3 ms·
A bit of honesty, maybe? The bill is duplicitous from the get go. It's entitled "To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide earnings assistance and
by SwellJoe 18y ago
A bit of honesty, maybe?
The bill is duplicitous from the get go. It's entitled "To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide earnings assistance and tax relief to members of the uniformed services, volunteer firefighters, and Peace Corps volunteers, and for other purposes"! If that kind of doublespeak don't get yer hackles up, I can't imagine what would.
Some honest discussion, some real consequences for the people that caused this meltdown (and it was caused, it was not an accident), and some oversight in how a bailout proceeds. Perhaps we, as the folks footing the bill, would also like to know what the total is actually going to be before agreeing to it. My understanding of the bill (admittedly weak) is that it is a blank check for Paulson to distribute amongst his friends in the finance industry, with no oversight and no transparency about how it's going to be used.
The fact that a bailout is being presented as "OMG! We have to do this now, imagine the consequences if we don't!" it has a strikingly similar ring to the "We have to invade Iraq now!" pose of a few years ago. I don't trust salesguys that insist I need to buy now, and I really don't trust politicians when they use the same tactic, especially when they're arguments are based on lies and misdirection.
Yes, something must be done. Accountability would be a great start. Bringing some trust back into our finance industry would be a good way forward. A bailout? I dunno. Maybe there are other ways forward that directly help the people hurt rather than the millionaires and billionaires that caused it.
- jodrellblank 18y agoWhy must something be done? I don't understand. Surely if all the banks failed that would be a great opportunity for people to start new banks with extra incentive to prove their honesty and trustworthiness, for instance. It can't be the case that banks will collapse and everyone goes "Oh shit money is now worthless, I'm shutting down my business, firing everyone and going to find a soup kitchen". Can it? Really?
- SwellJoe 18y agoWhy must something be done? Good question. And one I think ought to be asked. It's a standard tactic of both sides to frame a debate such that any result is one they'd be happy with. This appears to be a classic case of that. Both sides want a bailout, and so they've framed the debate as "What kind of bailout do we want?" rather than "Do we need a bailout, or can this problem be solved in other ways?" Interestingly, a huge percentage of Americans (even a few who understand what's going on) don't want a bailout, at all.
- jodrellblank 18y agoAt the core of my problem is the Hacker News philosophy that a spirited go-getter can create value for people out of nothing. Yet the oft mentioned depression of the early 1900s showed people queueing for handout foods. Farmers would still work because people still need to eat. People would still trade with farmers because they need to eat and farmers need work doing. People would trade with builders and mechanics and plumbers and cooks and delivery people and oil companies because they want things that those people have, and in exchange they have skills that other people want. This is business, this is life, has been for hundreds of years. So how can that also coexist with unemployed people relying on handouts? What went missing to turn the ongoing network of trades into a fallen pile of cards? Why are some economies sparkling and growing and others filled with peasants eeking a miserable existance? Is credit somehow the missing link I'm not getting? If so, why doesn't printing more money fix Zimbabwe? If it's not credit, what else can vanish? America isn't suddenly out of education, is it? Is it trust? Is there really any kind of meaningful answer to this that doesn't involve pointing at the whole world and saying "that, that's it. Everything that is, that's the answer"?
- SwellJoe 18y agoIf so, why doesn't printing more money fix Zimbabwe? Zimbabwe has deep problems unrelated to money supply. If you build a successful business in Zimbabwe Mugabe's thugs will kill you and steal it (or allow you to escape the country with the clothes on your back, if you're lucky). In a culture where everyone has to either be a part of the gang that runs the place, or pay for the privilege of mere existence, business cannot grow. The incentives are simply wrong for business to exist. There is no incentive to work hard, build something new, take risks on new ideas, or provide a service (to anyone other than the thugs in charge). If you had no hope of becoming successful would you start a new business? Would you bother working every day to maintain an existing one? Everyone who has the capacity to build products, grow food, and provide knowledge services, has either fled the country or been killed or imprisoned by the government. Of course the economy of Zimbabwe is a shithole. So, I don't have any answers to any of your other question. I'm by no means an expert on the subject. But the causes of the economic failure of Zimbabwe seems pretty obvious to me. And, the more the US looked like Zimbabwe, politically speaking, the more our economy would look like the economy of Zimbabwe. Luckily, we have a long way to fall to be in quite the same kind of mess as Zimbabwe. But, I do think a bailout without serious oversight and some accountability for the people that caused the problem, would be a big step in the wrong direction.
- netcan 18y agoI'm not necessarily representing my view. But a view: Economics is far from a fundamental science. Very far. It is really more of a description of what happens via all sorts of analogies that usually hold true & help to explain the things that we see happening. Some parts of economics are stronger then others because they are based on manipulating tautologies of various sorts. But others are really more along the lines of: 'If we put a dog here, the sheep will go there'. As with most non fundamental sciences, economics can break down in extreme circumstances. Neuton's Mechanics is not as fundamental as relativity. It breaks down in extreme cases. That only seems strange because physics is very fundamental. But with Zoology, Sociaology, Phsychology or other "downstream" sciences, this is expected. No one's surprised when techniques break down during psychoanalysis of a woman raised by wolves. Psychology is explained by Biology, explained by chemistry, explained by physics. And each of those words is just really a number of links in this chain in themselves. Economics is two or three links up that chain. So here's how we go back to the topic: If a supermarket chain that supplied 85% of food in a region goes out of business, leaving it empty of competitors, what happens? The rules still apply. Consumers seek alternative. Small shops, mail order shopping, markets become very lucrative. Consumers spend more on food or get 'less' for a period. Eventually, a new equilibrium is found. But what happens if the equivalent food producers go out of business? Wheat doesn't get sown. Coke doesn't get bottled. Sure it's a great opportunity for boutique vegie growers. But the same rules no longer apply. 20% of the food supply means there isn't enough for everyone to eat right. Maybe people sell off Apartments to buy houses with backyards (to grow food). Maybe they take time off work to plant. Maybe things are too volatile for boutique farmers to get investment to grow. I'm not saying this is a close analogy. I'm certainly not saying the 'bailout' should've happened. If I were American, I'd be as suspicious as SwellJoe of a bill that's called "tax breaks for Peace Corps & stuff" which gives unreal sums to big companies while the salesman-like proponents chants 'This is too complicated for you to understand', 'You need to decide now' & 'Apocalypse is coming so pick mine.' But I am saying that relying on high level economic principles here is not like relying on gravity. Not at all. At best it's like relying on wolves attacking a calf over a bull. It makes sense. It usually happens. But who know what happens to traumatised wolves from a a circus during a thunderstorm.