3 ms·
The author makes two points: 1. The vast majority of the money is made by blockbusters. 2. Producers outside of blockbusters aren't making a living. 1 is
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
The author makes two points: 1. The vast majority of the money is made by blockbusters. 2. Producers outside of blockbusters aren't making a living.
1 is true but misleading. Anecdotally, I believe 2 is wrong.
"The Long Tail" doesn't disagree with point #1. The fat head is where the most of the money is. That's not new or controversial. IIRC, the Long Tail says that it's now possible to exploit the long tail. It's still the tail, though. You're not going to be making rock star money, but at least you can now put food on your table. I know several musicians who pawned their instruments in the 90s to be able to eat. The musicians I know in the 2020s certainly aren't thriving, but they're not pawning instruments.
And #2 is just plain wrong. Tons of niche content creators have turned professional in the last few years. They're not making rock star cash, but they've quit their day job.
The ones who are coming closest to rock star cash are the video producers. This used to be a brutal field. You'd need to scrape together 7 figures to make a movie, do the indie field circuit, et cetera. Now all you need is an iPhone and a YouTube or TikTok account, perhaps combined with Patreon. Netflix isn't where you find the long tail, YouTube and TikTok are. And now there are YouTube channels much more professional than your local TV stations.
For music, 99% of musicians used to make their living teaching, and they still do. The money they get sporadically playing in small venues is just bonus money. But they all have Patreon's now too. It's not enough to let them stop teaching, but the regular income makes a huge difference compared to the very irregular income from gigs.
AFAICT writers have always had a long tail. If you could sell a few thousand books, you could find a publisher. You wouldn't get any promotion or shelf space at that volume nor enough money to quit your day job, but...
These days there are tons of writers who have quit their day job and subsist on web fiction + Patreon + Kindle Unlimited.
- ghaff 4y agoIt's an interesting question what the long tail looks like financially for individual creators both in absolute numbers and on a percentage basis relative to 25 years ago. I suspect in absolute numbers there is more money going to long tail creators just because there is so much more opportunity to reach a non-geographically-bound audience. On the other hand, the barriers to entry have essentially collapsed in many cases which has, among other things, led to a veritable flood of content--and many of the often fairly casual creators don't even have a particular interest in, at least directly, monetizing. If you're a long tail would be professional, you have more channels to a potentially paying audience today that doesn't necessarily involve getting picked by a gatekeeper. But you're also now competing with a huge number of enthusiastic amateurs, who don't care about the money, who would never have bothered if they had to get through a gatekeeper.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoMost novelists are, and have always been, amateurs and many of those are fairly indifferent to payment. And the vast majority of musicians are amateurs who play for fun, and always has been.