3 ms·
Three thoughts: 1. This article sees the repeal of Roe as undermining the legitimacy of the court. It doesn't seem to see Roe itself as undermining the court
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
Three thoughts:
1. This article sees the repeal of Roe as undermining the legitimacy of the court. It doesn't seem to see Roe itself as undermining the court's legitimacy. But to many conservatives, Roe was clearly legally wrong, and blatantly immoral. It was judges making up law to suit their political biases - the very thing the article accuses the current court of doing.
Conservatives responded, not by disregarding the court, but by a 50-year-long campaign to repeal Roe. The success of that campaign may restore conservatives' faith in the court, even as it damages liberals' faith in it.
How will liberals respond? By a long-term campaign to restore Roe? By a state-by-state legislative campaign? Or by trying to undermine the Supreme Court? They should be very careful about the third option - that way lies unleashing chaos, and they might not like the results.
2. The article suggests curbing the power of the Supreme Court, and trusting the legislature more. There are two problems with this approach. First, the legislature has become increasingly useless and unable to pass anything, with the result that the executive is more frequently ruling by executive orders. Diminishing the Supreme Court's role in favor of more executive orders is not a trade-off that I want to make. Second, even if the legislature is currently functionally capable of taking on the role, they need to write their legislation with a lot more eye on Constitutional limits of their authority than they recently have been.
3. The article talks about the next presidential election. I am deeply worried about that. It's not just the Supreme Court that can suffer from a loss of legitimacy; the whole federal government can.
Trump is the worst offender, and the one that worries me the most. I really, really don't want him to be the Republican candidate in 2024. I really don't want his minions to be winning primaries at the state level. I deeply fear this road.
But I also have to say that Democrats aren't helping. Hillary verbally disputed the 2016 election for years. It was just talk, unlike Trump, but it was opening a door. And even here, on HN, in that giant thread on Roe being overturned, I read comments that said, essentially, "2 of the last 6 presidential elections were against the popular vote!!!!!1! Tear the system down!" That mindset, that attitude, is too similar to Trump's for my taste. There were a set of rules, and Trump won by those rules in 2016. Accepting that your side lost and moving on is absolutely central to democracy.
Note well: I am not saying that Democrats' faults are equivalent to Trump's. They aren't. Trump is clearly going massively farther. But Democrats are taking steps in the same direction, and they shouldn't.
I think the battle for the survival of American democracy will be the integrity of the 2024 election, and the acceptance of the results. I think that is worth fighting for, even if your preferred side loses.