3 ms·
The House Financial Services Committee said that at the time of the Reddit rally, Robinhood was not connected to any exchanges, and of the six market makers Rob
by Animats 4y ago
The House Financial Services Committee said that at the time of the Reddit rally, Robinhood was not connected to any exchanges, and of the six market makers Robinhood routed all its customers' orders to, nearly all were unable to execute trades in certain meme stocks due to the market stress.
Had Robinhood had actual exchange connections, would they have been able to execute the trades? If the exchange can match a buyer and a seller, you don't need a "market maker". Market makers provide liquidity in infrequently traded assets. For frequently traded assets, you don't need market makers, just matching of buyers and sellers.
- ueieishdijw 4y ago
- astrange 4y agoThey wouldn’t be able to without charging fees; retail orders are too small to handle at the exchange, and Robinhood doesn’t AFAIK have their own internalizer.
- dchftcs 4y agoThe matching of buyers and sellers is a hard problem. When there's a limit order book, meaning bid and ask resting orders on NYSE, by definition the buyers and sells can't be matched. To "match buyers and sellers", one needs to buy from someone at time T, and hope to sell to someone else at time >T, during which time the market could have gone up or down. It's a risk-taking processes and a problem that's underappreciated by those who never actually tried to look at the basics of how an exchange works. Also the best bid and offers on exchanges are often already market makers. To say you "don't need" market makers because of liquidity is a bit circular.