5 ms·
> Without modern machinery and a national network keeping this place supplied with essentials there’s no way the current population of 2,200,000 people could su
by criddell 4y ago
> Without modern machinery and a national network keeping this place supplied with essentials there’s no way the current population of 2,200,000 people could survive in this environment. Las Vegas is basically a space colony.
Isn't that true of every large city? Is there any city of millions of people where you could put a wall around it and it would be self-sustaining? All cities rely on having food trucked in, use electricity mostly generated elsewhere, rely on water that comes from outside the city, etc...
- woodruffw 4y agoI think “survive in this environment” is meant to reflect the fact that human beings could not exist for nontrivial periods in the Nevada Desert. Contrast that with San Diego or New York, where the environment is not actively trying to kill you during most of the year. All cities import goods, because the economics favor it (space is at a premium). But most cities don’t exist in spite of their physical environs; they’re generally situated somewhere that’s advantageous to ordinary economic conduct (along rivers, lakes, coasts, etc.)
- mgraczyk 4y agoBut even in San Diego, it seems there isn't enough freshwater to support a population nearly as large as the city has. From a quick search it looks like SD imports something like 80% of it's water. I think Las Vegas is not really unique in this way, just a bit more extreme.
- bin_bash 4y agoWell they get their water from the same source (Colorado River). The difference is that river is right next to Vegas, so it's not imported. San Diego pipes it 200 miles across the state. The reason Vegas has such limited water is because California and Arizona have far more water rights. (Only 4% in fact) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River_Compact
- yellowapple 4y ago> The reason Vegas has such limited water is because California and Arizona have far more water rights. Which is a key reason why California needs to be sticking oodles of desalination plants along its absurdly long coastline yesterday. There is zero good reason why a top-10-in-the-world economy concentrated primarily on said absurdly long coastline should be dependent on water flowing from literal deserts. If California's so averse to the requisite power requirements to make droughts a thing of the past (it's almost as if shutting down nuclear plants might have downstream effects), then there's ample opportunity for Nevada and Arizona to step up to the plate as literal powerhouses. On geothermal energy maps, Nevada in particular is a giant blob of heat; plus, I can think of no better place for sprawling solar farms than "inhospitable" deserts. Nevada/Arizona powers California, California hydrates Nevada/Arizona, win-win.
- kortilla 4y agoIn New York the environment is most definitely trying to kill you. Spend a winter without heat to see what I mean. We’ve just solved the “how to keep your house warm” problem a lot earlier than “how to keep it cool” so you don’t think of heating as spiting the environment, even though it is.
- downandout 4y ago"Contrast that with San Diego or New York, where the environment is not actively trying to kill you during most of the year" Las Vegas is inordinately hot only 3 months of the year. The rest of the time the weather is relatively mild. That's hardly "actively trying to kill you during most of the year". Many people who visit Las Vegas only do so during the summer, so it seems like it's hot most of the time to them, but this is a myth. Having grown up in San Diego and currently living in Las Vegas, I'm not sure what special advantages you are implying it has that would enable it to be "advantageous to ordinary economic conduct" vs Las Vegas. It's next to an ocean full of water that you cannot drink (without expensive water treatment). Produce is grown in California (with water that it deprives Las Vegas of), but mostly not near San Diego, so it has to be transported in to support its massive population, just like it has to be to Las Vegas. In fact, the agricultural centers of California are approximately equidistant to both San Diego and Las Vegas, perhaps +/- 100 miles. Even putting aside the other issues with California - overpopulation, insane politics, high crime rates, absurdly high state income tax, high cost of living, etc. - I don't see any serious advantage that Southern California in general has over Las Vegas, unless you just like the beach (and even then...it's a 3.5 hour drive or 30 minute flight to Southern California). In fact, many Californians are starting to realize this, and are invading us.
- AlbertCory 4y agoYou're not the first one to point out that Southern California is a desert, and has to import water from elsewhere just to exist, e.g. "Chinatown." However, the weather is way better than Vegas, and I'm not just talking about summer. A cold ocean has its advantages.
- bin_bash 4y agoSan Diego (and LA) are not deserts. That is a myth.
- AlbertCory 4y agoWhat's the average rainfall? [1] OK, not technically a "desert." But definitely not enough rain to support the population it has. [1] http://www.laalmanac.com/images3/chart_rainfall_LA_1887_2020.jpg http://www.laalmanac.com/images3/chart_rainfall_LA_1887_2020...
- criddell 4y agoI didn’t read it like that because the author included the part about 2.2 million people. How long would the millions in New York or San Diego survive if their water and power and food deliveries were cut off?
- WillPostForFood 4y agoI think “survive in this environment” is meant to reflect the fact that human beings could not exist for nontrivial periods in the Nevada Desert. Native American tribes lived in the Nevada dessert for at least a thousand years. The Southern Paiute lived in the Las Vegas area. https://lasvegassun.com/news/2015/jul/20/las-vegas-smallest-sovereign-nation/ https://lasvegassun.com/news/2015/jul/20/las-vegas-smallest-...
- yellowapple 4y ago> the fact that human beings could not exist for nontrivial periods in the Nevada Desert That ain't really a fact; native peoples have lived in said desert for thousands of years, and settlers for hundreds. The actual fact is that back in those days the population was small enough for the desert to support and flexible enough to adapt to said support. Vegas in particular is situated "somewhere that's advantageous to ordinary economic conduct". So is Reno. That's indeed a big part of why they've been able to grow and stay grown (instead of collapsing as rapidly as they're established, like the average mining town). The problem is that the rivers supporting them (and the lakes/reservoirs supporting them) ain't infinite in capacity, not that they're entirely nonexistent.
- lom 4y agoYes, but with Las Vegas it probably mostly also comes out of state, and a different region altogether. Of course a New York doesn’t sustain itself with regional farming. But basic produce probably won’t come from a very far away plac,
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]