4 ms·
The interface of this with Music Theory is equal temperament, as in [1]. The musical hardware provides white piano keys giving intervals with rational frequency
by jesuslop 4y ago
The interface of this with Music Theory is equal temperament, as in [1]. The musical hardware provides white piano keys giving intervals with rational frequency ratio, so harmonious (called just intonation). With that you can play in only one key (or relative minor). The problem is what to do with the other keys. The solution was equal temperament, that suddenly alowed to play all keys at once without retuning the instrument. That new technology was showcased by Bach in his 'Well tempered clavier', that was a set of etudes each one in a different key, ranging over all possible keys. One could sit down and play them all in a row. In equal temp. one can, even inside the piece, do modulations (local key changes) that one couldn't in just intonation. But the price was to abandon the rational frequency ratios of intervals, turning to a system based on multiplying by 2^(1/12) (irrational, except at the octave, 12 semitones/multiplications away, that is at doubling frequency), hence dropping some of the good properties of just intonation. One can see that frequencies of notes in both systems are similar, but end up not really matching.
[1] https://pages.mtu.edu/~suits/scales.html https://pages.mtu.edu/~suits/scales.html
- azalemeth 4y agoMy Clavinova has buttons for changing temperament – by default it is equal (fairly obviously) but it is wonderful to actually be able to try out mean tone / pythagorean and various other obscure temperaments, particularly when bashing around with strings or singers. Playing Bach's well-tuned klavier -- a piece written to celebrate equal temperament -- in a pythagorean temperament is also just fun. The difference is subtle, but decidedly there.
- hyperjeff 4y agoMinor note (plz pardon pun) on Bach: While it’s still debated what tuning he used for this work, it’s generally currently thought that he did not use equal temperament. Tons of ink spilled on this topic.
- jesuslop 4y agoAh you're right, modern scholars are leaning as you say. Let me repair my comment saying that Bach could have played all WTC in equal temperament had he wanted. Thanks for completing.