4 ms·
Yeah, my commentary on this nonsense is at https://gitlab.com/kragen/bubbleos/blob/master/CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md https://gitlab.com/kragen/bubbleos/blob/master/CODE
by kragen 4y ago
Yeah, my commentary on this nonsense is at https://gitlab.com/kragen/bubbleos/blob/master/CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md https://gitlab.com/kragen/bubbleos/blob/master/CODE_OF_CONDU....
> Could J. K. Rowling require Harry Potter readers to follow a code of
conduct? Could Werner Heisenberg demand that you subscribe to a code
of conduct if you want to do quantum physics?
...
> Codes of conduct typically make laudable promises such as “We pledge to respect all people,” in an attempt to convince readers that they [the authors] will behave laudably. In my experience, though, people who put a lot of effort into telling you how laudably they will behave do not behave any any more laudably than other people do — slightly the contrary, in fact. ...
> ... I expect
that I’ll be delighted if you send me patches and bug reports, but on
that count I make no promises. Feel free to send them repeatedly
through different channels if you don’t get a response at first, since
I often don’t notice things. If you like how I respond when you send
me patches or bug reports, then maybe it would be a good idea to do
more of it. If you don’t like it, then maybe you would be happier if
you stopped. I’ll do my best to be polite, but I screw that up pretty
often, to be honest. ...
> But, as I said before, what humans tell you they will do is not a
very reliable predictor of what they will do. If you want to know
what to expect of them, look at their past behavior. Don’t just look
at their self-reports of their past behavior, although admissions
against interest there can be quite revealing; look at traces it has
left that they cannot delete, such as your own memory, mailing list
archives, past Gitlab issues, and other people talking about them.
- kennywinker 4y ago> Could J. K. Rowling require Harry Potter readers to follow a code of conduct? Nobody attempts to apply codes of conduct to users of software - that's the domain of the license agreement. They only apply to communities. Virtually every online community around harry potter has some set of rules for participating in that community. e.g. https://stories.jkrowling.com/terms-of-use/ https://stories.jkrowling.com/terms-of-use/ > Could Werner Heisenberg demand that you subscribe to a code of conduct if you want to do quantum physics? Heisenberg was the post-ww2 president of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physics (quickly renamed the Max Planck Institute post war) - which was involved in human "medical" experimentation in nazi concentration camps. During his governence: "after 1945 neither active participants in the Third Reich nor hangers-on were called to account" - https://www.mpg.de/history/kws-under-national-socialism https://www.mpg.de/history/kws-under-national-socialism So a guy who presided over an organization that didn't bother to clean house after being directly involved in the fucking holocaust isn't exactly my go-to for how to run a healthy community.
- claytongulick 4y agoSo, you skipped over the point and went directly to the ad-hominem. Do you learn much with this approach?
- kennywinker 4y agoI did learn a bunch, I went on a bit of a dive refreshing what I knew about the MPI and Heisenberg. Interesting stuff. But back to your point. Your point was made using two examples. Bad examples, in my opinion, since the first doesn't apply (consumption of work vs collaboration) and the second one also doesn't apply (building on others work vs collaboration). Your further point about watching what people do vs what they say they do is a reasonable point, but doesn't have much to do with the value of a code of conduct. I'm pretty much in agreement, that's the best way to proceed when collaborating with a single individual - but communities are more than the sum of their parts. If there are three people collaborating on a project, and one swears a lot in their commits, and one prefers a lack of swearing, and one doesn't care either way - how do you resolve that conflict? Nothing you've said offers a useful tool to navigate that situation.
- kragen 4y agoYou seem to have me confused with someone else.
- kennywinker 4y agoYes you’re quite right - I didn’t notice that that reply wasn’t from you.
- kragen 4y agoI'm glad you started to pick up on the subtle point about Heisenberg, but it sounds like you stopped halfway. What would be the consequences of allowing Heisenberg to dictate codes of conduct for quantum physicists today, or Wagner to dictate codes of conduct for performers of his operas? I addressed the point about when codes of conduct apply to users of software in the document linked.