5 ms·
It's hard to tell for sure, but the evidence suggests that several tens of millions of people survive on Bitcoin remittances from their family members abroad.
by kragen 4y ago
It's hard to tell for sure, but the evidence suggests that several tens of millions of people survive on Bitcoin remittances from their family members abroad.
- giaour 4y agoWhat evidence?
- SahAssar 4y agoEven if they do, why would the best way to allow efficient international transfers be to invent a whole new financial system? If the money is coming from traditional money (as the workers are basically always paid in traditional money) and will be exchanged into traditional money (as the recipients of the remittances will exchange to to be able to use it) why would we want to add an intermediate crypto step (which is also quite volatile)?
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoIt’s the best way because those in power in the centralized institutions embedded along the existing financial system don’t want to service these “fringe” use cases that to them are too volatile. - that’s one potential answer at least.
- sshine 4y ago> why would the best way to allow efficient international transfers be to invent a whole new financial system? The risk of running a traditional currency exchange in places where people really need money is high. Some places simply don’t have a money service for this reason. If you can cut the middle man and transfer money discretely, you may actually be able to send money, as opposed to not. tl;dr: If the average risk is high enough, the volatility of Bitcoin and risk of getting scammed may actually be lower.
- SahAssar 4y agoBut you still need to have a bitcoin exchange accessible, both to the sender and to the receiver, right? And in the cases of unbanked areas that exchange needs to be physical and able to give out physical cash. It doesn't need to be the same exchange, but both those exchanges would still have the same issues as a traditional exchange, right? Walk me through a transaction that is better with bitcoin and would not be easier by modifying the current system.
- kragen 4y agoIf you postulate modifying the current system, of course you can postulate modifying it to be better than Bitcoin. But Bitcoin isn't hypothetical.
- SahAssar 4y agoI postulate that modifying the current system is easier than integrating bitcoin/crypto in ways that are actually good, and easier still than replaceing the current system wholesale with crypto.
- sshine 4y ago> modifying the current system is easier than integrating bitcoin/crypto in ways that are actually good This is true for societies that have good money systems.
- SahAssar 4y agoAnd you think that replacing the financial systems of those other societies with a system that no one (especially not the societies themselves) has any control over will be easier than improving their current systems?
- sshine 4y ago> you still need to have a bitcoin exchange accessible, both to the sender and to the receiver, right? No, you only need an exchange accessible to the sender. The receiver can receive Bitcoins; they don't even need to be online while receiving them, because they can agree on a fixed address. > in the cases of unbanked areas that exchange needs to be physical and able to give out physical cash That is the case for traditional currency exchanges. It is not the case for Bitcoin. The missing part that you might object to is of course: If the receiver eventually wants to convert their Bitcoins into some other currency (USD, or some local, not hyper-inflated currency), they do need some kind of exchange. But they can choose to wait until they have access, they can send Bitcoins themselves, and they can meet with people to exchange Bitcoins with the risk that involves. None of these scenarios requires a traditional currency exchange to be available in their area. Running such a currency exchange is presumably too risky / not worth it. But being an individual Bitcoin trader might, because individuals are exposed to and assess different risks.
- RestlessMind 4y agoA colleague who sends money to his family in a third world country with unstable currency explained to me why he uses crypto to do so. Even if he uses dollars to initiate the transfer here in the US, his family is going to receive it in the local currency. But that would incur losses as the official exchange rate is held artificially low. Also that currency is losing value very fast due to high inflation (much higher than the US in fact). So it is much better for his family to have their savings in Bitcoin. If there was a way to transmit gold easily avoiding government rules, he could have done that too but sending gold to his country is impossible. This gets to the heart of another common refrain on HN that Bitcoin is great to facilitate illegal transactions. Well guess what, if a shitty government in some corner of the world is going to make it difficult for its citizens to live a normal peaceful life by devaluing currency and imposing artificial barriers to save meaningfully, then I am rooting for Bitcoin to help people evade that tyranny.
- democracy 4y agoWhat country is that?
- antoniuschan99 4y agoStellar Lumens are actually more suited for Remittances. It’s one of things it aims to provide. https://stellar.org/learn/stellar-for-remittances?locale=en https://stellar.org/learn/stellar-for-remittances?locale=en
- randomhodler84 4y agoSure but why would anyone want Jed’s PoS token in the first place? They just printed it and gave it away to people on Facebook when launched. Like all PoS tokens, they have no value and cannot really be used as a universal medium of exchange between fiat; they are best to be used as the antispam and fee mechanism, to conserve and meter precious eternally recorded storage.
- DennisP 4y ago> Like all PoS tokens, they have no value Then what's special about PoW tokens that give them value?
- randomhodler84 4y agoThat we had to fight for them be created. Eternal hash war. We didn’t wave a pen or type a keystroke to magic them into existence.
- ForHackernews 4y agoDon't flatter yourself: wasting electricity running sha256 a billion times is not "fighting" for anything.
- randomhodler84 4y agoBetter to spill the electrons of the enemy than their blood. We can only hope that future warfare is computational, rather than kinetic.
- msoad 4y agoPeople I know send money to their families using Western Union or PayPal. It's often completely free to send money using those systems.
- kragen 4y agoI guess you don't know anybody whose families are in Cuba, Iran, or Venezuela.
- msoad 4y agoSending money to those countries is against US sanctions. So now we're back to the point a lot of cryptocurrency skeptics say. It's only useful for illegal activities.
- kragen 4y agoIt's not illegal if you're not in the US, which 95% of people aren't. And there's an exemption in the sanctions for family remittances, so it's not illegal then either.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lobocinza 4y agoNot really. PayPal I believe it's ~3% fees + spread + taxes. That's not free. I just sent some money to myself (not via Paypal) effective fee was 2,38% and I will have to wait 3 days. Crypto for a time was a good exchange medium, low fees, almost instant, no KYC, less bureaucracy. But I believe those days are counted because for good and bad it's now regulated and was reduced to speculative virtual assets.
- kragen 4y agoMaybe PayPal subsidizes some users to make it "free" in exchange for gaining control of their finances. They're notorious for stealing users' entire account balances and justifying it with unsubstantiated accusations of fraud, so gaining control of more users' finances is very profitable for them.
- democracy 4y agoWhere is this evidence? People like to mention it, but no, there is no such group in the world of a meaningful size to depend on bitcoin for international money transfers.