24 ms·
The Supreme Court’s Faux ‘Originalism’
- ngcc_hk 4y agoIt is this which is important “ With originalists holding six of the Supreme Court’s nine seats, we’re all living in an originalist world.” Get more Supreme Court judges otherwise all will be lost. Unlike trump USA cannot recover from this.
- krapp 4y agoThings are going to get spicy when Loving v. Virginia and P̶l̶e̶s̶s̶y̶ ̶v̶.̶ ̶F̶e̶r̶g̶u̶s̶o̶n̶ get repealed. edit: I'm dumb.
- marcus0x62 4y agoPlessy v. Ferguson explicitly upheld the separate, but equal doctrine underpinning many of the Jim Crow laws. Why would you not want that repealed, even if it has largely been gutted by Brown, Civil/Voting Rights Act, etc.?
- krapp 4y agoApparently I meant Brown v. Board of Education, not Plessy v. Ferguson. I shouldn't post both in anger and haste.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoRespectfully: If one side expands scotus for political gain, I guarantee that the other side immediately does the same the moment they get the house and senate. The only way for that not to happen is to guarantee that they never lose the house/senate again. That, my friend, is a dangerous thought and one that may lead to civil conflict. Let's hope the statement you made is not followed - else hell may soon follow that.
- dredmorbius 4y agoOne side already has, effectively.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoAnd if you think that the court is politicized now, and that's a problem, each party expanding it to get a majority when they're elected is not the way to fix it. (And if you think that the court is politicized now, and the problem is that it's politicized the wrong way, you're part of the problem. And if you think it's not politicized when it goes your way but it is when it decides against you, you're probably a bit biased.)
- cafard 4y agoWhen he floated the notion of expanding the Supreme Court, FDR was vastly more popular than Biden is. You can see how that went.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoYour last sentence isn't supported by history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_switch_in_time_that_saved_nine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_switch_in_time_that_saved_... Plus of course aligned with your first sentence FDR got reelected after that. Twice. I rate these decisions as the first decisive break from what FDR wrought in the 1930s.
- sam_goody 4y agoInteresting article, one I appreciated reading. There are a few points which don't sit right with me, and I would love to read a rebuttal or even just a similarly styled article by someone on the other end of the spectrum. (Reading any one side of the news is to live in an echo chamber. It is hard to avoid confirmation bias, but if you don't make any attempt to hear truth you will surely not. My guidelines: 1. I can talk with my friends about politics only as long as we each agree to hear each other out, to not repeat ourselves, to respect each other, and to not let it get personal. This took awhile, but I now hear perspectives that amaze me. 2. Any article that gets me upset must be matched by another article with another perspective, even though it will invariably get me more upset ;) 3. Learning the truth is objectively a value, and it is worth getting the truth at the cost of being wrong. Better to get an uncomfortable truth before it comes at you in a conversation of 1, 'cause in a debate you have a bias to avoid eating crow. 4. The media are a bunch of liars, and their objectives are NOT to get you facts, their objective is to sell you a story. If you are relying on a story from the press, you are relying on Cinderella and Snow White. 5. Just because your team did something wrong or the others did something right doesn't mean you have to switch teams. There is a "programmers law" that you shouldn't discuss any software unless you can list at least five things that the other software does better than the one you prefer. Even Windows has 5 things it does better than Linux.)
- raxxorraxor 4y agoTo be fair there are journalists that don't just want to sell you a story. But the ratio of entertainment media and media with a serious attempt to inform people is sadly rather large.
- f154hfds 4y agoAs usual the opponents of originalism describe its very real detriment, that knowledge of history (and more specifically linguistic history / etymology) is vital to originalism while failing to offer any alternative view that doesn't make the judiciary into a super-legislature. Ironically in this case they make a great case (in my naive opinion) for a valid originalist take to regulate weapons. If only the debate on the 2nd Amendment could be about these historical points instead of one side arguing for originalism with the other side arguing for a 'living constitution' where any debate about the original meaning of laws is irrelevant. Many might object at this point to say the the originalists are fake, they use the philosophy of originalism as a propaganda tool to pull the wool over the eyes of the masses. This argument holds no weight as long as the other side rejects originalism as a fundamental presupposition of jurisprudence. In other words, contemporary American politics gives you two options for viewing our current legal system: either it's a super-legislature where justices are just senators-for-life and can as a group overrule anything on a whim with no repercussions or it's a group whose job is to interpret the text of existing laws applying the intent of our real legislature to actual situations that occur. If the former, then our country has very little hope. If the latter then we can work together to get principled justices who care about textualism. The article is right that a textualist shouldn't always be allowed to interpret along the lines of what they think is right, but you can't throw out the baby with the bathwater! Their argument is: originalists are unprincipled therefore originalism is wrong. This holds no water for me.
- capguy255 4y agoHow exactly does making historical, analogical arguments the center of judicial reasoning make the court LESS of a super-legislature? If nothing else, it makes the court MORE likely to be politically active so long as they can find a few pseudo-scholarly articles that make an argument for them. And that's remarkably easy these days when there are lots of ways to get published but far fewer institutions with the resources and time to check the historical scholarship for accuracy. "Originalism" and "textualism" are two different approaches to legal interpretation that can sometimes but not always overlap. Plenty of people who believe in a "living constitution" ground their reasoning in legal text. The innovation of originalist legal thought is that they realized so long as they can get enough activists onto law journals to write opinion pieces that make historical arguments, that judges can pretend to point backwards in time having clear-headed wisdom about what people thought "back then," without any clear and objective criteria that can be used to justify the decision or distinguish situations. In originalism, the law becomes completely arbitrary and based on whichever flavor of the day scholarship judges decide to cite -- even if it's obscure, historically inaccurate, or written from a clearly biased activist perspective. Ginning up creative ways to reach your preferred outcome and then pretending it's a one-off and so you don't need to explain the logic is a far more political way of making decisions than to ground judicial decision-making in precedent from past legal decisions and from actual text that have to be tested for relevance and accuracy.