3 ms·
You say, "There's nothing inherently wrong with human-in-the-loop." But humans have reaction times around 500 milliseconds; in the best cases, around 200 milli
by kragen 4y ago
You say, "There's nothing inherently wrong with human-in-the-loop." But humans have reaction times around 500 milliseconds; in the best cases, around 200 milliseconds. I routinely write software with worst-case reaction times around 0.001 milliseconds, or 1 millisecond for more complex stimuli. If a force of drones with humans in the loop fights a force of drones without humans in the loop, absent colossal blunders, the latter will win, and it won't even be close.
Imagine you get into a fistfight with a guy. He's bigger than you, he's got a loaded 9-millimeter pistol, and he's a good marksman. But his reaction time is 200 times yours --- say, about 50 seconds, if you're a regular human. That is, all his reactions are reacting to what you did 50 seconds ago, at best. Who do you think is going to win? Unless he's inside a tank and you're outside, you will. Even in that case, I think you've got a fighting chance.
You argue that it's good for armies to "have skin in the game" in the sense of being vulnerable to jail or financial ruin. And, from a moral point of view, it probably is good: armies that are exposed to retaliation will generally be less willing to do things that provoke retaliation, many of which are immoral. However, the things that provoke retaliation are also the things that win wars. Making your army more vulnerable may reduce war crimes, but it is not a recipe for victory.
The logic of warfare is inimical to our survival as a species, which is why our best and brightest have been calling for a pacifist world order since even before World War II. Nuclear warfare were a nice early warning, but they're children's toys compared to precision-guided munitions backed up by pervasive surveillance.
- kragen 4y agoCorrection: 500 times your reaction time would be about 40 seconds if your reaction time is 200 ms.