8 ms·
I gave up anonymity. I just learned to lean into taking control of my ID. Some time ago, I realized that there's no way for me to participate online, without th
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
I gave up anonymity. I just learned to lean into taking control of my ID. Some time ago, I realized that there's no way for me to participate online, without things being attributed to me.
I learned this, by setting up a Disqus ID. I wanted to comment on a blog post, and started to set up an account.
After I started the process, it came back, with a list of random posts, from around the Internet (and some, very old), and said "Are these yours? If so, would you like to associate them with your account?"
I freaked. Many of them were outright troll comments (I was not always the haloed saint that you see before you) that I had sworn were done anonymously. They came from many different places (including DejaNews). I have no idea how Disqus found them.
Every single one of them was mine. Many, were ones that I had sworn were dead and buried in a deep grave in the mountains.
Needless to say, I do not have a Disqus ID.
Being non-anonymous means that I need to behave myself, online. I come across as a bit of a stuffy bore, but I suspect my IRL persona is that way, as well.
That's OK.
- pmichaud 4y agoThis is also my strategy for similar reasons. I don't ever want to be confused that the future is watching what I do online, so I post using my name.
- sovnade 4y agoDon't forget the other part - being non-anonymous online makes it easy for stalkers and other bad actors to take it to the extreme. We need anonymity for lots of reasons.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have ... interesting ... friends. I'll bet I know scarier people IRL, than I'll find online. Also, what impressed me about the Disqus incident, was how fast it came back with that list. In the US, at least, true anonymity takes a lot of work. For example, if you own a house, people can use tax records to find out who you are, unless you do what rich people do, and use shell companies. I also own a couple of [small] companies. I maintain a UPS box, because they get a lot of junk mail (and some business junk mail comes to my home address, anyway). That's just one of hundreds of ways we can be found. Many predate teh Internets Tubes. My mailbox gets stuffed with junk mail. Some of it is quite specific. They use these mechanisms, and have been, for decades. I have known folks in the collections industry. They can find people surprisingly easily. There was one guy who used to be a skip tracer, and he wrote a book called How to Disappear[0]. It's a fairly sobering read (and probably quaintly anachronistic, these days). The Unabomber actually did it correctly. He only got nailed, once he posted something publicly. [0] https://www.amazon.com/How-Disappear-Digital-Footprint-Without/dp/1493045288 https://www.amazon.com/How-Disappear-Digital-Footprint-Witho...
- ntoskrnl 4y agoThis reminds me of a post I saw on /r/fatfire about how to buy a house anonymously. I have it bookmarked in case my company ever takes off. https://old.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/comments/l0wd5i/update_to_purchasing_home_anonymously_with/ https://old.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/comments/l0wd5i/update_to_p...
- yieldcrv 4y agoAlso just because there is a law doesn't mean there are consequences codified, and this is most true regarding states laws that “require” an LLC registered in their state. Remember that states are in competition for business, there are hurdles for them to do annoying things. The best example I’ve seen in one state is that a local LLC branch is required after your foreign LLC gets sued, and the limited liability is active and retroactively applied at that point in time. But hey maybe your anonymous LLC deters people from suing to begin with. (This is different than there being a law codified and not being enforced)
- collegeburner 4y ago"Anonymous" LLCs are going away. FinCEN will be requiring reporting of everybody with ownership greater than 25% starting in probably 1-2 years from now. The fucking feds won't let us have anything without stalking our every move.
- yieldcrv 4y agoYes, their proposed implementations of that act look pretty onerous and unnecessarily difficult to comply with But I’m fine with one agency of the federal government having a private database, shareable for some investigations, which is the direction its going I hope it gets handicapped or repealed
- mst 4y agoMy name being Matt S Trout, abbreviated on various documents as 'MS TROUT', I regularly get junk mail addressed to 'Ms. Trout'. Once, my housemate got junk mail addressed to 'Mr. <firstname> Trout' as a result. He was a trifle annoyed by this but his partner found it hilarious.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ReactiveJelly 4y agoThat's okay, as long as there is no police state hunting you. That's okay, as long as you aren't a member of any persecuted minority, and as long as you don't have any interesting political views to share.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoYou are absolutely correct. It’s fine, for me. I actually know folks that it would not be OK. I am not giving advice; merely recounting what I have experienced, and the personal choices I have made, based on those experiences.
- mst 4y agoI've on a number of occasions expressed opinions because I believe they needed to be expressed and I knew the other folks holding those opinions wouldn't be ok to do so, whereas I probably would (and have largely survived that so far). A small use of privilege but I hope a useful one overall.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThat's a good point.
- alcover 4y ago> some, very old > I had sworn were done anonymously How in the hell did they do it ? I presume you changed IP and user-agent many times over since then... How ?
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have no idea. This was before all the machine learning stuff came into fashion.
- thegabriele 4y agoPerhaps same email address?
- EwanToo 4y agoThey keep all the data posted since the early days of the internet, and are applying machine learning to it now (and will continue to into the future).
- alcover 4y agoThat's chilling.. The only long-going thread of attribution would rely on stylometry - a good fit for ML though..
- woojoo666 4y ago3rd party cookies perhaps? I'm actually very curious how this was possible too
- jerezzprime 4y agoLikely they drop a cookie with a session ID. I believe (but have no knowledge) that Disqus presents in an iframe, so the cookie persists whenever it loads on a page. So they can attribute all posts from that common session id. That said, chrome does not sync cookies, so this method only works as long as cookies don't get cleared (or computer replaced etc). So it might be something else, given the implied age of the comments.
- 4y ago
- chaostheory 4y agoYou don’t need to give up privacy. You just have to pay for it. If you want search engine privacy, Optery offers it as a service. https://www.optery.com/ https://www.optery.com/ It’s a YC company. My only affiliation is that I’m a customer. I have a discount code if anyone is interested. I wasn’t sure if I could just paste it in the comments
- colejohnson66 4y agoI’m getting nothing but PHP errors just visiting that page
- chaostheory 4y agoNot sure what you’re seeing, but it still works fine for me Maybe ping them? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30605010 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30605010 Are you sure it’s not an issue on your end Cole?
- colejohnson66 4y agoJust tried again and it’s working now. Regardless, I’m not sure how it could be my end when the site was spitting PHP errors listing filepaths on their server.
- p1esk 4y agoWhat prevents them from selling the database of their paid users to the highest bidder?
- chaostheory 4y agoNo clue. You’re going to have to ask https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=beyondd https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=beyondd I’m assuming that YC frowns on their funded companies doing unsavory things?
- 4y ago
- gentleman11 4y agoThese are called “chilling effects,” they cause people to self censor when it comes to socially controversial positions. Historically, this would include womens suffrage, black rights, gay rights, various religious positions… It’s not okay to be tracked so thoroughly that people stop feeling they can explore controversy online
- dcow 4y agoOn top of that: anonymity should not be required to explore controversy at all. That’s the chilling effect. The issue is that as a society we have failed royally to internalize tolerating freedom of expression. Instead we choose to censor and silence people who wish to explore controversy even though we have laws in place that protect one’s freedom to express themselves however they desire without damaging recourse to their life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness. Anonymity is certainly a tool that can be used in dire situations when there are real credible threats and the stakes are high. However it takes a certain type of courage to express oneself freely which would be really nice to see in the majority of all other situations. Instead of exploring controversy anonymously, we should aim as a society to explore it normally and simply build up the intellectual maturity and capacity to tolerate controversy like adults and not children…
- dcow 4y agoIn short, I don't want to live in a society where everyone is anonymous. That doesn't sound very social at all and doesn't work at scale. I want to live in a society where I can build strong respectful adult relationships with people and not immediately judge, shun, and twitter mob someone who says they don't 100% agree with my lifestyle. Tolerating differences in viewpoints and lifestyles is true diversity. Diversity is not finding people with different physical features who all actually think the same and putting them on a magazine cover or in the same office together.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y ago> In short, I don't want to live in a society where everyone is anonymous. You wear a name tag to the pub, or supermarket?
- BrainVirus 4y ago
- iratewizard 4y agoLuckily for you, you're not the only Chris Marshall in NY. I personally know a physicist with the same name in the same state.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI ran into one, at a FlashPix conference (dating myself -no one else will), last century. He worked for Kodak, at that time. I used to have his card, with his smiling mug on it (Kodak used to have picture business cards). One advantage of having a fairly old and robust online (and offline) ID, is that it actually makes it harder for people to assume your ID, as there is so much "prior art," pointing to your real persona. It makes it fairly easy to short-circuit hijacks. Of course, it all becomes problematic, if I decide to go around pissing everyone off, or poking bears. But, if I piss off people that have the willingness and ability to do me harm, they'll find me, anyway. I don't choose to live a life in a shack in the woods, typing manifestos. I want to be a part of Society, and reap the benefits of participation. It also helps me to help others. A lot of my life, these days, is around helping others. Hard to do, if I'm hiding in a dumpster.
- mst 4y agoThe only hijack attempt I've ever experienced was some card fraudsters I pissed off creating a fake paedophile blog under my full name (and then spamming a large chunk of IRC with links to it for a year or so). Happily for me everybody I've seen comment on it laughed it off as "I wonder what happened to make them that angry but I'm sure they deserved it" - with a few exceptions of people I've previously pissed off who basically said "nah, he's an asshole moderator but there's no way he's a paedo". And, well, sometimes I -am- an asshole, and some of those times I deeply regret. But reputation can be useful in general.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- birdyrooster 4y agoYeah for you and right now, it’s okay. Eventually something will happen to you where you will reevaluate your risk tolerance.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI’ve already been through plenty (long, sad story. Get your hanky). I don’t foresee changing my stance, for myself. However, I’ve been around long enough to know that the way I see (and do) things does not apply to others. I would not prescribe my way to others. I’m merely recounting my lived experience, and the personal decisions that I made, based on them.
- donkeyd 4y agoAnonymity is a broad term though. I would be incredibly surprised (and fascinated) if anyone on HN can find my true identity from my account, even with an e-mail address in my profile. I also know that Google (and therefore powerful bad actors or law enforcement) can easily figure it out, since I've logged in to this e-mail address from the same devices as my private e-mail address. If I'd need full privacy, I'd have to add many more levels of security in my daily life that I don't find necessary. I just don't want people (or a SWAT team) to show up at my door because I triggered someone on the internet. That's why I post from multiple different accounts on different platforms. Though, I'm sure, in the future some form of AI will be able to link them all based on writing style and similarity of content of my posts. Guess I'll have to find another way to remain somewhat anonymous then.