4 ms·
Just because RvW has been reversed does not mean life begins at conception. In fact, it is this debate, as to when life begins, that is the real underlying issu
by verdverm 4y ago
Just because RvW has been reversed does not mean life begins at conception. In fact, it is this debate, as to when life begins, that is the real underlying issue that will never have consensus. There will now be 50 different opinions codified into law. This is not a US specific debate or question, it's just been at the forefront of American politics because it was tied to a decision by a court top-down, rather than the people bottom up, republic style. Thus it became a national and political, one-size must fit all solution space, which can now have diversity.
I hope the debate evolves to center around the real questions rather than SCOTUS. What can science tell us (about when a fetus experiences pain or consciousness)? How does this inform our beliefs and the laws?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Just because RvW has been reversed does not mean life begins at conception. Legally, for purposes of homicide laws in the several of the trigger law states, it does (“fertilization”, actually.) > What can science tell us? That life is a 4+ billion year continuum, and that division into separate “lives”, some of which are deemed worthy of various levels of protection, is an arbitrary categorization based on subjective values. Stop trying to hope approaches that are about determining what is will give you a shortcut to what ought to be.
- Gibbon1 4y agoI think when life begins is a how many angels can dance on the head of a pin question. The fundamental truth is pregnancies often have bad outcomes. That runs head first in to conservative beliefs about chastity, tendency to frame everything as a moral issue, and to punch down when assigning blame. The result of conservatives banning maternal care for women is going have really bad consequences because their ideology doesn't match hard reality.