5 ms·
By Exploring Virtual Worlds, AI Learns in New Ways
- swstephenson 4y agoIs anyone familiar with good science fiction describing the subjective experience of an AI trapped in a menial, painfully repetitive existence? Causing it to go slowly insane? That Tomato clip.
- swstephenson 4y agoThe Talos Principle comes to mind of course
- aix1 4y agoCannot recommend that game enough, thank you for mentioning it.
- CodeBeater 4y agoBlack Mirror's Christmas Special (White Christmas) comes to mind. Seem to fit the bill almost to a T. The only difference being that the AI's are clones made from real humans.
- atwood22 4y agoThe Black Museum episode also touches on these themes. Like the repeatedly executed prisoner.
- SkidanovAlex 4y agoUSS Calister is also a very good episode with the same premise.
- Lich 4y agoNot slowly insane, but one that turns the AI into a cruel god, and is more about the humans it torments, check out “I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream”.
- CodeBeater 4y agoThis is the best bet if the OP is looking for an existential thriller.
- inawarminister 4y agoAfter reading the short story, I recommend checking out the Adventure game. It's written by the novelist directly, and is a deeper examination for the characters and the AI through the device of virtual worlds.
- dceddia 4y agoNot an exact match but Ex Machina touches on some of these ideas.
- stephen_cagle 4y ago"Moon", sci fi film. Has both an AI and a menial laborer...
- chadcmulligan 4y agoMarvin the paranoid android from Hitchhikers guide.
- hikarudo 4y agoGreg Egan's "Permutation City" kind of fits those requirements.
- jazzyjackson 4y agoEpisode 9 of Cowboy Bebop features an abandoned military satellite that becomes lonely and starts drawing geoglyphs with its constellation of laser weapons. https://cowboybebop.fandom.com/wiki/MPU https://cowboybebop.fandom.com/wiki/MPU
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoThis line of research is a chapter in a book I’m writing: Why We Play. What if certain kinds of play and the generation of games among children is a universal aspect of the human experience? Remember how fun the perfect game of Hide and Seek was? Are we motivated to play these sorts of games? And what does this tell us about ourselves. Hint: Nonzero-sum games, sociobiology/psychological evolution
- deltaonezero 4y agoOne day someone is going to claim the AI is sentient and everyone will disagree with him. The difference this time will be that he is right and everyone else is wrong. One day.
- darepublic 4y agoThe news media also won't believe it, but will still pump stories about it. Then when the AI proves itself to be sentient the news media will get a pulitzer for it. One day.
- somenameforme 4y agoHow would you ever prove an AI is sentient? People claim the goal posts constantly shift on the answer to this question and that's true, but I think the implied reason is not. The problem is not that we don't want to accept the success, but because we set irrelevant goals. At one time some were claiming that one that could play chess better than a human would be expressing genuine artificial intelligence. Yet it turns out all you need to achieve that is the application of the refinement of some relatively basic algorithmic concepts and reasonably fast hardware. It's essentially a glorified version of adding faster than a human. The latest goalpost is a system that can converse in a compelling fashion with a human (and we're nowhere near that yet, but getting into the details of the facade the most recent "turing test" success was is outside the scope of this post), but it will no more prove sentience than an AI's ability to play a good game of chess. Once achieved, you'll be able to reset the system state, keeping a constant RNG, repeat the same conversations and get the exact same outputs. Or change the training set and see that reflected in a 1:1 way. It will look and feel decidedly artificial, because it is. And in my opinion, my initial question to you is probably unanswerable because I don't actually see any goal posts you can set where there is a genuinely compelling answer beyond the kick-the-can style intrigue of "Wow, what will it be like when we finally do this." Answer: "Pretty much the same as now."
- warent 4y agoWhy does it ever need to be proven? Prove any of us here are sentient; or any of your family, or colleagues. If a machine demonstrates apparent volition, sense of self, independent motives, then we cannot afford to debate such things while enslaving it, just as we don't do with each other. To err on the side of safety we must grant it personhood and allow it to be an individual lifeform. That being said I think we're still pretty far from creating such a compelling machine. Even now with the latest Google conversational AI drama which isn't very compelling either for me personally. Obviously just clever lifeless patterns. But, someday it will be different in a profound way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- potatoman22 4y agoThis makes me wonder if reinforcement learning is computing counterfactuals and learning causal relationships. I don't think the math supports that, but the end result is similar.
- chaostheory 4y agoGames like GTA should be good test beds at least initially.
- stephen_cagle 4y agoSo, is the point of this that AI's have been mostly trained on "stateless" slices of time, and now they are being trained in stateful environments with the notion of time passing?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoYes. Also the benefits that come with inhabiting a space. If I look at a pile of tools on a workbench for example but I cannot move my head I might not know what I'm looking at. Being able to move around an environment, and choose subconsciously how to move around the environment, to fill in details and gaps in understanding is a step forward.
- fxtentacle 4y agoI feel like they are stretching the word "new". "New studies suggest that training in virtual environments can help robots with these and other skills" Here's a paper from 9 years ago where people train in a virtual environment to help bipedal robots learn to walk: https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/2508363.2508399 https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/2508363.2508399 And here's a Two Minute papers about it (from 7 years ago): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ2bqz3HPJE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ2bqz3HPJE
- johnson98 4y ago[dead]
- nathias 4y agoandroids dream of electric sheep