds and be certain they were up-to-date. No social features, and no straightforward way to sync across computers/devices, so it's not at all a replacement for Google Reader in its entirety. % https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/brief/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/brief/
- JayNeely 15y agoI switched to http://www.newsblur.com http://www.newsblur.com a while ago, and have been happy with it.
- magicalist 15y agoI'm a long time, heavy user of Reader, but as a disclaimer: my usage consists of the letters j, k, m, and v, so I'll admit that I don't care at all about the lost social features, and my short cuts and usage patterns remain unchanged. This article seems no different than any other of the reader articles submitted in the last few days (especially the one by the other former googler that worked on reader). If his offer were serious because he really really cared about the product, he would have sent an email. If his offer were serious because he really really cared about other users, he would have posted some user scripts (which lots of others have already done).
- gojomo 15y agoHis offer is serious because he used to work on Google Reader.
- anigbrowl 15y ago(especially the one by the other former googler that worked on reader).
- kfury 15y agoFirst, a user script is a poor solution because it reaches a small minority of people, is limited in the functionality it can add, and would frequently not survive updates. It's a band-aid, and a poor one at that. Second, what makes you think I didn't send an email?
- confusedreader 15y agoMaybe I'm missing something, but I don't really understand the huge community backlash to the Reader rework. I spend hours in reader every day, and it wasn't until they added in G+ that it actually became easy to share.The addition made it so I could share within a community I was already involved in rather then a few people in some disconnected Reader community. From my perspective they actually removed the useless and unnecessary functions that made the old reader impossible to use to actually share content. I see it as a good first step, and when G+ actually has a solid API to build upon, they can evolve Reader to use it. Also, rabble rabble rabble too much white space rabble rabble rabble. I tried some of the community created userscripts to see if the "UI improvements" people were making actually helped and in the large part they don't as the people writing them don't seem to understand UI design.
- rkudeshi 15y agoHow big is your display? I'm on a 13" MBP (1280x800) and there's significantly less space allocated to reading now, which is my greatest frustration.
- confusedreader 15y ago24in Monitor. I could see how it might not scale down well, maybe they need to introduce the UI scaling features that Gmail has that might help with a lot of peoples issues. The userscripts I tried basically just removed a lot of margins and padding around content, so maybe those might suit you on a small display?
- porterhaney 15y agoI miss most the confined, small but important social network I had within G.reader. I wish, in addition to a better UX the follow/subscribe to others function was imported into the circles concept and reintegrated into G.reader.
- cavalcade 15y agoWow this is a bit naive and egotistical. I HATE the new google reader but to think that it takes ONE man outside of Google to fix their product is downright silly. The redesign was made in the context of Google's near-future plans to ignore that is ridiculous. A more constructive move is to provide a short checklist of things to re-consider or build/recommend a competing product. Its not like Google cant improve it more soon to find a good middle-ground.
- siculars 15y agoDo not underestimate the importance of just one single person. Examples abound.
- sp332 15y agoI think the point is that (apparently) no one at google is paying attention to how the new features integrate with the actual experience of using the Reader. He can fix that, at least.
- briancurtin 15y ago> to think that it takes ONE man outside of Google to fix their product is downright silly. He spent 5 years at Google, including being the lead designer on the Google Reader project. It's not like he's some schmuck out of nowhere, and I don't think he asked to be a one-man team.
- dylangs1030 15y agoFigure it this way: instead of Kevin Fox being pretentious, he's making a public statement. Could he have sent Google a professional email? Yes (and I suspect he did, actually). More importantly, he is making a public statement as an ex-Googler, and thus as an authority on Google engineering, that sympathizes with the negative feedback from the user base. If the users are not sending a powerful enough message, here is an ex-employee (who left on good terms, as far as we know, and was very good at what he did) giving a personal declaration to the company. That it is public shows his confidence, and that he feels (correctly) that many are dissatisfied with the recent change. And from the perspective of a large company like Google, this is not just some uninformed group griping for no reason, this is a real issue. Kevin Fox isn't attempting to be arrogant, he's giving legitimacy to an issue that may otherwise be overlooked in a classic case of a large company missing the demands of its user base.
- bigwally 15y agoIs there somewhere I can put in a few dollars to make this happen?
- Swizec 15y agoFor me the only problem with the new Reader is that too much space is wasted on the header thing and controls at the top. Before the redesign my articles would come up to almost the top of the browser window, now the top is uncomfortably low on my screen. I love everything else from the redesign, it's cleaner and generally takes up less space but the design should be more about the content and less about Reader.
- bitliner 15y agoI have made a stupid bookmarklet to hide the 140px of header that i don't usually use. I have called this GoReader: http://www.searcheeze.com/it/p/free.musik/bookmarklets http://www.searcheeze.com/it/p/free.musik/bookmarklets
- jankassens 15y agoPress 'f' to hide the controls.
- icebraining 15y agoI use the Google Reader IMHO[1] style. It's clean and doesn't take a lot of space. [1]: http://userstyles.org/styles/55659/google-reader-imho http://userstyles.org/styles/55659/google-reader-imho
- west1737 15y agoI was pretty excited about Google moving sharing to Google+ as I like Google+ and I think making it easy to share will be crucial to success. That being said, I hate the new Google Reader. I used it primarily as sharing tool, and the new sharing makes that more difficult. I think two fixes would make this better: 1) Being able to share easily with different circles. While I might be okay sharing publicly something interesting, there are plenty of less-than-appropriate funny articles that I only want to share with a few friends. This is one of the strengths of Google+, and it'd be great if Reader could take advantage of this. 2) Being able to see shared articles from other people. I understand they want to increase traffic to Google+, but this was always a great feature of Reader. In effect, each friend that used reader became their own feed. It'd be great to still have this feature and even though you're decreasing traffic to plus.google.com, you'd be increasing the overall use of Google+
- abraham 15y agoRe 1: You can choose which circle to share to in the share dialog. It is just like creating a normal post on the G+ homepage.
- devnetfx 15y agoCurrently I have to use "#12C" to make links blue so that I can actually read the posts! Reader UI is not consistent in that both G+ and Google uses some blue for the links and heading where as reader just uses black.
- laserDinosaur 15y agoAll I will say about the redesign is: Jesus christ so much WHITE. My eyes BURN. BUUUURN.
- LVB 15y agoI will put my current projects on hold to ensure that Google Reader keeps its place as the premier news reader, and raises the bar of what a social newsreader can be. That's very nice, but I think 'git checkout -f PRE_POOCH_SCREW' would probably work just as well.
- jacoblyles 15y agoThe new Google Docs was just as bad, but at least they gave us the option of using the classic design.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- obtino 15y agoIf anyone's interested in an alternative - here's one: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1834305 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1834305
- johnx123-up 15y agoDirect link http://www.newsblur.com/ http://www.newsblur.com/
- gord 15y agoWhy not just launch a startup and build a superb reader that solves the problem and looks nice? Wouldn't it be better to have the freedom to implement your own version of what the ultimate Reader is, especially in newer tech [ websockets, node.js, realtime updates, drag to rearrange widgets .. whatever ] Id love someone to make a nice reader [and a nice mail groups] web app, Id enjoy working on these myself. It must be more efficient to build these things outside of Google, as a startup. An RSS reader with nice UI, realtime update, location sensitivity, smart filters, and unobtrusive social features .. you had me at RSS :]
- brlewis 15y agoThat might be too much like what he just did: http://blog.friendfeed.com/2008/01/another-new-friendfeeder.html http://blog.friendfeed.com/2008/01/another-new-friendfeeder.... (They sold to Facebook for $50MM)
- karolist 15y agoI guess when the time to pay would come most people wouldn't bother and stick with whatever is good enough, in this case Google Reader.
- rsanchez1 15y agoIs it really so bad? I would never even have noticed: I use Google Reader exclusively through client apps on my phone and tablet. I would never have noticed because these apps function today the same they did last week, last month, even last year. Pick a client app you like and stick with it. If it's made by a good developer the app will keep up with API changes. It could only break if Google decides it doesn't want to allow unofficial access to the Reader API anymore and doesn't provide an official API.
- watmough 15y agoSomeone at Google needs to get a Goddamn clue and look at a UI design manual. What the hell are they thinking? Has Larry let the MBAs get out of control? There's clearly something wrong, as no sensible, actual user of these products surely could believe that this mess is an improvement? This is on a par with the del.icio.us mess.
- johnx123-up 15y agoIt may not be MBAs, but Ex-Yahoo! guys http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3143054 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3143054
- watmough 15y ago:) Yeah, I'll take a look at your link, but the new styles are surely reminiscent of the awful YUI, which much as I love Crockford, I'd have to write off as crap, due to its convoluted programming model and wretched bad appearance and inefficiency. (Example: compare the stock charts in Yahoo with Google's - slow and very flickery) Here's a concrete example in the form of a comparison between old Gmail and new GMail. Page headers for old and new Gmail compared: http://imgur.com/a/X4gdp http://imgur.com/a/X4gdp
- acqq 15y agoHere's one of the reasons: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3190205 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3190205 "If I remember correctly, Google engineers are given the choice of one 30" monitor or a two 24" monitors," That explains all. At the time "normal people" converge to notebooks and laptops with even less height, they "optimize" UI for their immense screens. The managers who approve also test it on their 30 inch screens. And they certainly don't understand the complaints, probably saying: "don't you all have 30 inch?" "let them eat cake." I have an old notebook with 1050 pixels height and even there the new changes are annoying to me. What's with now more common 768, 800 and 900 pixels?
- karolist 15y agoSticking with one resolution when testing is such a noob mistake I'd doubt google could make it. You don't need a different screen to test different layouts, Firefox webdeveloper extension lets you define viewport sizes for testing easily.
- adrianwaj 15y agoMy only tip would be to make standard this plugin, make it look right, and have it remember its settings on a feed-per-feed basis: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/khbjahpecnkenngkidhioicnfpakihgo https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/khbjahpecnkenngkid... (Super Full Feeds) note - the Chrome Web Store has also taken a usability hit, in my view. YouTube was done fairly well, and I think that team should be moved across to do other products, or train other teams about what and how to do things.
- taitems 15y agoI hate to be that guy, but you need to put your line-height where your mouth is. .entry_content needs to be 1.5em at the least.
- djhworld 15y agoPublicly deriding the changes (that a lot of people have put a lot of work into) and then saying "Hey, pay me, I could do better!" seems a little arrogant to me. From Google's perspective I wouldn't rehire this guy.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- microcentury 15y agoIt really is astonishing how much bile and vitriol can be caused by a UI change. I guess it's a subset of the general dislike of change most people have. And it's also amazing how absolutely certain some people are that their own view is the right one. I'm not a fan of the new UI yet, but I suspect in a few weeks I will have forgotten what the old one was like.
- jarek 15y agoWhat is your screen resolution?
- brlewis 15y agoWhat part of this post sounds like bile and vitriol to you? I t reads to me like a clinical analysis, not an emotional reaction.
- timwiseman 15y agoPerhaps part of it is that it is a reminder of lack of control of cloud based software? With most traditional software, if I dislike the new version I can continue using the old. With cloud based software, including just about all web based programs, when there is a new version my choices are to use the new version or switch to something else entirely (and if the product has any form of effective lock in, the second may not really be an option). People like the feeling of being in control, and a change they did not expect and cannot undo undermines that feeling.
- mooism2 15y agoThe only bit of the change I object to --- since I never used the social features --- is that they've changed the link colour from blue to dark grey. This is enough to make links mostly invisible, and makes Reader much less useful as a feed reader for me. In a few weeks I'll either be using a different feed reader, or my eyes will be much better at distinguishing dark grey from black.
- ThaddeusQuay2 15y agohttp://kirbybits.wordpress.com/2011/10/21/wherein-i-try-to-explain-why-google-reader-is-the-best-social-network-created-so-far http://kirbybits.wordpress.com/2011/10/21/wherein-i-try-to-e... (Wherein I try to explain why Google Reader is the best social network created so far)
- GiraffeNecktie 15y agoI wouldn't hire any "designer" who center aligns (or right aligns or right justifies) his body text. Especially not for an application that is focused on reading.
- udfalkso 15y agoI've resurrected http://FeedEachOther.com http://FeedEachOther.com if anyone is looking for a nice, social feed reading experience.