4 ms·
> One reason so many Victorian public toilets have been closed is the cost of providing disabled access, which, unlike the provision of public toilets, is now s
by josephcsible 4y ago
> One reason so many Victorian public toilets have been closed is the cost of providing disabled access, which, unlike the provision of public toilets, is now statutory. It’s expensive and fiddly to update a Victorian loo reached by steep iron steps, so it’s easier just to close it
I hate the mindset of "unless we can have/use this, nobody else can either". Remember when UC Berkeley had to take down over 20,000 of their free podcasts and lecture videos because they weren't captioned? We need to fix our disability laws to stop this kind of thing from happening.
- pxc 4y agoI don't think this is an 'attitude' issue at all— no disability rights activists are satisfied with outcomes that don't actually make the world more readily navigable by disabled people. This isn't the result of some miserly attitude on they part of disabled people, or activists, or legislators. It's the result of the limitations of negative approaches to rights.
- josephcsible 4y agoThose two outcomes didn't make the world more readily navigable by disabled people. They just made it worse for the rest of us.
- klyrs 4y agoThat's because we need to recognize access to toilets as a human right. As the article mentions, it's possible to upgrade them, but city councils prefer to close them.
- noworld 4y agoThere's got to be something in between "desirable positive public health outcome" and "human right." Nothing about closing any given toilet implies "human rights violation."
- klyrs 4y ago"Any given toilet" is doing a lot of work there. Governments actually know how much people generally need to go to the bathroom. In fact, in many places, you can't get a license to host a large public event without providing toilets. But when it comes to public transit and downtown cores where that very same government has a very good handle on how many people are expected to be hanging around on an average/peak day, no need for toilets whatsoever!
- whatshisface 4y agoThe problem with recognizing things that cost money as a human right is that we have to grant that poor countries don't have the luxury of providing them. Then, the same dictators can argue that due to their country's instability, they don't have the "luxury" of providing torture-free policing or freedom of speech. I am sure evil dictators would love for the discourse about human rights to be redirected towards public works - and I don't say that without reason, because they tend to be the most reliable supporters of UN resolutions that do it. I don't mean to say that public works are evil, just that evil dictators would love for us to be unable to tell them apart from human rights issues.
- klyrs 4y agoThat's helluva weird excuse for rich countries to not recognize that their cultural anxiety about bodily functions creates a legitimate need for private spaces to defecate.
- whatshisface 4y agoAs long as you don't use a word that implies equating it with allowing people to criticize their government, or distinguishing civilians from soldiers in times of war, I don't have any objections.
- klyrs 4y agoI view the right to piss&shit on even ground with the right to breathe, drink, and eat. If you think all that's less important than the right to criticize one's government, that's fine, feel free to hold it 'til you asphyxiate or your bladder fails.
- whatshisface 4y agoSaying that people have a human right to public bathrooms is like saying they have a boating license to clean water - I can infer what you're saying from context, but it leads to confusion. If you're asking for a clear argument establishing a distinction, consider that if a pipe bursts nobody will be hauled off to Nuremberg. :-)
- toyg 4y agoIt should be noted that this is largely the result of malicious compliance on the part of local authorities. There are plenty of ways to get exemptions from the statutory duty, but it's a great excuse to dispense of stuff you didn't really want to maintain anyway. Nobody in politics these days, and I say nobody, really wants to be accountable for running a service, any service. That's because it dramatically increases risks to their own job security. So anything that can be ejected without backlash, will be.
- nvr219 4y agoOr just caption them. The technology is there.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's not really an issue unless the law has overall negative effects. By enforcing it across everyone as a standard it creates market opportunities for businesses to provide the service in an efficient manner. You don't have to rely on every single web video library to care about subtitles as they'll all have big customers that need it. People like to nitpick regulations because powerful groups hate being regulated. But it's a tricky job as they're fairly obviously beneficial, so you end up with some really weird complaints that have to dance around any specifics.