9 ms·
‘Just stop buying lattes’: The origins of a millennial housing myth
- ratsmack 4y ago>What keeps us living paycheck to paycheck is that we spend more than we make on stuff we don’t need. This is still true, though. When I turned 40 in 1994, I decided I had lived with debt long enough. So I sold my plane. my boat and my 2nd house. In the next four years, I paid off the remaining mortgage on my 1st house and installments on my cars and credit cards. Was it hard? Yes, it was damn hard. It's like kicking a habit like a drug addiction, but the drug is easy credit. I never went into debt again.
- bigChris 4y agoHold up. Hold up. Man. Man. I don’t... I don’t know what to say after reading your comment.
- ticviking 4y agoDave Ramsey changed my parents life too! If only they’d saved with that money instead paid it as interest on the boat they never used anyhow
- quantified 4y agoSarcasm or really? Can't tell from pure writing.
- cbg0 4y agoCome on, he's not even trying to be subtle.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y ago
- runaway 4y agoThis is satire, right? It's too good.
- cs137 4y ago^ Post that was flagged by cappies and neoliberals who don't get satire. Have an upvote, good sir.
- Hellbanevil 4y ago
- wronglyprepaid 4y agoSo something I don't quite get is this. (some) economist postulate that pumping metric fucking shit-tons of money into the economy will cause inflation, because there is literally more money chasing the same amount of goods, and this creates a quite expected upwards pressure in prices. Other economists and politicians posit this won't happen and then proceed to do it, and then inflation happens, and then all of a sudden nobody could have predicted it, it is transitory (until it clearly is not), it is caused by Putin (except not according to the fed chair), it is because the economy is in transition, etc etc. How about, don't pump metric shit-tons of money into the economy and see how that works. And while you are at it, maybe don't make a campaign promise to end fossil fuels and act all surprised when the prices for fossil fuels go through the roof. I'm as happy as the next person to see the end to carbon emissions, but I don't do everything I can to end it and then whine about it ending .
- pharmakom 4y agoThe governments of the world decided to prop up businesses, employment and asset wealth by printing loads of money. The alternatives were to seize wealth and redistribute it or let it all burn. I can see why they did what they did, although I think history will not be kind.
- Hellbanevil 4y ago1. I agree with you kinda. 2. Why did prices for pretty much everything go up the week, or two, after the media started talking about the war, supply chain problems, and government spending? Prices were pretty steady during Covid, at least on food, and gas, and most consumer products, except building materials, and appliances. I personally think corporations used the war, and Covid, to raise prices seemingly overnight. My Chevron station went from $4.29 to $6.25 in a day. These companies made record profits during Covid, but poof in a couple of weeks just blew up their pricing? I think they used found a few good excuses to raise prices; and they all fell in line. Kinda like my $5.49 rebate on my $800/yr. insurance policy at the beginning of Covid. Mercury by the way, and they used to be fair. Yea, I was uncomfortable with Powell throwing money at the stock market, and buying all those mortgage backed securities, when housing and the stock market thrived during Covid. His response was, 'I kept my agreement with the financial sector.' Weird times for sure.
- atoav 4y agoIf the median rent costs double (or tripple, or more) the median income any discourse about how indivduals spend their money is not only pointless, it is cynical. Problems of that scale cannot be tackled by changing individual spending. You could move somewhere else (if you can actually afford to do so), but the problem is not limited to one region.
- sokoloff 4y ago> If the median rent costs double (or tripple, or more) the median income any discourse about how indivduals spend their money is not only pointless, it is cynical. It obviously does not. The cost to purchase an entire house and the land it sits on is at that multiple or slightly more. The cost to merely use the median rental for a year is under the median income.
- rodelrod 4y ago> The cost to purchase an entire house and the land it sits on is at that multiple or slightly more. Where is this magical place?
- einszwei 4y agoI assume they mean that rental payment would be replaced with mortgage payment - for multiple decades to own a home.
- effingwewt 4y agoIt's still complete bullshit, rent has gone up not just mortgages. They are also are ignoring inflation and all the companies using the Ukraine war and the lockdown to justify the price multiples. While all are hitting record profits. Rent, not mortgages, has gone up from 1k to 2.5k here. For a one bedroom apartment. Minimum wage here will get you ~2k/mo. Minimum wage doesn't come close to hitting rents, especially when they have insane demands like you must make 4x the rent to even apply. It's hilarious that landlords were crying they couldn't rent their places out because of coronavirus, then they increased their rents 2-4x, the places are still empty- as are the houses for sale, yet they seem fine with empty property now. I'd always laugh at the articles saying there wasn't a grand exodus from California, as I see it every day. Still to this day, just not as many. Where did they go? Texas for the most part. And what happened to Austin? Priced locals out. Now those Texans are moving, but not here, they can't afford the exorbitant prices of everything ($7/gal for gas!). Many Texans are still making $7.25/hr. How tf can anyone afford to live with that? Cell phones cost the same, power costs the same, rent is getting there, internet costs the same as here in California where at least minimum wage is ~$15/hr. Poor people have been getting shit on since before the pandemic but now it's just evil what's happening.
- thriftwy 4y agoIf you're not buying lattes to compete for the same pool of available houses (and other people are doing that), you are absolutely ruin your economy by starving it for cash, while having price growth destroy any of your latte savings. Buy lattes and consider moving to where housing supply is not constrained.
- throw93232 4y agoHousing market is one big pyramid scheme, and "financial advisors" need new generation to join. Everyone MUST buy a house to start family. Well we found out that family and house are optional, and you can buy a latte instead!
- thriftwy 4y ago> Everyone MUST buy a house You can also inherit one, rent something or move where houses are cheaper. I'm not sure about the level of your irony so I clarify.
- cs137 4y agoIf you're not buying lattes to compete for the same pool of available houses (and other people are doing that), you are absolutely ruin your economy by starving it for cash I wish it were that easy to grind this economy to a halt, but it doesn't really work that way. Consumer shortfalls cause hiccups in the system, but the ruling class is still making steady progress on its mission to reduce the rest of us to generational peonage. You can boycott Black Friday, but so long as you have to show up for work to survive, the bad guys are going to keep winning.
- pydry 4y agoEvery systemic problem that the oligarchs of a capitalist system dont want to fix the sensible way eventually gets framed as a problem of personal responsibility. * When the first cars started killing people -> make jaywalking a crime. * When people take on too much credit card debt -> obviously a problem with financial literacy * When large companies destroy the environment -> if people just recycled more we could save the planet... * You're broke in 1990 -> why didnt you get a degree? * you're broke in 2000 with a degree -> why didnt you get a STEM degree? * you're broke in 2010 with a STEM degree -> why didnt you get a compsci degree? * You're broke in 2020 with a compsci degree -> tsk you should have done something useful like machine learning.
- romanovcode 4y agoDon't forget the: * Global warming -> Stop using your car and planes * Plastics everywhere -> Just stop using plastic straws and bags, that will fix it!
- pydry 4y agoThis only actually twigged for me when I worked for a large company that was pretty horrible for the environment that kept pushing this canard about everybody doing their bit with recycling. ...i know, i know right... why didnt I just take personal responsibility and not take a job at a horrible company that pollutes? Thats how I could do my bit. Being an environmentalist 5th column is probably the way to go, actually.
- chasd00 4y agoThe plastic straw thing blew my mind. I’m convinced it was a viral marketing ploy by the paper industry. That’s pretty far into conspiracy territory but it makes more sense than the saving the turtles story.
- serpix 4y agoThe answer all along was to invest in index funds starting from age 5.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoThe economy is what it is, and you can't really control house prices. Still, being frugal is not a bad advice and will definitely help you save money. What's the mental health cost though? That latte or that luxury item can be what keep you sane in a world that become increasingly worse. Lattes, pr0n, weed, alcohol. They definitely have their pro and cons, but they may be needed at certain times of your life. If they start ruining your life, seek help.
- cloutchaser 4y agoWell, all this macro economics discussion is nice. But on a micro level, you can't get around the fact that if you spend $50 on lattes a month, and then you stop doing that, you will have $50 more per month. And if you spend $50 on buying a luxury brand shirt rather than a $10 shirt, you have $40 less. If you DON'T spend $50 on lattes, then obviously you can't save that money. Anything else is self flaggelating excuses about why you need to buy lattes, and why capitalism is bad, and an excuse for your status games or your consumer desires. Fact is, if you buy lattes, you can save that money instead.
- kaybe 4y agoSo you'll have $600 per year. Good luck buying housing on that budget.
- sifar 4y agoAn alternative way to look at it is you would need a 12K investment @5% to generate those $600. Now how many such $600 are lurking in your habits. May be that would change your perspective.
- cloutchaser 4y agoIt's an example ffs. If that's your criticism of what I wrote, it doesn't really make sense, everyone can personally decide how much they want to spend on avoidable luxuries. But btw, $50 a month means $50 extra you can spend on mortgage payments, which can actually add a couple of thousand dollars to your budget potentially.
- Mordisquitos 4y agoEveryone can personally decide how much they want to spend on avoidable luxuries, of course. It just so happens that the "avoidable luxuries" that the overwhelming majority of the population can afford—the clichéd old lattes and avocado toast—are mere rounding errors when compared to the cost of housing that is keeping them from being able to own a home.
- 4y ago
- Tycho 4y agoIs housing unaffordable, or is it just that everyone wants to live in the same few places? That’s the impression I get in the UK. Of course the houses/neighbourhoods that everyone wants to live in will be unaffordable to most. That will always be true, basically.
- TuringTest 4y agoThe problem is that people want to live there because that is where employment is concentrated, so they have more opportunities to choose. Remote work may somewhat alleviate the problem, though it will take time and it won't dissappear entirely.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoWhen I was living and working in the UK I got that same impression. Trying to buy a property anywhere in central London is nigh on impossible. The only people living there are the very wealthy and the very poor in social housing projects. My colleagues used to commute in by train from two hours away each day, but I'm guessing they're leaning heavily into remote work now. There's nice areas in the UK which are dying because everyone wants to live in some metropolitan area. It's a real pity, but I can't see the trend reversing anytime soon.
- rodelrod 4y ago> There's nice areas in the UK which are dying because everyone wants to live in some metropolitan area. Maybe because > My colleagues used to commute in by train from two hours away each day ?
- anonymoushn 4y agoIt's illegal to build dense housing almost everywhere in the U.S.
- 4y ago
- Melting_Harps 4y agoWhether it's lattes, I don't even drink caffeine, or avocado toast (I used to eat this frequently to spite this adage) narratives, it's all in the attempt to justify the perpetual consolidation of wealth in developed countries: I think the avocado toast was from a real estate guy in Australia doing his best to tell people about pulling up by the bootstraps. The truth is that the lower rungs of the economy have been sacrificed in order to cater to the upper classes, and it has been this way since Reagan-Thatcher were in office. This has always existed before, but at no point in time has it been this blatant where failing up because of your social status has been this prevalent for the upper class, and whether it's University admission scams, white collar crime, to economic malfeasance... there is no limit to what length they will go to skew the game in their favour. I think if people are being honest with their children in the developed Western World is that they should be optimizing them to either take over a family owned and operated business if it exists, or simply to teach them to have skills in which they can bypass the university debt trap and travel abroad and work remotely in order to maybe settle elsewhere, because this insanity has gone on for far too long. Career building implies their is some integrity in the system but when it's built on nepotism and corruption one has to ask the very obvious question: why is this worth investing my child's life into? And who benefits the most for this? As a millennial from the US that studied STEM and worked in my field, and eventual became an entrepreneur in fintech and hired both local and international talent: my country failed me every step of the way. It never failed to hinder or prevent my ability to excel in anything that didn't first serve the interests of multinational corporation(s) or the business interests of someone who 'played the game.' Venturing out on my own and finding my own path in 2012 after paying off tons of student debt was not recreational, it was foreshadowing what I thought was happening in just the US but in most developed nations: self-cannibalization. Politicians and the Boomers who elected them had access to cheap credit and stable careers that allowed for some savings were able to leverage that and have a glut of viable tenets pay not just for their mortgages by renting out rooms at inflated costs, but their very lifestyle. It disgusted me to my core how brash and calloused people had become that they'd exploit education and housing to such a degree under the pretense of 'getting mine' when they were handed it on a silver platter all while simultaneously thinking this was achievable based on merit. The last landlord I had literately moved in his ex-wife unbeknownst to us and then subsidized her expenses based on increasing rent costs during COVID as we didn't chose to take advantage of the rent relief option. I lost all respect for this class of individual and I now want to see them get economically ruined as I think it's the only chance for any level of reform at this point: mass homelessness and unemployment from 2008-COVID onward didn't change anything, a perpetual bondage based University debt system hasn't changed anything, lower standards of living and shorter life expediencies for Millenials and likely Gen Z hasn't either. I've come to the conclusion that nothing less than the significant die off, or in this case financial ruin, of the affluent boomer will lead to any significant reform.
- ricardobayes 4y agoBefore working in high-tech, I worked in retail for a short while. My experience is in retail or other lower-paid jobs it's almost impossible to save money, and not because of the salary. I found I needed to 'reward' myself almost everyday with a relatively expensive thing to keep going. An expensive coffee, 'fancy' meal (think more expensive than the 3.50 sandwich+drink combo I could afford). Interestingly, working in tech, I never needed any of this.
- cs137 4y agoThe system is designed that way. Will power is a finite resource, and people get pummeled so hard at work, their need to execute what tiny bit of freedom they can scrape off the world results in their eating a tasty but unhealthy lunch at a chain restaurant to "treat themselves". Our whole society wouldn't function if people weren't exhausted to the point where their brains malfunction and they make bad choices. Wait till they bring Jira and Agile to your tech job, though. You'll find yourself "needing" expensive toys again.
- ricardobayes 4y agoOh they have, and to top if off, we have a daily 'standup' for about 1.5-2 hours (yep) every day. Still, since I'm in the comfort of my home, and my work is relatively well interfaced meaning I only need to really speak to the backend and product people, the mental drain is so much less compared to the brutality of engaging with the general public.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoI can't find the original source now, but millenials spend significantly less than boomers did on eating out and entertainment. The biggest delta was healthcare, which millenials spent, if I remember correctly, over twice as much monthly on. Couple that with all time high income to housing price ratios[1], higher than 2008 housing bubble, and the idea that lattes are the problem is asinine. https://www.longtermtrends.net/stocks-to-real-estate-ratio/ https://www.longtermtrends.net/stocks-to-real-estate-ratio/
- me_me_me 4y agoYou can insert any Millenials kill X industry meme too, no matter what millenials are to blame
- sershe 4y agoI dunno, after growing up ~poor and now working in tech I am still acutely aware of prices. Because I have to make an effort to tell myself I can afford things easily, many of my purchases tend to be baseline-cheap or with no concern for the price, with less middle ground than one would expect. Sometimes I have relapses when I pick up my usual fancy coffee bag and I'm like "why are you buying fancy coffee, the store brand has twice as much beans for the same price", so I have to be like "it's ok, whatever, I can afford it". Which is probably also not too healthy. Still, with that background, I do notice things... Like e.g. someone I know who grew up lower middle class in America (n=1, admittedly) being surprisingly oblivious of prices in the grocery store. Buying $7 artisanal ice-cream when $3 ice-cream is just as good - it's literally $100/mo right there, just on one item. Sure, they can easily afford it now, but I wonder if the notion that it costs $100/mo even crosses their mind in any way. I see people who look like they are homeless (there's a big extremely-affordable-housing apartment building next to the store) buying fancy beer... when I was poor I was drinking Bud Light equivalent ;) I am only slightly judging - to each their own, but then, it might indeed cramp your spending elsewhere.