3 ms·
1409 transistors, 10148 diodes, 5615 resistors, and 1674 capacitors, according to http://www.pdp8online.com/straight8/functional_restore.shtml http://www.pdp8on
by kragen 4y ago
1409 transistors, 10148 diodes, 5615 resistors, and 1674 capacitors, according to http://www.pdp8online.com/straight8/functional_restore.shtml http://www.pdp8online.com/straight8/functional_restore.shtml. There have definitely been simpler computers than that. For example, the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGP-30 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGP-30 had 113 vacuum tubes, 1450 diodes, and probably also some ungodly number of resistors, capacitors, and inductors. Unlike the "straight 8", but like the PDP-8/S, it was bit-serial. Many of the tubes were in 15 flip-flops, which provided restoration (amplification), inversion, and sequentiality (that is, memory, as opposed to pure combinational logic).
To quibble a bit about the 6502, it was a bit more complex than the -8, but not by nearly as much as you say. The 6502 had 4528 transistors, including diode-connected transistors and depletion-load transistors used as pullup resistors. In its NMOS logic, an N-input NAND gate required N enhancement-mode transistors and a depletion-load pullup; in the straight 8's DTL, an N-input NAND required one transistor, a pullup resistor, and N diodes. So 1409 transistors is more or less 1200 (inverting) logic gates, and 4528 transistors is probably closer to 2000 gates.
The Intersil 6100 was a CMOS PDP-8, with 2N transistors per N-input NAND. It had 4000 transistors, which is probably also about 1200 inverting logic gates, but it included the EAE.
Further comparison at https://retrocomputing.stackexchange.com/questions/5843/pdp-8-transistor-count https://retrocomputing.stackexchange.com/questions/5843/pdp-....
To quibble a bit about subroutine calls, JMS didn't store the current PC at memory location 0; it stored it at the operand address, then continued execution at the next memory word after that. So the called subroutine had its return address just before the beginning of its code. This mechanism doesn't directly support recursion but at least it does directly support more than one level of subroutine calls, which your alternative wouldn't.