2 ms·
> A perfect storm of events has led to a once-in-a-lifetime discovery for a gold miner, a First Nation, a veteran paleontologist and a territory. Saying 'a Fir
by OJFord 4y ago
> A perfect storm of events has led to a once-in-a-lifetime discovery for a gold miner, a First Nation, a veteran paleontologist and a territory.
Saying 'a First Nation' like that is equivalent to saying 'a female' - which people also mistakenly say - or 'a British', which nobody would say.
'Canadian' happens to be both adjective and (proper) noun; that doesn't mean everything is, eh.
- lolinder 4y agoThis use of "a First Nation" is meant to refer to the group of people, not an individual. I believe it's equivalent to saying in the US "a Native American tribe". EDIT: see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Nations_in_Canada https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Nations_in_Canada > Some indigenous peoples in Canada have also adopted the term First Nation to replace the word "band" in the formal name of their community.
- OJFord 4y agoThen why 'a'? It still seems wrong to me, like (but opposite) 'woman police officer', it should surely be 'a First Nation people' or something? To use your example, it sounds to me like 'a Native'. 'Native what?' I'm left wondering as a reader. Perhaps I'm wrong, I'm not Canadian, nor 'a First Nation', it just doesn't scan to me.
- stormbrew 4y agoIt parses a little ambiguous or odd to me but not wrong. It's the Tr'ondëk Hwëch'in First Nation, one of many First Nations in Canada. The analogous word you might be reaching for would probably be tribe or band, and neither "a tribe" or "a band" read weird to me at all. Within the Canadian legal framework, the treaties between Canada and its indigenous population are at least theoretically between distinct "nations".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- derefr 4y ago"Nation" is already a collective noun. Canada is a nation. These people, as a group, are also a nation.
- Rastonbury 4y agoA First Nation, a Nation, a Territory (which is in the sentence)
- denkmoon 4y agoThe sentence is structured a bit oddly but are you really proposing someone wouldn't say "A British veteran paleontologist"? It is not uncommon to mention someone's nationality alongside their profession when talking in an international context.