3 ms·
"The irony, for those about to have a kneejerk reaction about merely considering the financial realities of marriage instead of solely the love partnership part
by giantg2 4y ago
"The irony, for those about to have a kneejerk reaction about merely considering the financial realities of marriage instead of solely the love partnership part, is that this kind of pre-planning actually allows you to focus on the love part. You don't have to be skeptical or worried about any partner or anecdotes because you have it all figured out."
That's my basic opinion. My wife and her family had a fit when I suggested a prenup, even though it mostly followed the general guidelines in law with the removal of alimony. It was crying and "you don't know what you're doing" with not a logical argument in sight. I just wanted a calm, rational conversation. Instead I feel like I was emotionally bullied and manipulated. If only I realized it then.
- yieldcrv 4y agoYeah, on that topic, I wish alimony was modified more holistically at the state level to avoid this discussion. Proponents say “one person does more unpaid labor to support the breadwinner and the lifestyle they were both beneificiaries of”, but why does seemingly nobody create a market value of that unpaid labor (feel free to correct me if I’m wrong). People act like this unpaid labor is the same value at any amount of money that the lifestyle costs, when that’s not true. “You did the dishes most often according to these angry text messages, and also got to travel to Tuscany in luxury, so here is $800,000 for 10 years and if your ex has any disruption in income then they have to check themselves into jail, if they make more we can modify that amount upwards and assume their income never goes down” I would like alimony capped at the state level in both amount and time based on what the value of supportive household/emotional labor is. Monaco’s alimony law is a decent rubric.
- giantg2 4y agoThat's the problem. It's not even based on unpaid labor. There are courts assigning alimony to support porn addiction and other lifestyle factors. If it were based on unpaid labor, my wife would be paying me for all the high-rate mechanic, handyman, tech support, accounting, etc work. By getting married the lower earner is basically taking possession of your earning potential. “You did the dishes most often according to these angry text messages, and also got to travel to Tuscany in luxury, so here is $800,000 for 10 years and if your ex has any disruption in income then they have to check themselves into jail, if they make more we can modify that amount upwards and assume their income never goes down” If anyone thinks this is joking, my wife's father was in an accident and then a coma. Lost his job and obviously wasnt making money in a coma. Apparently the child support payments emptied his account. He was arrested for not paying. He then couldn't find any decent job with the arrest record.
- moneywoes 4y agoCo auld prenup have helped? Crypto?
- yieldcrv 4y ago> If it were based on unpaid labor, my wife would be paying me for all the high-rate mechanic, handyman, tech support, accounting, etc work. Great rebuttal I wonder if this has been successfully argued by a breadwinner in calculating alimony payment amounts or alimony reform Too bad all of this is stuck in family courts at the municipal level and not publicly indexed, the information is fragmented
- giantg2 4y agoMy cynical guess is that if you argue that you did all these tasks, then the spouse will argue that it's part of their lifestyle to not handle that. That they will have to pay someone to do all that for them, and thus the breadwinner who did all that work should give them money to hire someone.
- yieldcrv 4y agoThat is quite cynical, but I could see it being argued especially if there isn't a scenario to cancel costs out.