3 ms·
There is a problem because some licenses require attribution, but ignoring that... You can make a model that is trained only with BSD and MIT code, and IIRC/II
by gus_massa 4y ago
There is a problem because some licenses require attribution, but ignoring that...
You can make a model that is trained only with BSD and MIT code, and IIRC/IIUC the result can be used with any license, including proprietary code.
You can make a second model that is trained only with BSD, MIT and GPL2 code (and perhaps GPL2+), and IIRC/IIUC the result can be only with GPL2 code.
You can make a third model that is trained only with BSD, MIT and GPL2+ and GPL3 code, and IIRC/IIUC the result can be only with GPL3 code.
AGPL, Apache, WTFPL, ... Just add them to the correct model or create a new model for them.
- q-big 4y ago> You can make a model that is trained only with BSD and MIT code, and IIRC/IIUC the result can be used with any license, including proprietary code. BSD and MIT license still require attribution of the used source code (there exists a MIT No Attribution License, though: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=MIT_License&oldid=1091025780#MIT_No_Attribution_License https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=MIT_License&oldid...).
- wolpoli 4y agoGreat. Now developers will need to check license compatibility before picking the copilot model. In reality through, we'll all just end up using the MIT No Attribution License copilot.
- q-big 4y agoDevelopers already have to check license compatibility. If copilot implemented such a feature, this would just represent the status quo.
- xigoi 4y ago> In reality through, we'll all just end up using the MIT No Attribution License copilot. Great, so GPL code would be left alone. I don't see how that's a bad thing.
- mbreese 4y ago> BSD and MIT license still require attribution of the used source code Which in this scenario could be accomplished by starting that “this software contains algorithmically generated code that was trained using MIT derived code from X, Y, and Z. This attribution list would be very long, but it could be done. I think the interesting thing here would be to compare the generated code with the original training data after the fact. If the generated code does not already exist (with some degree of similarity), then it would be okay to use. Otherwise, if it did already exist, you’d then need to attribute the authors of the chunk of code — which you’d now know. I’m not discounting the hurdles involved, but there might be ways to overcome them.
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoWhats to stop them from just making a huge attribution page with every possible instance and a vague statement like "the following may or may not have been incorporated in part or in whole" ?
- jacobolus 4y agoThey’d be gambling that such a crummy attribution would hold up in court. Generally judges aren’t too amused by people’s efforts to find wacky loopholes that make a mockery of the law. On the other hand, open source licenses haven’t been tested thoroughly in court, so maybe the result would be to throw out such attribution requirements entirely. The main relevant case to date is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobsen_v._Katzer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobsen_v._Katzer
- winety 4y ago> There is a problem because some licenses require attribution, but ignoring that... Surely the solution would be to give credit to every author from the training corpus. I am looking forward to the 10 000 lines of copyrights in every header. :P If Microsoft had trained it on its own code, there would be no such problems. Surely a company as large as Microsoft has produced enough code over the years to create a large enough training dataset.
- ShamelessC 4y ago> If Microsoft had trained it on its own code, there would be no such problems. I keep seeing this sentiment from the GPL/"laundering" side of the debate. Believe me, Microsoft wouldn't have released this thing (after what, 6 months of beta testing?) if they thought they had any "problems" at all. I'm not saying I don't sort of agree with you, but is there no room for what's actually _likely_ to happen in this debate? Because as best as I can tell, they aren't going to see any real legal issues from this. (There's also an option to remove generations that result in a collision with actual GitHub code, just fyi) I feel like when the singularity happens HN is going to be flooded with programmers mad that they got automated away despite it very much being one of the primary goals of computer science and software engineering. This stuff is a kind of just a fact of life now. Salesforce trained models (on GitHub) competitive with copilot without needing to own GitHub. I would spend less time worrying about how to lawyer up and more time figuring out how you're going to adapt to these new tools. That's the gig.
- iostream24 4y agoAs you mentioned “WHEN the singularity happens” as an article of religious faith, followed by a vast leap of faith in proposing no-code tools taking over programming, I’m afraid that you adapting to the reality on the ground will be the difficult part here, rather than the lack of adaptation by programming writ large. Do you work in marketing? Do you program?
- ShamelessC 4y agoI'm only somewhat certain that the singularity is inevitable (and obviously my predictions aren't worth betting on anyways) - sorry for using poetic language. I'm a machine learning engineer, amateur researcher and open source contributor. Before that I was a software engineer for 8 years.