4 ms·
The article completely fails to mention that religious people tend to believe that humans have a "soul" and animals don't, which seems to me to be a massive ove
by lapcat 4y ago
The article completely fails to mention that religious people tend to believe that humans have a "soul" and animals don't, which seems to me to be a massive oversight. Of course Dawkins doesn't believe in the soul, but it's hard to see how his arguments are going to move anyone who does believe.
The other problem with the argument is that, on the other side, many vegans believe that killing animals for food is wrong.
- k__ 4y agoWhat are the properties of a soul? How does it work with twins from one egg? Does it split?
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoThe primary property of a soul is its soulfulness. An egg split into twins because it had too much soulfulness for one person.
- 9991 4y agoBy that logic, chimeras and gingers have too little soulfulness?
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoYes to the chimera question, not sure about gingers.
- alexvoda 4y agoIs the measurement unit for that metric or otherwise?
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoPretty sure its an imperial unit.
- hotpotamus 4y agoAnd furthermore is the soul eternal? If the soul is present at conception and then the corporeal body is aborted, is the soul re-used in another child, or does it go to eternal judgement directly? How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?
- Beltalowda 4y agoI think the main argument that Dawkins wanted to make is that many pro-choice arguments are completely missing the point and don't engage with the pro-life arguments at all, rather than try to engage with all pro-life arguments, and do a full exploration of them.
- lapcat 4y ago> I think the main argument that Dawkins wanted to make is that many pro-choice arguments are completely missing the point and don't engage with the pro-life arguments at all I agree, but I think Dawkins fell prey to the exact same problem. He ignored the religion behind the pro-life movement and tried to break it down into biological terms. Is that really engaging?
- Beltalowda 4y agoThe intended audience for this article is pro-choice people, not the pro-life people. It's trying to start a "strategy discussion" on how to better enact certain goals. In short, he's not trying to convince any pro-lifer of anything here, he's trying to convince pro-choice people to use better arguments. And in general, I actually avoid the "soul argument" as well, even when engaging with pro-life people. First, I know several pro-life people who are not religious or even atheists, secondly I have no good arguments to counter a faith-based belief, and thirdly I think that for many religious pro-life people it's not even that important of an argument (for example many – though not all – pro-life advocates will allow room for nuance in cases of medical issues or rape).
- sparrish 4y agoHe knows that as an evolutionary atheist, he has no attack against the "soul" or "man is made in the image of God" argument that would be persuasive to a believer so he avoids it.
- ykevinator2 4y ago