4 ms·
"I think anyone who can’t work well remote, on average, will not be your top performers anyway." Ah, there it is, the bountiful blind arrogance I have come to
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
"I think anyone who can’t work well remote, on average, will not be your top performers anyway."
Ah, there it is, the bountiful blind arrogance I have come to expect from threads like this on HN. It's like you didn't even read my post, just looked for the hook to drop in and proclaim your superiority.
- l30n4da5 4y ago> It's like you didn't even read my post, just looked for the hook to drop in and proclaim your superiority. Seemed to me it was just a counter-point to your post. If you don't have anything productive to add, that's fine, but resorting to personal attacks doesn't really make your argument/viewpoint look better. From my own personal experience, I'd mirror what the previous poster said. Most of the top performers in a remote setting (at least with software engineering) are usually also a top performer in an office setting. Does that mean there are not outliers? No.
- cmrdporcupine 4y ago
- l30n4da5 4y agono it isn't.
- fileeditview 4y agoIt is a claim without proof which discredits people failing in a remote job. Comes pretty close to an insult TBH. Considering that success and failure in remote jobs does depend a lot on the team, the organization, the planning etc.. not only the person itself. Also e.g. this sentence by GP raised red flags for me: > Most software engineers produce more effort than they’re worth and skate by with meetings, “pair programming”, etc Let's leave meetings out because I agree that too many meetings are bad but pair programming can be a useful tool, especially to transfer knowledge. And that MOST SWEs produce more effort than they're worth.. lol.. what a blanket statement.
- l30n4da5 4y ago> It is a claim without proof which discredits people failing in a remote job. Comes pretty close to an insult TBH. It was an opinion. Given based on someone's anecdotal experience. I'll stand by my original statement regarding whether that is a personal attack: > No it isn't. ___ > lol.. what a blanket statement. agreed on that point. I believe that statement definitely missed the mark, imo.
- bragr 4y agoI think you should read that post again with more dispassion. It does NOT say that top performer's are not suffering from remote work. It says who the top performers are has not really changed. The top performers could be getting 50% less work done and that person's post still holds for me.
- ospzfmbbzr 4y agoNot personal unless you take it that way -- instead take it as a challenge and show him he was wrong about you. Programming well is difficult and takes time and effort to get good at, but it's worth it. Being junior and learning while remote is not ideal at all. I work very well remotely but only because everything is second nature to me now after so many years. If that makes me a 'top performer' then it's only because I worked my way up to that. Do you believe you are at your top performance already? Or can you get better still?
- travisgriggs 4y ago> Programming well is difficult and takes time and effort to get good at, but it's worth it. I agree very much with parts 1 and 2 of your assertion. At 51, with a decent brag list of successes, I think I’ve even achieved some measure of it. The part I’m not sure about is the “worth it.” I used to think that, I’ve become less sure of late. What makes it worth to you? I’m honestly curious. I used to have various things that made it worth it to me, and of late they’ve become less valued.
- ospzfmbbzr 4y agoYeah I'm a bit jaded too. Would I get into this business today? Probably not. Mostly because of the potential employers, who they hire and why, and how success is 'measured' these days. I've been contract only for 17 years and I'll never go back to employment. I guess I'm lucky to have the option, but if I didn't I'd find another non-employment way to earn a living. As you say the problem is that individual contributor quality isn't valued as it should be -- it's not prioritized above say compliance with 'all the current things.' Engineering culture is mostly absent everywhere nowadays and in it's place a culture of entitlement and groupthink -- the hallmarks of failing institutions.
- mgfist 4y agoYou're totally missing the original point. > I work very well remotely but only because everything is second nature to me now after so many years. This is coming from the narrow view that people who struggle remotely only do so because they are inexperienced. I know people who struggled because they lived in a small NYC apartment where their desk was 2 feet from their bed, and the lack of movement or change of environment was killer mentally. I know people who struggled because they are highly extroverted and not seeing people IRL led to crushing mental health issues. I know people who did not live up to their IRL potential because they thrive on watercooler chats for creativity. I know people who just felt disconnected remotely and didn't feel the purpose and connection to the team/company in person. Basically, "technical ability" is not the sole reason why someone would be worse remotely than in person. Likewise there are people who feel distracted in person and need the remote solitude or get drained from the commute.
- fromwhence 4y agoThat is not a personal insult. It couldn't even be so by implication, unless the alleged insulter here knows something about you personally that the rest of us don't know. They simply made an assertion. You can disagree with it, but that's their general assertion and that's not the same thing as a personal insult.
- barrysteve 4y agoYeah his post could be interpreted that way, especially by the open topic about "personality types" and your implication that your better jobs were in person. But I doubt he meant it that way. Some people are so used to talking in impersonal generalities it is assumed to be an impersonal statement, even in oddly personal situations.
- prmoustache 4y agoHow is "not being a top performer" an insult? Not everyone is born/made to be a top performer at work. And that is fine, especially as it is probably the least interesting quality in a human being, especially outside of work.
- bumby 4y agoMy guess is this those who find it an insult are either overachievers (who have to feel like they excel at everything), or tie their personal identity to their work (and by saying they are not a top performer, the implication is have less personal worth).
- pyb 4y agoAgree that it was poor form of lettergram to non-sequitur your post, as an opportunity to bash their own colleagues. This kind of interaction is normally more prevalent on Twitter than it is here.
- avgcorrection 4y agoHN holds that mythical lone^W solo^W remote hacker in high regard.
- the_only_law 4y agoKinda ironic given most people I know who fit this description dislike the site.
- Rychard 4y agoBut they did read your post, as shown by their provided reasoning. Your follow-up seems to have disregarded their entire response, resorting to ad hominems rather than providing any justification of why you disagree. From my perspective, your response is an example of the exact opposite of what was written, that being "bountiful blind arrogance". For what it's worth, I largely agreed with their assessment that a top performer in a remote setting is highly-likely to be a top-performer in-office as well. The set containing top-performing engineers that are effective in-office is a subset of top-performing engineers that are effective remotely. While there are certainly exceptions to this, the article seems to support this assessment when it enumerates the list of things that new-hires would need to learn for both in-office and remote scenarios: > As you can see, junior remote employees are doing almost 2x the upskilling they're doing in the office. It's not their fault they are struggling to get up to speed as quickly.
- lettergram 4y agoI pointed out what I’ve seen. It’s not a personal attack to say “generally people who do poorly in a remote setting lack discipline” I then provided several methods we used to increase discipline (we developed over years of trial and error). I think it’s arrogant to dismiss others experiences, particularly someone who’s managed / lived this experience for a decade (and helped setup multiple remote offices and teams). I never claimed superiority, I did point out a skill that’s often lacking in those with poor remote performance.
- anon2020dot00 4y agoRemote work can affect a variety of people in different ways so a blanket statement that classifies people who struggle with remote setup as under-performers anyway comes across as too judgmental and lacking in nuance. There are a variety of possible reasons why a person can thrive more in an office environment compared to a remote environment (and vice versa) such as maybe they have a poor remote environment due to a lack of funds. Some people might have comfy homes and a good support system at home while others may have cramped apartments and a poor home environment. Also, the blanket statement can also be used inversely such as "generally people who do poorly in an office setting lack discipline" when maybe the person doesn't just do well in an open office or lives far away from the office with a difficult commute. I think it's simpler to state the some people thrive in an office environment and other people thrive in remote environment for a variety of factors such as their personality and personal environment rather than to condemn those who don't thrive in either set-ups as "lacking discipline".
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoYou say that >I think there's in general a "personality type" that does really well with remote in a certain kind of job and thrives with fairly asynchronous disconnected tasks and they say that in general those people are already the top performers. When you think about it, that shouldn't be surprising. People who know how to succeed in one environment also know how to adapt and succeed in another. That's to be expected.
- bumby 4y agoFrom the HN Guidelines: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." I don't think a personal attack is most generous interpretation of their post. I would add some nuance. I've increasingly come to the conclusion that initiative is one of the best qualities in an employee. It's natural to see how having initiative will lend itself well to both in-person and remote work, but I suspect the effect is even more prominent in asynchronous work where there's less oversight and less opportunities for someone to spell things out. Relating to the article, junior employees are often at a disadvantage regarding taking initiative because they simply lack the tacit organizational knowledge to run with a task. They may not know who to contact or the full context of problem areas. This makes them more reliant on mentorship, which can be more difficult in remote work.
- tuckerman 4y agoIf someone writes a post about struggling remotely and someone immediately follows it up with some general observation about how most people who struggle remotely weren’t going to be that great anyway it’s pretty easy for the OP to connect the dots.
- bumby 4y agoIt's not "can you connect the dots" but "should you connect the dots." I can frame just about any comment as an attack in one way or another, but it's not a great idea. For one, it goes against HN guidelines but, more importantly, it just doesn't seem like a very healthy mindset.
- tuckerman 4y agoI think the fact that OP and others are taking it as a personal attack is at least a sign that we should also be mindful in how we write things.
- akhmatova 4y agoThe bountiful blind arrogance I have come to expect from threads like this on HN. I didn't read it that way at all. The commenter was simply relating their observation of how remote works well for some co-workers, but not for others -- as they see it. That's all. It seems you're reading way too much into that observation.
- UnpossibleJim 4y agoWhile said in an arrogant manner, I'll agree, I think the sentiment of, "Top performers tend to be self starters, no matter where you put them", tends to hold true. All rules have exceptions... sure, but by metrics of task completion which is what work should be about, instead of butts in seats (unless I missed something), That's what I want from my team. I admit my team is small and I can meet with them over Slack and chat more than most other, larger teams but I think maybe that's the answer to remote. 1. Defined goals 2. Available help over Slack and chat (which we have group and private channels) 3. Weekly or bi-weekly standups to get more of a sense of where everyone stands and have a lay of the land and understand your team. 4. The lead needs to do the leg work with the managers to let them know their team is doing the work and get the recognition they deserve. It is harder in someways, but easier in a lot of ways and WAY more efficient where it counts in many ways. It is a shift and requires effort.
- dang 4y agoPlease don't swerve into off topic flamewar like this. I didn't read it closely, but the GP reads to me like normal internet conversation. That doesn't mean the comment is right, but there's plenty of room for an exchange of views here. Instances like this are where the following guideline comes in handy – if you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, we'd appreciate it: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." The strongest plausible interpretation is obviously that the GP was making their own point about remote work based on their own experiences and not proclaiming personal superiority over you. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31894409 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31894409.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]